3 ms·
HTTPS is not end-to-end encrypted (it kinda would be if we used P2P but we don't) so you can subpoena the server.
by wmf 5y ago
HTTPS is not end-to-end encrypted (it kinda would be if we used P2P but we don't) so you can subpoena the server.
- CogitoCogito 5y ago> HTTPS is not end-to-end encrypted (it kinda would be if we used P2P but we don't) so you can subpoena the server. How is https communication not end to end encrypted? And what’s the difference between subpoenaing a server vs an end user? The server is just another person/organization. Edit: Re-reading this I guess you mean that having a centra server acting as a middle man would probably not be end to end which I agree with. I thought you meant user <—-> server wasn’t end to end.
- xeromal 5y agoI think they just mean they can just tell the company who owns the server to give them the data.
- woodruffw 5y agoA typical example is a chat application served over HTTPS: your communication with the server is encrypted, but the messages sent between you and your friends are passed through the server in the clear (through databases, logging, caching layers, etc.).
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoIt is absolutely end-to-end encrypted. However, one of the ends is usually a server.
- pyuser583 5y agoI guess it depends on which end we are talking about. Generally, “end to end encryption” refers to client to client encryption, where the sever routes data but can’t read it.
- judge2020 5y agoYour comment is only confusing because E2EE is a term about encryption where no data between two devices can be read by eavesdroppers. HTTPS is indeed end-to-end encrypted between the server and the device. A better way to put it is that HTTPS does not promote E2EE between end-users, which it doesn't intend/pretend to do anyways.
- upofadown 5y ago>E2EE is a term about encryption where no data between two devices can be read by eavesdroppers. That would cover any use of encryption. E2EE is a term used where there is a distinction to be made between access by users at the ends of the system and some other part of the system. Originally used to cover the encrypted email case where there is a lot of "middle" in the form of email servers and a small amount of "end". The term is often used incorrectly these days for marketing purposes. TLS could be used in an E2EE system, but it is normally not.