25 ms·
He wasn't polluting the Internet any more than Google are. He was running a directory of companies. Having a directory organized for a specific industry can be
by petercooper 18y ago
He wasn't polluting the Internet any more than Google are. He was running a directory of companies. Having a directory organized for a specific industry can be extremely useful, compared to the myriad of results you'd get on Google.
If his site had no "value" then how was it creating $155k/mo of profit? Out of thin air? By browsers forced at gunpoint to click on ads? It had value.
- lacker 18y agoTake a look at the site yourself and ask if this is the sort of page you want to end up on. http://timepieces.sourcetool.com/index.php?s=0&l=2&code=5410 http://timepieces.sourcetool.com/index.php?s=0&l=2&c... Looks like a spam directory to me.
- petercooper 18y agoI wouldn't, but I'm not the target market for this sort of thing. I'm defending the business model, not the individual site.
- wastedbrains 18y agoThe model of buying cheap ads and then having pages with nearly no content filled with many more higher paid ads? When I ran a site that had adwords I hated directories like this they would fill up all the ads on my site and no one would click them nor would anyone be happy if they did. It was a constant battle of banning those domains from ads I would allow on my site.
- petercooper 18y ago> The model of buying cheap ads and then having pages with nearly no content filled with many more higher paid ads? Why not? Google does something similar itself with its "link units" where you click through to a new page with a whole group of ads. Advertising is not immoral (usually), illegal (usually), or some sort of thing to wipe out. Buying cheap and selling high is how the world works - whether you're selling labor, bricks, commodities, or, yes, advertising. Would you be raising similar objections if, say, the Yellow Pages advertised with "Find all Builders in YourTown, FL", and it then went to a page with a (paid) list of all the builders in said town? If so, why? It'd be useful and a good demonstration of arbitrage.
- peakok 18y agoHave you read the article ? So what do you think of http://www.business.com http://www.business.com ? A privileged Google partner wich does the same thing but is tolerated. What's the difference ? Why is this one okay but not sourcetool ? Isn't there something under the rug ? Why is the Google policy so arbitrary ? That's the point of the article.
- emmett 18y agoIt seems like you're making the argument that any company that turns a profit must by definition be creating value. But it's possible to turn a profit by all kinds of destructive means (fraud, externalized costs, etc.) In particular in this case, the issue is not that the ads had 0 value themselves. Obviously, as you point out, his sites had some value. However, that value is clearly less than that of actually relevant search results (or so Google, the worlds foremost authority on search results, believes). Therefore the profit comes from externalizing the costs, rather than from value creation.
- tomsaffell 18y agoIt's certainly true that 'profit' does-not-infer 'value'. But nonetheless, I think they are adding value. Here's why i think that: A. Customer utility (for a subset of customers) is higher for search results presented in the style of Sourcetool than in the style of Google. (i.e. Google isn't all things to all men - no shame in that). B. Those customers do not know about Sourcetool, but do know about Google. (market inefficiency = imperfect knowledge) So assuming this customer ultimately wants sourcetool style results, there are three steps to be taken: 0. Customers goes to www.google.com 1. Google refers them to Sourcetool 2. Source tool provides the desired services (even if that includes serving an ad) In this scenario, both Google and Sourcetool should capture the value associated with giving the customer what they want - they both played a part. I dont know if both parties are capturing value, but its certainly true that they both could. Google gets paid by the advertiser who places the ad served by AdSense, so even if Google's two transactions with Sourcetool are net negative, Google may well be coming out net positive with the inclusion of the transaction of the AdSense advertiser. Seems to me that Google should merely be setting is rev-sharing terms with Sourcetool to ensure that both parties capture value. tom saffell
- emmett 18y agoI see what you mean about it creating value, and I certainly agree that they are making the market for those ads slightly more efficient. However, it's still the broken window fallacy. Because the user clicked on that link in the search results, they didn't click on some other probably more relevant link. So on the balance, the total value created goes down.