4 ms·
> It costs credibility. I enjoy the cut of the jib, but credibility isn't really that important. From memory, Argentina isn't credible. All that means is they
by roenxi 5y ago
> It costs credibility.
I enjoy the cut of the jib, but credibility isn't really that important. From memory, Argentina isn't credible. All that means is they have to pretend that they will pay high interest rates before people will lend to them. If the question is "can they pay back all their debts with real value?" angle the US position isn't credible either, the numbers have gotten too large. Doesn't mean much in practice.
The real issues with a default are:
1. A country is being run by people who don't believe that written words should decide what they do and who won't keep their promises even in the most watertight of cases.
2. Either the polity or political leadership are incapable of medium term planning.
3. The sort of people who think 10-30 years ahead are being tricked into making bad financial decisions.
So on the one hand a default doesn't matter to people who don't directly own the debt. On the other hand, if there is a default, a host of other problems are going to hit and the country won't be ready for them. It is a bad sign.
- jbay808 5y agoThe credibility I'm referring to is: when Jerome Powell says "we have the tools at our disposal to control inflation, and if it persists, we will not hesitate to use them", how much do you update your expectations of future inflation and interest rates? If statements like that start to sound like a bluff and no longer cause you to update your expectations away from high inflation and low interest rates, then the Fed has lost a certain amount of credibility. And that credibility should be thought of in some sense a conserved value. It's not regained instantly, but rather only by the market being surprised to discover that the Fed wasn't bluffing. And that's an expensive surprise, because by definition, it goes beyond what the market priced in.
- cma 5y agoThey have a dual mandate on both employment and inflation, and have to balance.
- jbay808 5y agoFor sure, and I strongly believe that a dual mandate was a grave mistake because a single-output controller simply can't control two variables that respond in opposite directions to that output. This allows their policymaking to be politically influenced and pick winners, and is one strong reason their inflation-fighting credibility is low.
- ajross 5y ago> If the question is "can they pay back all their debts with real value?" angle the US position isn't credible either, the numbers have gotten too large. The US is only slightly above median in debt to GDP among industrial nations: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/debt-to-gdp-ratio-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/debt-to-g... I know it's popular to imagine that the government is spending out of control, especially when it's being run by people you didn't vote for, but it's really not. If we're going to collapse then we've got a lot of headroom, given how far ahead of us Japan is on the spending ladder.