7 ms·
App can vibrate a single drop of blood to determine how well it clots
- funstuff007 5y agoMaybe HOlmes's problem was she was collecting too much blood. Maybe she needed to collect less blood.
- joering2 5y agoHer only problem was that she fell off the runway before she had a chance to take off. Some engineers I spoke with told me she was 2 years before her big breakthru. At the end of the day no difference between Holmes being over-promising on blood testing, and Musk over-promising with your Tesla being a robotaxi that makes you $30,000 profit a year, by driving fully autonomously inside a vast network of underground 3D tunnels at speeds of 150 mph.
- jacquesm 5y ago> Some engineers I spoke with told me she was 2 years before her big breakthru. That's pretty gullible given her history to date. 2 years before a breakthrough spells 'never', that's exactly how the rest of the investors got bilked.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoDid these "some engineers" get their degree from a crackerjack box? Holmes was always full of shit, and a "big breakthru" in this area is impossible, as there is ample evidence that capillary blood at these volumes is simply not homogeneous enough to give accurate results for quantitative tests.
- joering2 5y agoImpossible with todays technology. When Musk was initially pitching electric car, everyone was laughing because back then the batteries density made it impossible for battery to be lightweight enough to be carried in a normal sized car. And look where we are today... Let's revisit Holmes claims in 15 years. Unless you want to argue that there will never be any progress made in terms of blood tests???
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoNot sure why I'm feeding the trolls, but anyway: > everyone was laughing because back then the batteries density made it impossible for battery to be lightweight enough to be carried in a normal sized car. That's simply untrue. The issue was always recognized to be economic, not a physical impossibility issue. There were a bunch of (crappy) electric cars in the 90s. With respect to Theranos, impossible as in it is physically impossible, because of the non-homogeneity of capillary blood. It simply doesn't matter how good your blood test is, if you are doing a quantitative test, for many types of tests you can simply not get good enough accuracy doing a finger prick test.
- joering2 5y ago
- fastball 5y agoWhen you said the 90s, did you mean the 1890s? If so, you would be correct.
- CamperBob2 5y agoWith respect to Theranos, impossible as in it is physically impossible, because of the non-homogeneity of capillary blood. It simply doesn't matter how good your blood test is, if you are doing a quantitative test, for many types of tests you can simply not get good enough accuracy doing a finger prick test. The crazy thing is, you don't have to consult biomedical engineers or pore over leading-edge research papers to discover this. You just need to ask almost any med tech with a modicum of experience with blood tests. They will tell you, in no uncertain terms, that Blood Does Not Work That Way. I will never understand the lack of due diligence performed by the Theranos investors. There couldn't possibly have been any due diligence at all. It's very hard to avoid slipping into victim-blaming mode in any conversation about this company.
- austinjp 5y agoYou've leapt from 2 years to 15 years, I notice. And "blood tests" vs tests of capillary blood is a big difference.
- kuhewa 5y agoWere the engineers from the future?
- axutio 5y agoHolmes wasn't just making lofty promises about the future capabilities of her technology, she was lying about its current capabilities to investors and using unreliable diagnostic tools to provide patients with test results that were frequently wrong - real patients experienced real harm as a result. The better analogy would be Musk indiscriminately enabling full self-driving in every Model 3, claiming its Level 5 as is, and encouraging drivers to sit in the back with a blindfold on.
- BoorishBears 5y agoActually the current state of the FSD Beta would be a great analogy, no alteration needed.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> At the end of the day no difference between Holmes being over-promising on blood testing, and Musk over-promising with your Tesla being a robotaxi that makes you $30,000 profit a year, by driving fully autonomously inside a vast network of underground 3D tunnels at speeds of 150 mph. There's a difference, Musk is wealthy and has mostly swindled consumers and retail investors, while Holmes wasn't wealthy and mainly swindled the wealthy.
- xwdv 5y agoThere’s no need to make this an app on a smartphone. For mere dollars we can build this out of off the shelf components, as a small single purpose device. Make it Bluetooth compatible if you want.
- lupire 5y agoThere is no need for an expensive custom device. We already have plenty of phones.
- mateo1 5y agoUntil you get killed by a hacker, or your device manufacturer silently changes camera firmware to include shitty AI updates to your computational photography device and breaks the app etc. I'll buy the actual medical device, thank you.
- krisrm 5y agoMaybe I'm misunderstanding, but this seems like a pretty unlikely threat vector.
- eloisius 5y agoI’m sure they’ve thought about it, but I’m also curious about the risk of coupling an OTC medical device to the implementation details of a smartphone. Apple never intended the iPhone’s haptics or camera to be used this way, and could change them with a soft update at any time. Seems risky to trust the results without owning the supply chain or at least having guarantees.
- xondono 5y agoAnd then Apple changes some mechanical aspect of the haptics actuators and suddenly you are getting false results without knowing it. I’d rather get a custom device if my life depends on it.
- skeeter2020 5y agoIt doesn't take much of a smart phone, which many already have though. I'd rather buy someone a smart phone for this purpose than a custom, one-off testing device.
- collegeburner 5y agoTheranos lookin ass mf
- walterbell 5y agoWe need open-source DIYbio hardware and software for the same reasons as open-source security. This is a good device candidate for development by indie hackers, so that the resulting data samples and analysis are offline-first, with later optional aggregation under user consent.
- skeeter2020 5y agoThis is a pretty cool idea, with a technique that is both simple and proven. It's a mechanical test so they're basically coming up with an efficient way to do ancient medicine. Warfarin is almost free, but your diet and health changes can impact it's clotting impact, and changing your dose is like steering a cruise ship: long lags between inputs and final results. I've had to use a fast-acting injectable while getting into my clotting range which can take almost a week at $100 per daily shot. This also involved going to a clinic daily, then waiting for my doctor to get the results and phone me up, just to change my warfarin dose. You then go happily on your way but need to test regularly to stay in the desired range. The quality of life impact for millions of people could be enormous. Kudos!
- jfoster 5y ago> This also involved going to a clinic daily, then waiting for my doctor to get the results and phone me up, just to change my warfarin dose. Have you considered getting a PT/INR monitor? They're not cheap, but even just going to a clinic that has one will mean that you get your result very quickly.
- zabzonk 5y ago> Warfarin is almost free, but your diet and health changes can impact it's clotting impact, and changing your dose is like steering a cruise ship: long lags between inputs and final results. In the UK, edoxaban has more or less replaced Warfarin, and has far fewer side effects or need for monitoring (or so says my GP).
- davejitsu 5y agoIt really depends on why you need anticoagulants to begin with. I have mechanical bits in my ticker and so I’ll pretty much the last cohort to be able to jump, but your post prompted me to read up on Edoxaban and I’m apprehensively exited :)
- zabzonk 5y ago> It really depends on why you need anticoagulants to begin with. Of course. I have atrial fibrillation and it is more or less standard medication for that in the UK (along with god knows how much other stuff). My (late) Dad had the same problems as me, and he was never confident he had taken the right amount of warfarin. But if you have heart valves, stents or whatever, or indeed anything, please don't take this as medical advice - IANAD.
- samwillis 5y agoI find these type of inventions so exciting, taking a consumer device and modifying it for medical purposes. We need more of this type of innovative thinking in the medical field. I used to work in medical and biotech device development. There are very much two sides to the the development of a medical device, the scientific development and the commercial device. Far to regularly when I was working in the field (particularly diagnostics) researchers would see some positive early results, get some VC money and jump straight in to developing a snazzy device to do it before completely validating their science. They would get distracted by wanting to make a handheld touch screen thing, or a beautifully styled bench top device. In the 7 years I worked in medical/biotech development only a small portion of the projects I worked on made it to market and then to success. The ones that did, properly validated their science early in the process and kept thing simple and inexpensive.
- bobowzki 5y agoThe concept isn't new [1] but the low budget implementation is certainly quite clever. More advanced machines of this type are already in widespread use. The article makes it sound like it's a completely new concept. 1: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24123050/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24123050/