4 ms·
I've said this in other threads, but I'm probably done buying AirTags, because the anti-stalking features, that I assume you're aware of, are so annoying, that
by nomel 5y ago
I've said this in other threads, but I'm probably done buying AirTags, because the anti-stalking features, that I assume you're aware of, are so annoying, that I don't want to add any more to my life.
When I get in my car with my wife, we both get a notification that an AirTag is following us, because my wife is potentially stalking me with her purse and keys. I can silence this notification for only one day. I can't disable it, because that's what a stalkers or abusive boyfriend would do. They randomly beep and boop to notify me that they exist, and I'm being stalked, and to put my phone near the offending AirTag so I can see the serial and last four digits of the owners phone number.
If someone were actually stalking me, I probably wouldn't notice.
I think the whole concept is almost doomed, if you're to be satisfied. The purpose of an AirTag is to track a thing. The desire of a stalker is to track a thing. I don't think these two identical problem spaces can exist together, in some harmonious way, that would satisfy people with your concerns, without constant annoyance. Just imagine if these were more popular and you did something crazy like, got on a bus, or went on a plane, walked any reasonable distance down a street with someone in your proximity.
I would love to hear a solutions that doesn't result in constant notifications. I also think it's completely silly to say "We'll we just have to restrict location track of anything, because there are bad people out there. Period." If the metric is to stop all the bad, then technology needs a huge lobotomy!
- varenc 5y agoApple just needs to add shared AirTags to iClould family sharing. I think that’d solve your issue and ~90% of other unwanted stalking alerts. They already allow shared “Find My iDevice” and just need to add AirTags to the mix.
- nomel 5y agoI agree, but from previous HN threads, people have said that this would enable people in abusive relationships to be stalked. Also, it appears that some distance is required to trigger the notification, so I imagine stalkers could use the AirTags within this distance. For example, to find which apartment someone lives in, within a building. I think there will always be headlines about stalking and abuse, and people claiming Apple didn't do enough (even though it's so annoying as is), regardless.
- varenc 5y ago> would enable people in abusive relationships to be stalked I can see that concern, but family sharing ALREADY lets you share iDevice locations at all time. That's a superior form of stalking compared to AirTags... So I just don't get this concern. It might just be perception though. From a PR perspective this is a bad time to release any feature that could be perceived as reducing AirTag stalking alerts.
- jeromegv 5y agoYep. People saying that have no idea.
- Gelob 5y agoor just be able to mark an airtag as friendly?
- Schiendelman 5y agoIt appears to already be in the mix for me. I see other reports on this thread saying the same.
- azinman2 5y agoFamily sharing is how you permanently silence one with you. Otherwise the only option is 24h.
- Syonyk 5y ago> then technology needs a huge lobotomy! Yes, it does. It really, really does. The absolutely human-toxic nature of most modern consumer tech ("You buy me, I feed you ads, and collect absolutely as much data as I can to improve the ads other people pay me to deliver to you!" model being the core complaint here) has done a huge amount of damage to humanity. There are upsides, but we culturally seem horrible at actually evaluating things fairly. Always-on devices, constantly sending notifications, are just horrible to every aspect of humans - and the more we learn about just how horrible the are, the better the companies involved refine their ability to "drive their users nuts" for more eyeball-time to view ads, desired or not. So, yes, if what you get out of my writings are that we should radically pull back on what consumer tech is and can do, you're evaluating my position quite accurately.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> If the metric is to stop all the bad, then technology needs a huge lobotomy! I think we need to change the metric. Every tool humans have ever invented can be used maliciously. So we have fallback options, like punishment, to mitigate that. Apple needs to make you read and acknowledge a notice when you get an AirTag that says quite clearly that they know the serial number and will happily provide your contact info to authorities on request. And then police need to actually arrest people for misusing tags to stalk.
- howinteresting 5y agoWhy should the public bear the costs of a $2 trillion dollar company's decisions? Why should overpoliced communities be subject to even more policing? The solution here is to restrict airtags to finding your own stuff only. That takes away some of the utility but also all of the stalking risk.