3 ms·
In fact, the heating is produced by the gas going through a shock. This isn't heating by compression. Adiabatic compression is a reversible process; going th
by pfdietz 5y ago
In fact, the heating is produced by the gas going through a shock. This isn't heating by compression. Adiabatic compression is a reversible process; going through a shock is irreversible. Entropy is generated at the shock.
In more detail: at the shock, the conditions of the gas change over a distance on the order of a mean free path. This means that, locally, the gas is out of thermodynamic equilibrium, with fast molecules running into slow ones. The extremely high gradient of gas conditions causes extremely rapid relaxation to an equilibrium state, a process that very rapidly produces entropy.
As Mach number increases, the density jump across the shock approaches an asymptotic limit, but the heating increases without bound.
- WalterBright 5y agoAs you compress a gas, its temperature rises. The air at the leading edge of the machine is static, meaning its compressed. (This is how pitot tubes measure airspeed - they are simply pressure sensors.) The temperature rise from the compression matches what one predicts from PV=NkT A shock wave is unnecessary. It happens with subsonic flow, too. In fact, it's how refrigerators work. (In ME101 Fluid Mechanics, the Prof showed how a re-entering satellite would melt even if the atmosphere was a frictionless gas.)
- pfdietz 5y ago> The temperature rise from the compression matches what one predicts from PV=NkT That's a null statement, since that holds for any (ideal) gas regardless of how it got into its current state. If you mean, the temperature rise is the same as if it were adiabatically compressed to the density or pressure the gas has after the shock, then that is not true.
- WalterBright 5y agoIf you compress a gas, even an ideal frictionless gas, its temperature rises. Like I said, that's how refrigerators work. As for compression in flight, that's how pitot tubes measure airspeed. It has nothing to do with friction. On a wing, the temperature rise is highest at the static point on the leading edge, where there is no motion of the air. The temperature declines from there back as the airflow speeds up. If friction was the source of the heat, you'd expect the temperature to be the lowest at the static point, and would increase towards the trailing edge. BTW, how a diesel engine works is by compressing the air/fuel mixture until it heats up enough to ignite. A gas engine will sometimes "diesel" on after the ignition is turned off.
- ncmncm 5y agoYet, he has explained that this is not what happens, and why.
- pfdietz 5y ago> It has nothing to do with friction. The point I am making is that gas going through a shock is a fundamentally different process than a gas being adiabatically compressed. The former causes an increase in entropy; the latter ideally does not. While a shock isn't "friction" per se, like friction there is dissipation (and at entry speeds, quite a lot of dissipation).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoAre you sure? Consider: https://www.kimerius.com/app/download/5782475760/Calculation+of+surface+temperatures+in+steady+supersonic+flight.pdf https://www.kimerius.com/app/download/5782475760/Calculation... The paper does talk about heat from friction, but not at the stagnation point. It also talks about the heating of the surface being less than predicted by adiabatic compression, but that is the heating of the surface, not the heating of the air at the stagnation point.
- pfdietz 5y agoThat paper doesn't appear to have much to do with what we're talking about here. The transfer of heat to the vehicle from the hot shocked gas is another issue entirely. Anyway, it's foundational supersonic fluid physics that shocks create entropy. "Shocks are irreversible occurrences in supersonic flows (i.e. the entropy increases)." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shock_(fluid_dynamics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shock_(fluid_dynamics) Reentry with blunt bodies works because most of the dissipation is occurring at the shock, at some distance away from the vehicle, allowing most of the heat (that must be produced from the kinetic energy of the vehicle as it slows) to be carried away.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]