3 ms·
> How much re-analysis of the same books over and over again can one do? Of course people will look for more and more extreme interpretations. In this case, pe
by wolverine876 5y ago
> How much re-analysis of the same books over and over again can one do? Of course people will look for more and more extreme interpretations.
In this case, people aren't analysing a molecule or RFC that exists in isolation from its context, and has limited content. It's not a problem to solve.
What they are analysing (not a great word IMHO - 'exploring', perhaps) is something heavily defined by its context - the book (or any art) is defined by its specific words, the world around it, and the person reading it. Its content is almost unlimited. Shakespeare's Julius Caesar means something much different in 2022 than in 1822, and something much different to you than to me than to Shakespeare than to George Bernard Shaw, and it there is so much to explore that you will never exhaust it, that shifts and changes as you travel through it.
It's not a problem to solve, but an entire world to explore. You don't run out of things to learn and say about the real world either.
- WalterBright 5y agoI once read an article by a literature professor analyzing Romeo + Juliet. At the end, he ruefully wrote that he would throw away all his analysis and knowledge of R+J to be able to read it again for the first time. I've read some analyses of Lord of the Rings. 98% just sounds like bullshit. Maybe JRR Tolkien just wanted to write a great story! and there's nothing more than that. Sure the story was influenced by his life experiences, like trench warfare. So what. I wish I could read it again for the first time :-)
- wolverine876 5y ago> I wish I could read it again for the first time :-) On one hand, there is nothing like it and I wish I had that unmatched emotional surge again, like a drug! On the other, I get much more out of LOTR now than the first time - a more sublime, but still incredible experience. > 98% just sounds like bullshit. Well that's circular, not evidence. 'I hate Chinese food, and 98% of it tastes terrible!' I wish I could find a way to say this without sounding like a condesceng a--, but I truly mean it genuinely: There is really something there, that I think (without presuming) you are missing - something incredible, life changing, intellect expanding to an incredible degree. It gives access to not just one idea, but the entire world of art in incredible technicolor that few see. If you decide to, maybe start with the Tolkien book below. Or I recommend the London Review of Books - the art and book reviews, not the political stuff - there are people with an unabashed, unhesitating passion for art. > Maybe JRR Tolkien just wanted to write a great story! Maybe it's a secret code of the Illuminati. The evidence says strongly otherwise: read On Fairy-stories by Tolkien [1], which is pretty short, absolutely stunning, and where he lays out much of his approach to art. Tolkien was also an all-time leading scholar of Old English (Anglo-Saxon) - arguably as important in that field as in fantasy fiction, a two-domain genius - and studied much of historic myth, which he read in their original languages; he studied and thought more about it than almost anyone who lived. And what is a 'great story'? Obviously, the LOTR is much more to people than a fun plot, as is all art. I don't think a great story exists that isn't more, or people wouldn't experience it as great. And like a great bottle of wine, many will miss out on much of it if they don't learn to understand it. If you limit your experience to a fun plot, that's your choice but your loss, like going to a musuem and never leaving the lobby. [1] Get the recent edition, ~2008 or 2014; the fantastic editor's notes explain many of Tolkien's references that come from deep in his knowledge of myth.
- fknorangesite 5y ago> Maybe JRR Tolkien just wanted to write a great story! Maybe, but an author is not somehow magically insulated from their own context and cultural experience. We can explore, for example, how an author's life experiences affect(ed) their work - even if that author didn't put those effects in intentionally. I find it interesting (and, admittedly, frustrating) that a community like HN that likes to think of itself as being intellectually curious will at the same time insist on only the most surface-level art analysis. 'Cause I guess if it's not software it's not worth thinking deeply about.
- wolverine876 5y ago> I find it interesting (and, admittedly, frustrating) that a community like HN that likes to think of itself as being intellectually curious will at the same time insist on only the most surface-level art analysis. Lots of people like to think of themselves as intellectually curious, including me and you! Let's not look at the mote in our HN neighbor's eye ... :) Art challenges norms and people instinctively reject things that challenge their norms. On top of that, extreme reactionary culture is very 'normalized' now, so being closed-minded is legitimized rather than being seen as an embrace of ignorance.
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm not talking about rejecting things that challenge my norms. I'm talking about people finding pictures in clouds.
- fknorangesite 5y ago> Let's not look at the mote in our HN neighbor's eye Hah fair enough. I may not be an art critic, but my point is that I try not to just outright dismiss the entire field the way I often see in tech communities. (Also, aside: I've really appreciated your contributions in this thread.)
- WalterBright 5y agoIf I ever write a novel, I guarantee it will not come from an agenda or have deep meaning. I'd write it for fun, and would be pleased if other people enjoyed reading it. > if it's not software it's not worth thinking deeply about I'm not offended if people don't think deeply about D. It's designed to be fun and highly useful. If somebody wrote an essay about D having some metaphysical deep meaning, I'd probably have a good laugh!