4 ms·
Social Control Media Is a Bubble and JoinDiaspora Might Be the Next Casualty
- dredmorbius 5y agoRoy Schestowitz's message here is largely about the threats, risks, and costs associated with hosting and serving third-party content. Words, images, and other materials can be huge liabilities. I'd hit on this element of self-hosting during the Google+ exodus ("Plexodus"), and started a Wiki page addressing some of the relevant risks, here: <https://social.antefriguserat.de/index.php/Risks_and_Threat_Models https://social.antefriguserat.de/index.php/Risks_and_Threat_...> That includes a few of the attacks Roy is referencing, though missing the whole "general legal harassment" element. I'd begun a conversation with the EFF about this aspect, though that largely died out, mostly my own fault. I'd written an earlier piece on why Usenet died. Effectively, limited financial opportunity, unlimited downside risk. See: "Why Usenet Died" (2015) 1. It got spammed to death. 2. It lost control over its culture, and that culture was crucial to its functioning. 3. It was too problematic for ISPs (or others) to provide ready access to it: spam, harassment, child pornography, and copyright violations all posed massive concerns. 4. There was no viable business model for providing the service. And beyond that, the original Usenet was small, attempted resurrections and updates have failed to gain traction, it lacked any sort of robust defences, and and relied excessively on unsupported trust and volunteered maintenance (mostly by university-employed systems administrators). <https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/3c3xyu/why_usenet_died/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/3c3xyu/why_use...> That's based on no especially close insights or awareness, though it seems to have held up reasonably well. It was the basis of a submission to HN a few years back as well (though I can't find that presently). For decentralised Internet services, unless you're serving a very small community or just your own content, all of these factors still apply. It turns out that the hardware costs of providing services to even many thousands of users are minimal. Bandwidth is also cheap. But technical and especially social and legal admin time turn out to be tremendously expensive. The big players see this as well, but can both optimse operations and present a sufficiently solid defence that the threats are at least generally manageable. But an underrated role of a large publisher is that it has sufficient legal muscle to be resistant to such threats.