5 ms·
Rome: Decline and Fall? Part III: Things
- jq-r 5y agoA minor nitpick from the article as the author writes that amphorae were used only for liquids like wine. That's incorrect, it was used for all kinds of unpackaged bulk good like grains, seeds (say olives), even sea shells. If you're transporting goods, you want it in containers; and amphorae were the shipping containers (quite literally) of that time. They were even used as toilets on ships.
- 0x_rs 5y agoAmphorae were widespread and commonly used for all sorts of things, so much in fact that it seems there was a "standard" set of sizes and manufacturing processes, and there's one notable mound in Rome [0] made primarily with one type of amphora that, the theory goes on to explain, was too burdensome to recycle, so it was simply discarded in an orderly manner. This is pretty much in line with the standardization that happened with modern freight containers and allowed a substancial economic benefit, so the comparison is really on point. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Testaccio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Testaccio
- ggm 5y agoThere is simply no way the author doesn't know of the multiple functional uses of amphora. Either you've misconstrued the meaning, driven a long bow from the meaning, or the author made a typo or edited a sentence too hard. They are a professional historian of the period. They know what the jars are used for. "Incorrect" is "schooling " language. I think you could find a nicer way to put this. "Surely the authors shorthand for wine is an expediency here since they undoubtedly know amphora had many purposes" or something. I might add I corrected the author on twitter for a misread one article prior and he very charitably pointed out how I hadn't read properly, unlike my uncharitable tweet so I write from experience.
- Spellman 5y agoThe TL;DR quote: "Instead, I think the stronger point here ... is that the collapse of the Roman Empire in the West – while it was a catastrophe for those people living at the time – was less a product of ‘hoards of barbarians’ coming over the frontier ... and instead a product of actors within the political system, within the empire, tearing it apart out of the pursuit of their own interests, deceived by the assumption that something so old could never simply vanish…until it did. The consequences of their decisions and of their failure to recognize the fragility of the clockwork machine that suspended them above the poverty to come (and that it was already damaged) were great and terrible." But I highly recommend walking through all the data and discussion of exactly what that clockwork machine was. And then think about if/how today's society is different.
- e4e78a06 5y agoI think the author fails to adequately discuss the impact of climate change on the economy. We know from modern history that recessions lead to political change. It's not implausible that an agrarian economy like that of Rome would be greatly impacted by climate change reducing crop yields, causing political upheaval. Those actors in the political system didn't just decide one day to depart from 200 years of stability to overthrow the government, there had to be some motivating factor.
- xeromal 5y agoIs unchecked corruption not a motivating factor? Greed?
- Spellman 5y agoI think the shifts in agriculture could definitely spark something, but robust political institutions and state capacity would have allowed them to weather the issues and adapt. Instead political fractures grew into much bigger problems bringing instability causing a downward spiral. Not to mention some of the biggest political shifts that happen around that era. The shift to the Late Roman empire is marked with a series of assassinations of the Emperor. Partially because of consolidation of the position's power and prestige. And in contrast other empires to the East and West organized and grew in power.
- charliea0 5y agoA very interesting article as usual from this source. I particularly enjoyed learning of the marvelous social mechanisms which elevated Roman living standards without the technological advancement which created the modern world. It is fascinating as well to compare to the fundamental problem of coordination and defections. The accumulated damage to Roman society by selfish actors eventually destroyed the institutions which produced such wealth.
- jjoonathan 5y ago> the marvelous social mechanisms which elevated Roman living standards How much of it was conquest and slavery? Certainly not all of it, but I feel like a lot of it was conquest and slavery and we should control for that sort of thing when singing praise.
- akomtu 5y agoSlavery is the equivalent of cheap oil: it doesn't absolve the nation from the need to build something meaningful with it.
- jjoonathan 5y agoBuilding something meaningful doesn't absolve the sins of its construction. The Romans were very good at conquering people and levying brutal taxes, but that doesn't add value and we shouldn't pretend that it does. They were also good at civil engineering, keeping the peace, and other economic activities which do add value and we should give them credit for it. I'd love to see a historical economic discussion that tries to tease apart these factors and weigh them against each other.
- 988747 5y ago> levying brutal taxes One of the reasons why Roman empire was so stable was that Roman taxes were actually lower and simpler than whatever taxes the local kings imposed previously. This makes sense if you think about it: Romans only really cared about Italy, and they didn't have to extract much resources from all the provinces to enrich Italy significantly. Previous rulers typically had only their small kingdom to tax, so they taxed it heavily.
- eerikkivistik 5y agoThere is a wonderful historian who talks in length about Roman history with some basic visual aids and animations. I'll leave a link to the playlist here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9qlNBBoFG4&list=PLODnBH8kenOrjXjWy7Hhkz9uOpZ3NTAow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9qlNBBoFG4&list=PLODnBH8ken... I highly suggest taking a look at the episode that covers the battle of Alesia for example.
- DiogenesKynikos 5y agoI've always been irked by the "continuity" argument. The collapse of the Roman imperial system must have had a massive effect on the way of life of normal people. The archaeological evidence presented in this article backs that up. The chart of average femur length over time is really interesting - especially the fact that it tracks the ups and downs of Roman political stability. However, I wish that there were error bars on the plot. The plot tells a nice story and matches what one would expect, but without error bars, I'm not sure whether to believe it.
- chmod600 5y agoIf I understand correctly, the main point is that the destruction of institutions lowers the quality and quantity of life that can be supported. That makes sense. The bigger surprise to me was that after the Black Death, quality of life for the survivors improved. I suppose that's because there was less dependence on institutions, or maybe the Black Death caused less damage to institutions than to people?
- champagnois 5y agoA theory proposed by a professor at my school was: The black death killed a lot of the people who grouped in churches and ignored the common sense precautions of staying away from people. This could be seen as a culling of what was largely the weak and foolish third of society. Coincidentally, with fewer people to do the labor around and a generally smarter stock of people remaining, the upper classes were forced to pay more for services that keep the world running. There was a huge impact on labor markets, claimed the professor. Thirdly, and likely related to all of this, the renaissance began.
- Calavar 5y ago> The black death killed a lot of the people who grouped in churches and ignored the common sense precautions of staying away from people. Was that really considered common sense before we knew about germ theory? I'm not asking rhetorically; I'm legitimately curious about whether the average medieval peasant had any intuition about the fact that disease was communicable.
- analog31 5y agoI don't know about the Medieval period, but reading a book about Galileo, I noted that his communications with the officials in Rome was hampered by the fact that the cities along the mail route would close their gates and impose a quarantine whenever a plague went through the region. So at least they had a hunch that the disease could be carried from A to B, even if they didn't know by what.
- champagnois 5y ago
- ogogmad 5y agoExcerpt from the Wikipedia page on the Antonine plague (165-180 AD) [1]: A good indicator of nutrition and the disease burden is the average height of the population. The conclusion of the study of thousands of skeletons is that the average Roman was shorter in stature than the people of pre-Roman societies of Italy and the post-Roman societies of the Middle Ages. The view of historian Kyle Harper is that "not for the last time in history, a precocious leap forward in social development brought biological reverses." That's admittedly a vague quote. But it suggests that Roman civilisation made life shittier than either before or after. Is there a genuine inconsistency with the submission? [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonine_Plague https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonine_Plague [edit] The Wikipedia article has a reference to this article about skeleton height: https://academic.oup.com/ereh/article-abstract/9/1/61/457455?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://academic.oup.com/ereh/article-abstract/9/1/61/457455... - It apparently improved after the collapse of the Western Roman Empire!
- throwaway98211 5y agoI remember reading about a similar dynamic in Harari's 'Sapiens'... the shift to from hunter/gatherer to agriculture being better for 'society' (more people) but worse for the average individual within the society, at least in terms of health (poorer/narrower diet, increased disease, shorter lifespan.)
- thematrixturtle 5y ago> A system like that, where the gains in per-capita production were the product of trade networks leveraging competitive advantage and the accumulation of agricultural capital (animals, but also potentially mills, olive presses, that sort of thing) could potentially be very fragile. Disruptions to trade or a failure to maintain that agricultural capital through a crisis could lead a society to fall back down to a lower equilibrium. The parallels to what we're experiencing right now due to COVID affecting trade and supply chains are uncanny and worrisome.
- afthonos 5y agoI think COVID disruptions are recoverable. However, rising international tensions and a move away from globalization will at least result in a readjustment; managed poorly, it could lead to longer-term decreases in quality of life.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoI'm thinking that the de-globalization we're already experiencing is at least partly responsible for some of the inflation we're seeing (the pandemic itself is the big cause, but I suspect we would've started seeing inflation increase even if the pandemic hadn't happened). Inflation is already leading to some decreases in quality of life.
- stakkur 5y agoThere’s nothing new or novel here—except of course that’s it’s told in blog posts. Much of what I read there is paraphrases of well-known knowledge about Rome.
- jondwillis 5y agoI just want to re-plug the Mike Duncan “The History of Rome” podcast that I heard about in one of the comment sections for previous parts of this series here on HN. I’m on episode 103! https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-history-of-rome/id261654474 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-history-of-rome/id...