3 ms·
There are all kinds of choices when making art of any sort. The internet more or less proves that there are many things that never even appeared to the creator(
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
There are all kinds of choices when making art of any sort. The internet more or less proves that there are many things that never even appeared to the creator(s) as choices at all, but to those interpreting/experiencing the art appear to have been choices made for a reason.
Why did she wear a red sweater? Why was it set at the equator? Why did it rain? Why is the only named plant a phylodendron? Why did they leave for 2 days and not 3? Why did journey go north instead of east?
People convinced that all art is created by careful choice-making at every possible juncture seem to find it a little difficult to accept that the creator(s) of a piece of art that they like may not even have experienced a particular story/view/sound/structure point as a choice at all.
- brimble 5y agoSure, but I think stopping all the way back at "they killed a pig because they were hungry" in Lord of the Flies is... well, going to limit one's literacy level. There's flights of fancy, and then there's not being able to understand literature.
- gkop 5y agoYou expect too much from the HN commentariat with regard to this topic.
- vidarh 5y agoIt's entirely reasonable to ask the question and to ask people to consider what it might mean, and what supports that reading and how likely readers are to interpret it that way. That is not the issue. The issue is to then assume that this must have been the intent of the author all along unless they've actually told you. There's nothing wrong with not knowing with certainty the intent of the author. That does not take anything away from your interpretation. But often people seek to ascribe intent to the author in an attempt to assert authority over what the "true" meaning of a work is.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoActually, there is a sub-steam of art interpretation that insists that you can ascribe a particular meaning to some part of a peice of art even if the creator explicitly says "I did not mean that"
- wolverine876 5y ago> People convinced that all art is created by careful choice-making at every possible juncture Where are these magical strawpeople? :D
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoChris Nolan fans who've been to film school.