3 ms·

> More money inflates the supply of money. This is why cryptocurrencies that burn crypto are considered deflationary. Crypto isn't in a vaccuum. If the only c

> More money inflates the supply of money. This is why cryptocurrencies that burn crypto are considered deflationary. Crypto isn't in a vaccuum. If the only currency in the world was bitcoin, sure, call it deflationary. But compared to a decade ago, there are far more dollars floating around thanks to crypto. Not only are there are the rich people holding dollars and other currency, or gold, etc, but we've invented a bunch of crypto tokens that we also value massively, so you can be bitcoin-rich or ethereum-rich or nft-rich OR currency-rich... which is no different than printing currency out of thin air.

quadrangle 5y ago
> there are far more dollars floating around thanks to crypto Uh no, cryptocurrencies can't generate USD. But if you meant "dollars" as a generic term for currency, then sure, kinda yeah, to the degree that cryptocurrencies are actually working as currencies (which they mostly are not). Anyway, the "deflationary" claim is internal to a cryptocurrency. Nobody is asserting that cryptocurrencies cause deflation of USD.
- ravel-bar-foo 5y ago
  > Uh no, cryptocurrencies can't generate USD. If I buy crypto from a miner, the dollars don't disappear. The miner uses it to buy energy and semiconductors, which makes its way around the econony until some miniscule fraction of it comes back to me. (The loss of assets in the economy needed to create the transaction does not destroy dollars, but it does destroy finite resources such as fuel or sunlight for energy, the time of the people involved in the supply chain, etc. In that sense, buying crypto generates USD: we end the process having completed the reaction Dollars + fuel/energy/resources + time -> Dollars + Crypto So if one values crypto more than fuel/energy/resouces + time (say, because crypto is deflationary and its value will rise faster than that of the natural resources used to create it, then it does look (if you squint at it) like dollars are generated: the crypto can be sold later for more than the dollars. At the individual level, the transaction might be even more biased: dollars -> crypto now looks a lot like it generates dollars later if dollars are inflationary and crypto is deflationary (with stable demand for crypto).
  - RC_ITR 5y ago
    Lol, you’re trying to talk about the credit multiplier as it relates to crypto with a crypto fan. Maybe a lost cause?
    - quadrangle 5y ago
      How did you imagine me to be a crypto fan??? I'm a total crypto-cynic sympathetic to the argument that it's all a speculative wasteful scam.
  - quadrangle 5y ago
    I'm not following. Yes, cryptocurrency mining and the buying of it with dollars has effects on the world, but "generate" dollars?? Economic activity doesn't generate dollars. Do you mean the standard metaphorical "make money" which really means "get paid"? If a single dollar gets pushed around a small economy a thousand times in a day, it is facilitating economic activity, but that doesn't increase or decrease the money supply.

quadrangle 5y ago

> there are far more dollars floating around thanks to crypto Uh no, cryptocurrencies can't generate USD. But if you meant "dollars" as a generic term for currency, then sure, kinda yeah, to the degree that cryptocurrencies are actually working as currencies (which they mostly are not). Anyway, the "deflationary" claim is internal to a cryptocurrency. Nobody is asserting that cryptocurrencies cause deflation of USD.

ravel-bar-foo 5y ago
> Uh no, cryptocurrencies can't generate USD. If I buy crypto from a miner, the dollars don't disappear. The miner uses it to buy energy and semiconductors, which makes its way around the econony until some miniscule fraction of it comes back to me. (The loss of assets in the economy needed to create the transaction does not destroy dollars, but it does destroy finite resources such as fuel or sunlight for energy, the time of the people involved in the supply chain, etc. In that sense, buying crypto generates USD: we end the process having completed the reaction Dollars + fuel/energy/resources + time -> Dollars + Crypto So if one values crypto more than fuel/energy/resouces + time (say, because crypto is deflationary and its value will rise faster than that of the natural resources used to create it, then it does look (if you squint at it) like dollars are generated: the crypto can be sold later for more than the dollars. At the individual level, the transaction might be even more biased: dollars -> crypto now looks a lot like it generates dollars later if dollars are inflationary and crypto is deflationary (with stable demand for crypto).
- RC_ITR 5y ago
  Lol, you’re trying to talk about the credit multiplier as it relates to crypto with a crypto fan. Maybe a lost cause?
  - quadrangle 5y ago
    How did you imagine me to be a crypto fan??? I'm a total crypto-cynic sympathetic to the argument that it's all a speculative wasteful scam.
- quadrangle 5y ago
  I'm not following. Yes, cryptocurrency mining and the buying of it with dollars has effects on the world, but "generate" dollars?? Economic activity doesn't generate dollars. Do you mean the standard metaphorical "make money" which really means "get paid"? If a single dollar gets pushed around a small economy a thousand times in a day, it is facilitating economic activity, but that doesn't increase or decrease the money supply.