4 ms·
There are many competing theories for this inflation: 1. The increase in money supply. 2. Supply chain bottlenecks. 3. Corporate greed & tech monopolies. 4.
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
There are many competing theories for this inflation:
1. The increase in money supply.
2. Supply chain bottlenecks.
3. Corporate greed & tech monopolies.
4. Fundamental supply constraints. (mostly in the housing sector)
Anybody trying to tell you that it's only or primarily one of them has a political motivation. It's all 4, with the first 2 being primary and both being important.
To effectively solve inflation we need to attack all 4.
- dcolkitt 5y agoI'm sorry, but "corporate greed" doesn't make sense. Were corporations not greedy in 2017?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoSure, but they weren't able to execute on that greed to the same extent that they were in 2017. Look at the profits of big tech in 2021 compared to 2017. In a well-functioning free market, most of the surplus is captured by the consumer rather than the producer. So excess profits are a sign of an inefficient market, and thus the drum beat for anti-trust enforcement against Google/Apple/Amazon/Facebook.
- dcolkitt 5y agoNeither Google nor Facebook make any significant profit from selling consumer profits. It's pretty tenuous to claim that their large profits are driving consumer inflation. Amazon makes virtually zero profits in consumer goods. It's high recent profits come from the B2B segments of AWS and advertising. Apple's margins have always been historically high. If anything iPhone concentration in the smartphones has declined since 2017. The sizable bulk of consumer inflation is being driven by housing, energy, food and used cars. It's extremely tenuous to tie any of this to FAANG profits.
- JaimeThompson 5y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/27/business/beef-prices-cattle-ranchers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/27/business/beef-prices-catt... "Since the 1980s, the four largest meatpackers have used a wave of mergers to increase their share of the market from 36 percent to 85 percent...Their dominance has allowed them to extinguish competition and dictate prices." https://twitter.com/AlecMacGillis/status/1476219789899096064 https://twitter.com/AlecMacGillis/status/1476219789899096064
- ldiracdelta 5y agoIn food supply, I think the issue is regulatory capture. If you make food in the USA you almost have to have a lawyer on staff to navigate all the regulation. Compliance team sizes are growing in ag. The difficulty of starting up a competing meatpacker plant is getting harder every year. When the ability of entry into food production is harder every year, you don't have to compete on efficiency and it trends toward monopoly.
- dcolkitt 5y agoHow does a gradual consolidation over 40 years explain a sudden spike in meat prices in the past year? The meat industry was only barely less concentrated in 2017 than 2021.
- archon 5y agoNot advocating for this point of view, but I think the thinking goes that even if <insert industry of choice here> wasn't any less concentrated in 2017 vs. now, the pandemic provided a lot of opportunity for price increase that might have otherwise caused regulatory scrutiny.
- radford-neal 5y ago"To effectively solve inflation we need to attack all 4." Why do you think that? You've listed four conceivable reasons for inflation. One could probably list another 20 after a bit more thought. That doesn't mean that these are all plausible. It seems entirely possible that just one of them accounts for just about all of the inflation. You haven't made any argument against this. Of the four you list, (3) and (4) seem implausible. Why would corporations suddenly have become more greedy? Have fundamental constraints on the housing sector (you mean zoning restrictions, maybe?) suddenly increased?
- bryanlarsen 5y ago> Of the four you list, (3) and (4) seem implausible. Why would corporations suddenly have become more greedy? Have fundamental constraints on the housing sector (you mean zoning restrictions, maybe?) suddenly increased? Those are the 4 I've heard politicians and pundits mention. I could name 20 more, but experts aren't naming them. 3&4 are long standing problems, sure. 3 is the anti-big tech anti-trust crowd. Big Tech makes a substantial portion of the profits in America, and that is fairly recent. Re: 4. Housing costs are a big portion of the inflation index, so tackling that issue will substantially reduce inflation even if it's not a recent problem. It's also the issue that's best addressed by local politicians, in a way that the other 3 can't be.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago> You haven't made any argument against this. If the problem is supply chain constraints, inflation will be quite varied among the sectors. And this is true, with used cars leading the way at 41%. If the problem is the money supply, inflation will be fairly even across the sectors. And while the sectoral components are quite different, they are becoming more similar over time.
- radford-neal 5y agoThose seem like good arguments for both (1) and (2) being factors. Not definitive, though. One expects there to be some variation in price changes from sector to sector at any time, so only a greater than typical variation would be indicative of particular supply disruptions (or put another way, there are always supply chain disruptions, though maybe not of the current magnitude). Also, increased money supply doesn't immediately get distributed throughout the economy. One expects price increases to first show up in the things that tend to be bought by the people who first got the money. And I'm not sure who got the bulk of the recently-created money...
- hackeraccount 5y agoBut arguably one solution - slowing the increase in the money supply - will fix all 4 of them. This isn't like a fire that needs fuel and air to keep going and stopping it can be done by taking either away; One of the two items is technically trivial (raise interest rates) and politically unpopular to do - the other is politically popular and technically challenging (fix supply issues). If history is any guide we'll try the politically easy one for 10 or 20 years before we finally get around to actually doing what will work.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoRaising the interest rates increases the unemployment rate and 9/10 times causes a recession. That's cutting off your nose to support your face.
- hackeraccount 5y agoAbsolutely. If the attitude of people were - 7% inflation? No problem, let's just not have an increase in unemployment or a recession then I'd at least be sympathetic. Instead people say "I can whip inflation without raising rates, increasing unemployment or causing a recession." What do you get? A recession. Rising unemployment. And inflation too.