3 ms·
If that actually worked, and you still believe it, you missed out on all the substance of an education. Dismissals are always a signal of ignorance.
by wolverine876 5y ago
If that actually worked, and you still believe it, you missed out on all the substance of an education. Dismissals are always a signal of ignorance.
- bane 5y agoI actually think it's a shame. It seems that many English Lit departments (and associated K-12 pedagogy) have arrive at a kind expected & trite monoculture of thought. There's a tremendous value to being able dissect a text, form an argument, and defend it. But what students ultimately find is that executing this well and demonstrating the validity of a viewpoint is not really the primary evaluation point but rather that the content conforms to pre-decided avenues of thought. These departments have the trappings and ceremony of rational thought, but none of the ability to face the revelations of diverse truths and viewpoints that challenge the established status quo. As a result millions of students leave the classes without the tools to read and analyze for comprehension and to form coherent and rational opinions that reflect the things that are important to them. Even worse, when they are presented with these cognitive models, they've "learned" to reject them. These tools can not only reflect thought, but also help shape it. Critical thinking results from it.
- mlyle 5y ago> Dismissals are always a signal of ignorance. Only a Sith deals in absolutes! (As you dismiss all dismissals). Literary criticism has reached increasing levels of "sophistication" where frankly a big fraction of it deserves to be dismissed. Conversely, people who dismiss looking for literary intentions, possible alternative interpretations on other axes of thought, and reasons that the structure works are foolish as well. I think where one goes awry and too far is when one insists that a specific interpretation is particularly valid without any real evidence of authorial intent or that other readings don't make sense. The lit crit world is buried in these insistences.