4 ms·
Why bother? It’s not like silicon is some rare element that needs to be mined in distant, war-torn countries. It’s literally sand! The hard part is purifying
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Why bother? It’s not like silicon is some rare element that needs to be mined in distant, war-torn countries.
It’s literally sand!
The hard part is purifying it. Starting from already manufactured electronics seems like an uphill battle because the silicon is already contaminated with precisely those elements that need to be removed from it to control its electronic behaviour!
- teruakohatu 5y agoThe world is producing vast quantities of solar panels, which will eventually end up in landfills. What they are doing is essentially just what say: removing sand from panels and separating the contaminants which can then be dealt with separately.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _Microft 5y agoThe Fraunhofer Society is a research organization (tending towards the applied/engineering end of the spectrum), so the answer might be simply "because they can?". Beside that: if they can work out the economics of the process, why not? Waste disposal costs money which might shift the economics in their favour (as people would have to pay someone for disposal anyways, so they could as well pay the people who make new panels from old ones).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andrewxdiamond 5y agoWe as a society cannot keep disposing of things forever. We need to be making as many production streams cyclical as possible, or we will eventually run out of the easy-to-aquire resources
- slavik81 5y agoThe earth's crust is 60% silicon dioxide. I don't understand how we could possibly run out. I mean, I get the value in recycling the panels. It's presumably easier to start with almost pure material than 60% pure. Still, if it were cheaper to start with a chunk of feldspar than an old panel, I don't think we'd have to worry about the lack of virgin materials.
- jiggawatts 5y agoThis is precisely my point. So many people automatically assume that everything is scarce and recycling is automatically “good”. Chances are that the process described in the article uses more resources and produces more pollution than simply starting from sand.
- andrewxdiamond 5y agoThis comparison is incomplete without thinking about what happens to the disposed-of panels. Panels in landfills are pollution as much as anything else
- jiggawatts 5y agoSolar panels are glass and silicon. Just crush them an mix them into concrete…
- pfdietz 5y agoIt's also not clear if recycling the silicon in PV cells into new PV cells is the best way to recycle it. The world also uses silicon in silicon steels and in the manufacture of silicones. As PV is further scaled up these may not be large enough markets, granted.
- kube-system 5y agoThe air is 21% oxygen and hospitals were running out of oxygen in some places during the COVID pandemic. Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe, and yet, the supply of hydrogen is one of the biggest hurdles to the adoption of hydrogen cars. Just because a resource exists nearby doesn't necessarily mean it can be harnessed economically or within the other constraints that the world and society imposes on us. Silica mines are mostly (all?) surface mines, we don't explore anywhere into the crust to get it now because it isn't economical to do so. "Running out" of supply doesn't necessarily mean that the element doesn't exist, it could mean that it is inaccessible for other reasons -- like it could be the beach in front of someone's house, or a protected park.
- hedora 5y agoSand mining causes significant environmental damage, and there's a shortage of sand from the less-delicate sources. Also, I imagine it takes a lot of energy to go from "we found this on the beach" to "this is ultrapure silicon for use in solar cells". We have essentially unlimited aluminum too. The purpose of recycled cans is saving energy and reducing pollution from extraction. I do wonder whether it's easier to start with glass from beverage bottles than from solar panels though.
- pfdietz 5y agoSilicon is purified by conversion to trichlorosilane, followed by distillation. One doesn't need extremely pure silica as the input. An intermediate step for this is reduction of silica to metallurgical silicon which is not anywhere close to semiconductor grade (it's about 98% pure). Where one DOES want pure silica is in making the crucibles where silicon is melted. There's a particular mine in North Carolina (Spruce Pine) where this very pure silica is mined. We could make artificial pure silica, but this stuff is cheaper.
- pengaru 5y ago> there's a shortage of sand from the less-delicate sources I thought the only sand shortage to speak of was the specific type required for making concrete, because wind-blown sand is too rounded off for producing strong concrete. So those endless dunes of wind-blown sand everyone envisions aren't applicable. But when you intend to melt the sand I presume there's an abundant supply.
- orev 5y agoAll sand is not equal, and it is slowly becoming more scarce. There are already sand mafias popping up due to certain types of sand (used in construction) becoming hard to find. There are black markets, and shady practices already happening. Maybe the sand needed for semiconductors doesn’t fall into this category yet (I don’t know, maybe it does), but it doesn’t hurt to start thinking about it.
- scotty79 5y agoWe are already running out of one type if sand mostly due to the amount of concrete we make.
- toss1 5y agoYour answer is in your penultimate sentence ("The hard part is purifying it.") and at the end of the article. >>The German scientists said the cells were fabricated only with wafers relying on recycled silicon and that no commercial ultrapure silicon was added during the manufacturing process. >>The performance of the first trial PERC cells was tested and the devices were found to achieve a power conversion efficiency of 19.7%. “This is below the efficiency of today’s premium PERC solar cells, which have an efficiency of around 22.2 percent, but it is certainly above that of the solar cells in the old, discarded modules,”
- friedturkey 5y agoYeah, just like fresh water and trees are everywhere, so why bother conserving them. Environmental destruction is a huge problem and usable sand is a limited resource and often in delicate environments. It’s not the 19th century anymore—people today are more aware that taking resources has consequences.
- lovemenot 5y agoThere's a widely-held belief that the energy cost of PV production is largely outweighed the benefits from PV usage. This may have been somewhat more true in the past, but I believe the energy payback period is now less than 24 months, on a PV device that should last over 20 years. We must pay attention to weighing up the relative costs to environmental destruction by one cause (production and disposal of PV) against its most common alternative (continued fossil fuel usage).
- rtpg 5y agoNobody is arguing that the material usage from non-recycled goods is a big enough issue to stop selling solar panels. But maybe this technique makes the payback go from 24 months to 22 months. Maybe even just to 23.5 months! It’s still progress!
- lovemenot 5y ago>> Nobody is arguing ... Nobody here is arguing that. FUD is a real thing. Be careful not give them ammunition.
- friedturkey 5y agoWhat? You somehow implied that people hate renewable energy when the only thing is people are saying that in addition to that, recycling is good. FUD isn't even an applicable term.
- TrainedMonkey 5y agoBecause we are increasing solar panel production on an exponential curve. This is amazing for sustainable energy, however 30 years from now amount of trashed solar panels will be increasing on an exponential curve. Recycling them into more solar panels sounds like an amazing solution.