4 ms·
Absolutely not. As a simple, specific example, look at much of the art funded during the New Deal. But regardless, the measure of art isn't mass appeal - simila
by wolverine876 5y ago
Absolutely not. As a simple, specific example, look at much of the art funded during the New Deal. But regardless, the measure of art isn't mass appeal - similar to basic research, if the market funded it, we wouldn't have to. And that especially is a an issue when it's made: famously, many artists considered brilliant and very mainstream now were ignored and even reviled during life. Van Gogh didn't sell any paintings and was desperately poor. Stravinsky's Firebird caused riots.
> nobody would pay for out of their own pocket
People have such a strong reaction to it, such an urge to shut it down and leave no room for it to breath. That's actually a great start to art. The next step, however, is one few take (and fewer now it seems, when the wisdom of learning, knowledge, and being open-minded is politically rejected): Figure out what buttons it is pressing in you - not politics or whatever, but personal.
Almost all my favorite artwork really pissed me off when I first saw it. I learned it was a great signal that there was something there. And that is how art, in large part, more than any other thing in the world, helps us expand and grow.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Absolutely not. Compelling riposte! > art funded during the New Deal I've seen it. Not impressed. But heck, why don't you pay an artist to make some more for you? (We both know why <g>) > the measure of art isn't mass appeal Yeah, it is. Consider The Beatles, one of a looong list of examples. Though they didn't take off until they got a manager who understood marketing. They still weren't government funded. > Van Gogh was very bad at marketing. It turned out he didn't need government funding, either. And people are willing to personally pay for his art, though the prices they fetch means it's likely 99% virtue signalling.
- wolverine876 5y ago> why don't you pay an artist to make some more for you? I do, though not New Deal stuff in particular. I do pay for New Deal stuff as part of admission to museums, etc. > Consider The Beatles, one of a looong list of examples. Some art is popular, therefore all art must be popular? But I'll give you this: It's hard to come up with artists I never heard of who would have done better with government funding! But many well-known artists have benefitted from government funding. > <g> Wow, how long has it been since I've seen that one! I actually prefer those tags, but gave up.
- WalterBright 5y ago> I do pay for New Deal stuff as part of admission to museums If more people did, it wouldn't need government funding. Note that there are very many completely private museums in this country. Funded by the profits from the patrons. > Some art is popular, therefore all art must be popular? More like if people like art, they'll pay for it out of their own pockets. Art that was voluntarily paid for is all around you. There's no shortage of it. It's Big Business. Ever been to a movie? watched TV? bought a greeting card? seen an advertisement? bought a book? bought a house? bought a car? seen a garden? bought a lampshade?