10 ms·
The Raptor 2 engine is just an absurd. The original specs were already kind of insane. But Raptor 2 is an monster. They really pushed already significantly into
by panick21_ 5y ago
The Raptor 2 engine is just an absurd. The original specs were already kind of insane. But Raptor 2 is an monster. They really pushed already significantly into a second generation design before first flight. Raptor 2 is not just a slight upgrade, its a huge upgrade.
If it can actually launch multiple times a day without any refurbishment, it will simply totally break space travel as we have known it. This engine makes everything else possible.
- sfblah 5y agoAnd then what? What's the use case?
- panick21_ 5y agoI guess you can listen to the presentation yourself.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoLifting enormous amounts of mass to orbit and Mars. Arguing the merits of these activities is beyond the scope of this thread.
- sfblah 5y agoSorry, I didn't realize we weren't allowed to discuss the point of the presentation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI’m unsure there’s much to discuss in that specific regard? If you believe in cheap heavy lift and humans colonizing Mars, you agree this project has merit (and the costs and human effort involved reasonable). If you don’t, you see this project as superfluous and wasteful. Is that interpretation inaccurate? It’s somewhat, but not entirely, binary. From the presentation, development costs will be 5-10% of the Saturn V program (2020 dollars adjusted). Thats a bargain for the capabilities delivered.
- HWR_14 5y agoWhat if I believe in government run Mars colonies, but don't believe in private ones like one run as Musk's empire? Am I not allowed a nuanced opinion?
- krisoft 5y agoMars is a big place. If we have the tech to create colonies governments can pay SpaceX for a ticket to get whatever flavour of structure they wish there.
- chriswarbo 5y ago> private ones like one run as Musk's empire Where have you got this idea from? SpaceX are a haulage company: they currently haul crew and cargo to and from Earth orbit (plus a few deep-space probes, and one deep-space car); Starship will extend this further through the solar system (Moon, Mars, asteroids, etc.). At the moment, their main "destination" is the government-run ISS. There are no off-world colonies (public or private); there aren't even any private space stations yet. (NASA recently funded some private space station proposals; SpaceX made a token effort, which was rejected). Musk himself has stated that he wants humans to be multi-planetary, and doesn't care who does it; that he would be happy for someone to out-compete SpaceX, since that would mean the goal has been achieved. SpaceX will gladly help governments set up off-world colonies; in fact, that seems like the only feasible way to build them. The problem is the cost was too high, even for government; the point of Starship is to reduce that cost. The only reason Musk started SpaceX was because the Boeings/Lockheed Martins/etc. were happy to keep prices high; and Russia wouldn't sell him a Mars-capable rocket.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fastball 5y agoMoon colonies, mars colonies, space stations in orbit for science, space stations for leisure, space stations for industry. Shipyards for building bigger spaceships in orbit. Mining asteroids. Etc.
- bjelkeman-again 5y agoMass to orbit gives you lots of options: Starlink completed, more telescopes like James Webb but cheaper, a moon base, radio telescope on the far side of the moon, orbital rotational space stations (for G forces), missions to asteroids, Mars, outer planets, are just a few things. Point to point transport on Earth, halfway around the world in less than an hour.
- bqmjjx0kac 5y agoSpace mining.
- senectus1 5y agofor building in space.
- monocasa 5y agoIt also opens up off planet manufacturing in a way that can snowball into self sustaining growth. Which IMO is how we're going to mint the first trillionaire.
- XorNot 5y agoAlso the only true way we'll save the biosphere IMO - doing it all somewhere there isn't one, and where your pollutants basically don't matter.
- Seanambers 5y agoIf this pans out and rapid and full reusability of the starship system is realized - which by all accounts looks more than very likely at this stage its more a question of when. Elon Musk will be the world's first trillionaire and he also got Tesla's FSD to pull out of the hat.
- vanattab 5y agoThe launch costs of James Webb were an insignificant part of the spending on the telescope.
- ksec 5y agoI am by no means an expert or even enthusiast. Space Manufacturing, New innovation possibility with near zero gravity. New way to harness energy from the sun. Or the real possibility of space tourism.
- boxed 5y agoCan turn out this will save all of humanity. This could make a sunshade feasible: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094576521001995 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009457652... If you don't recognize him, one of the authors of this paper is Swedens only astronaut :)
- chasd00 5y agoI like how small and slender Raptor 2 is compared to Raptor 1. The turbo pump looks even scarier than usual though. It's amazing that something so small is producing 100k HP (the pump turbine).
- ewjt 5y agoI thought 100k HP was either too incredible or a typo. Then I looked it up: “You def don’t want electric pumps on a rocket engine! Raptor turbopumps alone need 100,000 horsepower per engine. That’s not a typo.” —Elon Musk x 32 engines. Amazing! For comparison, this is an internal combustion engine with 100k HP: https://www.zmescience.com/science/biggest-most-poweful-engine-world/amp/ https://www.zmescience.com/science/biggest-most-poweful-engi...
- iliketrains 5y agoThat is interesting, so could you replace the biggest and most powerful internal combustion engine in the world that weighs 2,300 tons by [whatever powers] turbopumps from a raptor engine and get the same power output? Where is the catch? Less fuel efficient? Less torque? Edit: What I meant to ask was: Can one use "whatever is powering the turbopumps and delivering the 100k HP" to power say a ship propeller, instead of that 2.3k ton internal combustion engine. Like, make some variant of raptor engine that delivers this power to a shaft.
- gpm 5y agoIt's a totally different problem. Yes it's less efficient, you spent all this energy cooling off all the fuel and oxidizer to cryogenic temperatures before using it. The turbopumps in the raptors are also running very far off from stochiometric fuel mixtures (which is fine in the rocket because they're exhaust is used as fuel for the next stage) - which means if you're just using it for the pump your not actually burning most of the fuel. The exhaust is also really hot, and if you're not somehow using that energy it's definitely inefficient. None of those issues matter to the rocket. Energy used on the ground to cool down propellants is "free", the colder the better because it means you can fit more propellants in the same tanks. The exhaust is just being piped into the main combustion chamber, so it will eventually be fully combusted extracting the left over chemical energy. The heat of the exhaust (after the main chamber) is the whole point, with a nozzle converting it into kinetic energy. You've also got a bunch of safety issues. High pressures, liquid oxygen, and so on.
- inasio 5y agoMy theory is that they aim to disrupt Earth travel (airlines). Elon pointed out that the reliability of Starship would exceed that of commercial airplanes, and the fuel costs are not that different than, say, a 747. Fewer moving parts than an airplane, less human costs, order of magnitude faster...
- etrautmann 5y agoElon seemed to indicate that it would be stretching to get individual launch costs below $1M. That seems at least 2-3 orders of magnitude out of range for most conventional travel?
- inasio 5y agoThere is no way the cost per trip (airline) is in the $1K - $10K range. The Boeing 787-8 has a fuel capacity of 33,500 gallons. I don't think an intercontinental flight costs significantly less than $1M
- mikeyouse 5y agoIn round numbers, airlines’ cost basis is ~$0.15 per available seat mile. So a trip from NYC to Rome of 4,300 miles in a 777-300ER with 350 passengers would cost in the ballpark of $225k. LA to Shanghai at 6,500 miles in the same capacity plane would be more like $350k. $1M wouldn’t make much sense because with 350pax you’d need them to pay $2,900 each leg just to cover the operating costs. So a round trip flight to Shanghai that was completely sold out in both directions would need to have an average ticket price of nearly $6k.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI’m sure they would find their customers. The Concorde from NY to Paris ran about 10k USD round trip. There are many more millionaires now than there were in the 90s.
- mlindner 5y ago
- jnsaff2 5y agoWhenever I read enthusiasm like this for space travel .. especially talk of Musks interplanetary species and stuff, I get a flashback to Stark by Ben Elton . Published in 1989, getting closer to true by the day. Also probably the funniest book I've ever read. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stark_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stark_(novel)
- nickpp 5y agoI prefer to think of The Expanse instead. It seems a much more likely future to me. There are countless dystopic futures (they sell better) we already avoided so I prefer optimism.
- the_other 5y agoWhere's the utopia in The Expanse? Humans move offworld; two communities with stable infrastructure spend a century abusing a scattered sub-class; then they all get into a war because a sociopath egotist finds alien technology powerful enough to wipe them all out or mutate them into components of itself. And then there's the meteorites... Sounds idyllic.
- nickpp 5y agoThe utopia is that humanity is not stuck on a single planet anymore, with all eggs in one basket - so to speak. The rest I find just realistic though. I do not expect humans in space to behave much differently from humans on earth.
- timeon 5y agoIf I sum your two paragraphs new title can be: Swarm Of Locusts.
- nickpp 5y agoYes, we are a result of evolution and it is our evolutionary imperative to find and fill any biological niche available. You can try denying our nature but it is a futile endeavor. However, these "locusts" can discover and create. We can do art, science, understand the Reality and the Universe. I find this absolutely beautiful and breathtaking, especially for a "swarm of locusts".
- ksec 5y ago>This engine makes everything else possible. I have seen lot of tweets ( from highly intelligent people and engineers ) suggesting Starship is not possible. Raptor 2 is not possible. But now it seems it really is coming. It is easy to fault him for robotaxi and FSD, which a lot of people do. But sometimes he really does the impossible.
- mlindner 5y agoAll the tweets from people who should know better tells me that even smart people are highly influenced by propaganda and bad takes from the media.
- traceelement 5y ago
- czottmann 5y agoAnnoying, isn't it. SpaceX, like all worthwhile and impressing endeavours in the past, is the work of a legion of people in front of and behind the curtain!
- hoseja 5y agoThe chamber is still melting. Hopefully they can figure that one out.
- Azrael3000 5y agoSource? Several raptors have been fired for long duration and even multiple times. If the chambers would melt that should not be possible. Of course RUDs of engines happened but they were the exception and not the norm.
- virgilp 5y agoAlso, the only non-intentional engine RUD that I know of is SN8, where debris from ground destroyed the engine avionics at takeoff. Any other incident?
- londons_explore 5y agoIf they are making such big upgrades before even getting to orbit, it suggests the rest of their design is falling short of expectations on mass/performance, and they need more thrust to make up for it.
- panick21_ 5y agoNo, they are always evolving everything as fast as they possible can. They don't have a 'target performance' that they need to hit because the military or somebody told them. They are just iterating each individual part pushing towards ever higher performance.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoOr that they don't shy from making changes just because of the fact that current design is "good enough".
- causi 5y agoI wonder how much an orbital flight would cost if it were reduced to, say, the price of fuel plus ten percent.
- bagels 5y agoAbout 10k-100k based on 10m launch cost and 100 tonne capacity.