5 ms·
> Your not buying the rights, that's the most annoying thing about NFTs, that people don't get. You are buying the rights, but they're rights that exist in a p
by naasking 5y ago
> Your not buying the rights, that's the most annoying thing about NFTs, that people don't get.
You are buying the rights, but they're rights that exist in a pseudo-legal system that has no enforcement and isn't recognized by any existing legal authority. Some kind of enforcement could exist one day though.
For instance, it's possible that your house in a "metaverse" might only display art for the NFTs that it verifies you own.
- gota 5y agoI truly hope we do not let technology be used to create this kind of artificial scarcity If anything, metaverse should allow you to see all works of art as if they were the real thing, all the time, for "free"* * assuming the efforts of building and maintaining the infrastructure are properly compensated
- dmix 5y ago> I truly hope we do not let technology be used to create this kind of artificial scarcity Aren't virtual economies old news by now? Plenty of games and game networks have accomplished this with virtual goods. The 'metaverse' stuff doesn't scare me personally (where this concept could become widespread). I don't buy for a second that it's going to be a big deal where it will be anything more than a niche glorified game lobby.
- knorker 5y agoYou are both right. Buying an NFT is buying the right to the NFT. It's not buying the right to the art. Even if NFTs were backed by law, so that if I use your private key to transfer the NFT to me you would be able to use the law to come after me for theft, what I stole from you wasn't the rights to the art. What the grandparent post was complaining about was that it's not even the rights to the art. If you buy the rights to the ape, then you can sell copies. I suppose the holder of an NFT can sell a "copy NFT". Maybe that's the next thing. Selling an NFT of an NFT of an NFT of a Beatles song. With a holder chain making sure that whoever minted the NFT-of-NFT at the time did hold the parent NFT. That last paragraph is of course exactly the kind of nonsense that is at the core of NFT, so you should expect these derivative NFTs to start becoming a product soon. If you can sell NFTs-of-art, why not NFTs-of-NFTs? Anyone can sell copies of the Mona Lisa (because expired copyright). Anyone can make NFTs of it, too. Why would NFTs minted by the Louvre be more real? To me, NFT is performance art. It makes you think about intangible ownership. But outside of being performance art it's worthless.
- captaincaveman 5y agoHow are you going to get a picture of the Mona Lisa? Take a photo? Your not allowed. The people who own the Mona Lisa, prevent people from taking photos of. They instead they take a photo of it themselves, which is a new creative work and has copyrights. Now they have controlled the market on photos of the Mona Lisa and you need to license photos of it from them. That's what I heard once anyhow.
- captaincaveman 5y agohere you go https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_panorama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_panorama
- knorker 5y agoHere you go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Mona_Lisa,_by_Leonardo_da_Vinci,_from_C2RMF_retouched.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Mona_Lisa,_by_Leonardo_da... Resolution 7,479 × 11,146, or 83 megapixels. From that page: The official position taken by the Wikimedia Foundation is that "faithful reproductions of two-dimensional public domain works of art are public domain". This photographic reproduction is therefore also considered to be in the public domain in the United States. In other jurisdictions, re-use of this content may be restricted; see Reuse of PD-Art photographs for details.
- FireBeyond 5y agoTo be pedantic, though. Just because the WMF (through its counsel, presumably) "takes a position", doesn't infer that "therefore" this piece is public domain. It may well be, but unless the WMF created the piece, it has no standing to declare this. I may well be reading too much into things, but I know also that the WMF has taken "interesting" legal positions on art (a famous recent photo set up by a wildlife photographer where a curious primate, IIRC, wandered up to the camera and depressed the shutter).
- knorker 5y ago
- captaincaveman 5y agoNo, you are not granted copyrights on the image attached to the NFT in all cases I've looked at, spoken to the people behind them and they also agreed. Doesn't mean this can't be done, but in each case I've looked at, granting of rights (and which specific rights do we even mean?) is not happening. Further more there is no obligation for anyone to do anything with the image linked to the NFT your the holder of.
- naasking 5y agoCopyright is a right defined in existing legal systems. I said the NFT defines a new type of right in a new pseudo-legal system.
- 6510 5y agomind blown! We could have as many opt-in legal systems as we want! Like a ball to go with the chain.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoA right isn't a legal system
- captaincaveman 5y agoyeaah I don't think that's a thing.
- FireBeyond 5y agoAnd if I infringe upon these new rights, do I get pseudo-sued in this pseudo-legal system?