4 ms·
" we've let a bunch of politicians and cable TV/internet/podcast hacks claim that it's not serious so that a significant fraction of the population ends up acti
by giantg2 5y ago
" we've let a bunch of politicians and cable TV/internet/podcast hacks claim that it's not serious so that a significant fraction of the population ends up actively spreading the disease and providing reservoirs for it to mutate."
This is sort of a half truth. You can still spread it if vaccinated.
- davrosthedalek 5y agoYes, and you can still die with a seatbelt on. But a vaccine makes it less likely that you get it (can't spread it if you didn't get it), less likely to spread it (fewer days sick, smaller viral load, ability to self isolate because still functioning, not requiring outside assistance to not die).
- giantg2 5y agoIt seems we're in agreement - it was a half truth to target one group for the blame when clearly others are also contributing.
- mannykannot 5y agoYou are implying a symmetry that does not exist: one group is doing what it can to help, the other is not.
- giantg2 5y agoAre they though? I agree that there is not symmetry. There are many groups, doing many different activities. There are plenty of vaccinated people who are done with masking, done with isolation, and going out in public or traveling. While there are also people who caught covid while doing a necessary job before a vaccine was required. It's false to create only two groups. This completely ignores symmetry, undermining your entire argument of saying I'm ignoring it.
- mannykannot 5y agoI see you want to be pedantic: >It's false to create only two groups. That claim is not even a half-truth... >This completely ignores symmetry ... and this would not follow even if it were. [Update moved to a subsequent reply.]
- giantg2 5y ago">It's false to create only two groups. That claim is not even a half-truth." Would you like to expand on that? There clearly are numerous different groups providing a variety of permutations of risk taking or risk avoiding actions. ">This completely ignores symmetry ... and this would not follow even if it were." Would you like to explain this too? It appears to me that two artificial groups were formed and then used in a false dichotomy. I'm not being pedantic. Attacking a large number of people in a heterogeneous, artificial group is disingenuous when a moderate to large number of the people in that group may not even exhibit the risks claimed, while wholly ignoring the risks posed by the "good" group.
- mannykannot 5y agoI see there was a data race in my editing, so I will move my update here: Beyond that, it is consistent with every factual claim you have made to say that the population lies on a broad spectrum of how thoroughly they are contributing to ameliorating the impact of this epidemic on the population as a whole. Your own argument is predicated on this spectrum being divisible into two populations. My point is that, wherever you make that divide, one group is helping more than the other. With regard to your specific questions here: 1) Putting aside the abstruse issue around the axiom of choice (which is not relevant here) one can always create two groups, and in my expanded reply, I made a relevant, non-pedantic case for that. 2) There are more symmetries than dichotomous ones. Also: > while wholly ignoring the risks posed by the "good" group. With words like 'wholly' and 'false', you are making straw man arguments. It is factually accurate and completely reasonable to say that some people are net contributors to public health, while others have the opposite effect.
- aardvarkr 5y agoYou’re blatantly ignoring logic here just to make yourself feel better. Vaccinated people catch the disease 90% less with 90% less viral load and somehow you’re equating that to an unvaccinated person’s ability to catch and spread the disease. Ridiculous. Vaccinating saves lives and reduces the spread.
- giantg2 5y agoYou seem to be ignoring the various permutations of the situation. How about people with natural immunity, which some studies suggest is as food or better? It seems you are ignoring scenarios to avoid cognitive dissonance. 90% is not 100%, it's not logical to assign 100% of the blame.
- t0bia_s 5y agoThat is debunked lie repeated like mantra in mass media. Omicron is spreading same for vaccinated or not. Gibraltar, Ireland, Portugal data proofs that... Inform yourself, please and do not repeat fantasies. Vaccines are designed to help with reducing death risk for mutations that are not here anymore.