3 ms·
> Fast forward two years and several pivots, and my slightly-less-early-stage business is doing $900 per month in revenue... from ads. This entire piece just f
by kelnos 5y ago
> Fast forward two years and several pivots, and my slightly-less-early-stage business is doing $900 per month in revenue... from ads.
This entire piece just feels like someone trying to rationalize their choice to do something they previously considered yucky, because that thing turns out to be lucrative.
> In particular, attention is a form of micropayment with low friction.
This is an interesting way of framing it, one I am surprised I actually like.
When framed this way, it's easier for me to coherently say "I don't agree to use this payment method". I say that by using an ad blocker. And if you still give me the content of your site, despite the presence of the ad blocker, that's on you.
This framing does have flaws. A traditional payment goes through some kind of order and confirmation flow. "Taking my payment" -- i.e. foisting ads upon me -- before confirming I am ok paying that way, is not ok. I'd be fine with a page that popped up a modal saying "This site requires payment in the form of attention (advertisements). Click 'Accept' if you agree to these terms." I would be happy to see sites being up-front with that, so I can choose to close the browser tab rather than waste my attention. (Sites with ad-blocker blockers more or less do this, and I'm fine not consuming their content.)
I get that cash micropayments have all sorts of problems, but I do wish that was at least a viable option.
> This doesn't address more salient concerns with advertising, like sharing data with 3rd parties or the question of if it pushes companies to maximize for engagement more than they otherwise would.
While I agree those are big problems, for me, the problem is that I see advertising as a form of mental and emotional manipulation. I don't want to be treated like someone who must be manipulated into purchasing something, even if it is something that I need or would find genuinely useful.
Having said that, I'm not sure how our economic system would look if all advertising (not just online) were banned. Our economic system depends on consumerism, and no advertising would severely damage sellers' ability to get consumers to open their wallets. Not saying that would be a bad thing, but it would certainly cause a huge upheaval, which could be painful for a lot of people, at least for a time.