4 ms·
There is a strong negative correlation observed in all cultures of intelligence and happiness. The more intelligent you are the less likely you are to be happy
by dijit 5y ago
There is a strong negative correlation observed in all cultures of intelligence and happiness.
The more intelligent you are the less likely you are to be happy.
This is most extremely observed in the case of the 14 year old child prodigy who committed suicide despite no pressure from his parents to succeed: https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/19/us/one-shot-ends-the-life-of-a-prodigy-who-appeared-to-be-ordinary.html https://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/19/us/one-shot-ends-the-life...
- jcal93 5y agoI find this really interesting, and definitely sad. I wonder if it's because as people become more educated, they understand (or at least perceive) that their individual life is insignificant when contrasted against the great big universe of things and beings, and this results in deep and profound unhappiness.
- tomc1985 5y agoI think it is more that one has the ability to see "the man behind the curtain", and at how badly the deck is stacked against you for most things. Seeing and hearing the lies promulgated absolutely everywhere and knowing they are so where others do not.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWhat I don’t get is what keeps people around who have “seen the man behind the curtain”, and know enough to suffer from knowing.
- sidlls 5y agoIt's (also) more mundane than that. Think about those minor annoyances one has with their partner in a relationship (friendship, romantic, doesn't matter--everyone has something they could pick nits about in their friends, spouses, etc.). Now consider them to be multiplied and magnified by virtue of being literally one or more steps ahead, so to speak, in thinking about...anything. From an approach to doing chores, to planning recreational activities, to supposedly "higher minded" things (e.g. politics, philosophy, whatever), you name it: the smarter one is, the more likely there is friction in these everyday interactions by virtue of the fact that more and more of one's peers is simply not able to keep up as it were. Not to mention the same is true of other less mundane issues (politics, finance, etc.).
- NeuNeurosis 5y agoWow well said. I think this is the real core of the issue. I have experienced this since I can remember and people would get mad at me as a child for explaining how something worked or how to look at something from a different perspective. I struggle with sharing my understanding about anything due to the depth of explaining I have to do for people to understand why I arrived at my conclusion. One thing I have found helps as I get older is to let go of the feeling of importance of things going a certain way. I can now live with small mistakes and misunderstandings way better than when I was young.
- MonaroVXR 5y agoI have the complete opposite experience right now and it's killing me. Even with dating. Gotta explain why I do this or that. Because bit it's contradictory in their eyes Any advice?
- NeuNeurosis 5y agoInteresting, without context its pretty difficult to offer advice. From your comment, and I'm reaching here, you might not have a great awareness of how your actions/choices are perceived by others before you make them. You seem to in hindsight, which is great. Also it could be the stage of life you are in where the people you are surrounded by are still exploring options of how to live and are curious when they see someone make choices outside their realm or expectation. In either case it comes down to how much you want them to understand your what and why. I have really tried hard at accepting that most others are not going to see why I make my choices so what is the point of explaining any of them. This is all conditional on who it is and how much I love them but it is a constant in my thought process. Letting go of the need for people to understand your motivations is liberating, when you can achieve it. :) I hope this helps.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 5y agoNow, sure, you might attribute that to being so smart. But graduating from high school at 10 would totally stunt your social development. His parents reject that idea but I am less than persuaded.
- bruce343434 5y agoHow can you possibly connect to your peers when you have forgotten more than they will ever know? They have nothing to offer you. Every interaction predictable and boring. It must be supremely lonely being the odd one out.
- emodendroket 5y agoI will tell you what. He probably would have liked to have a girlfriend more than to hang around a bunch of kids in their early twenties treating him like their baby brother, no matter how smart he was. It seems like a very narrow notion of the value of relationships with others if you think that any interaction where you’re not being intellectually challenged is worthless.
- bruce343434 5y agoI can tell you form experience having a significant other with a sufficient "gap" gets very demoralizing and frustrating. That, or I just can't appreciate what I have.
- emodendroket 5y agoThat can be frustrating, but the kind of isolation you'd get being a young kid in a college milieu would be much worse. The story goes that Nick the Greek introduced Albert Einstein to his gambling buddies as "Little Al from Princeton," who "controls a lot of the action around Jersey." I've always aspired to be able to move between worlds with that kind of grace.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- e1g 5y agoI’ve seen studies [1][2] showing positive relationships between happiness and intelligence. Do you have a source saying the correlation is negative? [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22998852/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22998852/ [2] https://www.inderscienceonline.com/doi/abs/10.1504/IJHD.2012.050808 https://www.inderscienceonline.com/doi/abs/10.1504/IJHD.2012...
- dlsa 5y agoNo pressure? There's the pressure right there in that word prodigy. That's enough pressure. Everything the kid does is an example of what a prodigy does. Oh the prodigy is writing a story! Must be great! The prodigy is playing sport! He'll be an expert for sure! No? Well then he's not such a prodigy after all! Haha the prodigy tripped over that step! Can't even walk! I can easily see all this creating enough pressure to crush someone sooner rather than later. Its a form of perfectionism. But not so much from aiming at perfection itself but having it expected and compelled upon you. People will want to use you if you do well and distance themselves the moment things get tough. The weight of the mind games around that must be horrendous. Expectations would attach like mosquitoes. The price of fame. Even in a micro-version its annoying and draining. Its probably also why very famous people all solve this with giant little-worlds they create called mansions. A world within a world. Its the luxury of having enough space so you can be a special sort of anonymous in that vast space again.
- booboofixer 5y agoI have nothing to add to this so I'm sorry for commenting if i shouldn't. But thank you for writing this because i felt a little insane looking at the world around me and coming to some of the same conclusions as you have arrived at, that result from treating people a certain way. I'm not sure why most other people don't seem to get this.
- Trasmatta 5y agoHah, joke's on you! I'm dumb AND unhappy.
- erikbye 5y agoNo surprise there. Both my cat and dog seem happier than me, and I hope they are less intelligent.
- radu_floricica 5y agoThat's a myth. Intelligence is correlated with quite a lot of things which promote happiness. There are already sources in the thread, so I'll just mention a couple factors: education/work/money, and late marriage/kids. Believe it or not, but not living close to minimum wage and having children only when married and you can afford them are both huge factors of a happy life. Huge. And both are very correlated with intelligence. Now, why is this myth so widespread? Tbh, I don't really know. I can guess at availability heuristic - smart people see mostly themselves and smart people around them, see that the happiness level isn't that great, especially when young, imagine everybody else is happier so it's a reasonable conclusion that being smart is bad. The problems with this logic are that less smart/poorer people have it a lot worse, but they don't have contact with them. And also that extra education will indeed delay your earning years somewhat, so being young, not-yet-earning and smart does feel pretty bad.