3 ms·
> "why fight the centralization effort? It is better to take control of it than let it run wild." Would you also say this about democracy? Why not to become a
by fsflover 5y ago
> "why fight the centralization effort? It is better to take control of it than let it run wild."
Would you also say this about democracy? Why not to become a dictator yourself and ride this wave?
- godelski 5y agoI think you're giving my comment an unfair characterization. I'd appreciate it if we discussed in good faith with one another. If you read carefully I talk about trying to maximize negative rights and a balance. The political equivalent is saying that I like democracy but a pure democracy is chaos. This does not mean I'm remotely in favor of autocracy. There's a spectrum here and it isn't a dichotomy.
- fsflover 5y agoThere is no bad faith in my comment, just trying to understand your argument better. Thanks for the explanation.
- Barrin92 5y agoOf course you can say it about democracy. The basis for democracy as we know it is the modern nation state, a fundamentally centralized institution. Democracy without a high degree of centralization tends to decay. Even the dictator in its original sense as an institution acts on behalf of the people, appointed during times of exception. (many presidents in presidential republics today actually have comparable emergency powers). So centralization is not an insult to democracy at all. Decentralization aligns if you want to make a political analogy, much closer with democracy's predecessor, feudal society in which sovereign fiefdoms compete with each other. (It's not surprising that this is also a popular form of organization among libertarian decentralization advocates).
- fsflover 5y ago> Democracy without a high degree of centralization tends to decay. AFAIK Switzerland would be a good counter-example to your words.