2 ms·
With all due respect to the core Emacs team (which is a substantial amount) being steeped in Emacs Lisp traditions is hardly an advantage. ELisp is a weaker lan
by roenxi 5y ago
With all due respect to the core Emacs team (which is a substantial amount) being steeped in Emacs Lisp traditions is hardly an advantage. ELisp is a weaker language that has only managed to hold on because it is embedded in Emacs by default.
It is quite telling that Emacs is the only place that ELisp gets used as a style. Compare that to a lisp like Clojure where people love implementing Clojure in strange new places. Or Common Lisp which has more than 10 major implementations (and one in Emacs, naturally). Nobody chooses to use ELisp without serious prompting.
Someone writing bad ELisp doesn't say much about the quality of a package or how useful it will be.
- BeetleB 5y ago> Someone writing bad ELisp doesn't say much about the quality of a package or how useful it will be. If they're writing it on Emacs, then it is. I mean, if you have an app running on the JVM, and the developers are poor at Java, you kind of would expect issues.
- roenxi 5y agoI doubt it. Bad code takes longer to write, understand and is less maintainable. But it is rare that those are the issues that make or break an OSS project. Typically the maintainer's goals and motivation counts for much more. And besides "good code" in ELisp is a bit of a funny one. Lexical scoping is a relative innovation.
- ParetoOptimal 5y ago> being steeped in Emacs Lisp traditions is hardly an advantage. I used to think this, but sometimes this determines how deeply your package integrates into emacs. The obvious example here being seamless tramp support. IIRC this is demonstrated in this very interesting blog post[0] about debugging why opening a remote file is slow in the projectile package, likely didn't exist in the project.el alternative that is more steeped in those traditions. 0: https://www.murilopereira.com/how-to-open-a-file-in-emacs/ https://www.murilopereira.com/how-to-open-a-file-in-emacs/