4 ms·
> was always silly. That statement is in the same line as "we really dont know" ?
by mistrial9 5y ago
> was always silly.
That statement is in the same line as "we really dont know" ?
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe long-term impact of either one cannot be conclusively determined in the short-term, barring the invention of time travel. "I will not take the vaccine because there are no long-term studies" is silly because it's inconsistent. "I will not take the vaccine and I will not get COVID" isn't a reliable option, so it's largely a choice between two unknowns. That leaves us having to make educated guesses. Based on the history of vaccination, the safety thus far of nearly 10 billion doses of vaccine administered, and stuff like the biology and half-life of mRNA, the choice seems fairly clear.
- giantg2 5y agoThat's a false dichotomy. You can be vaccinated and get covid since the vaccine only prevents serious illness (and as this study says, you don't need to be serious ill to have these elevated risks). So it's not an either/or. With the soon to be endemic status, it's most probably 1) catch covid while unvaccinated 2) catch covid while vaccinated 3) very unlikely but not catch covid with either vaccination status.
- realreality 5y agoYou're making a false dichotomy, ignoring the existence of other treatments, the fact that 50-80% of infections are asymptomatic, and the fact that cross-immunity from previous coronaviruses means many people may never develop COVID, even if they are exposed.
- twofornone 5y agoNo, it's really not so clear if you take a more objective look. First off, the history of vaccination is irrelevant, because this is a novel technology. Second, the short half life of mRNA does not guarantee that there are no long term effects. Third, you are ignoring that in this choice between "two unknowns", the probability of getting symptomatic covid (presumably asymptomatic/mild covid is unlikely to cause heart issues) is less than 1. The probability of exposure to the vaccine for a vaccinated person is 1. Fourth, unlike exposure to covid in young, healthy people, the vaccine guarantees that your tissues are exposed to a rapid megadose of an inflammatory protein, manufactured in isolation, as opposed to an infection where the protein is attached to the rest of the virus and exposure ramps up gradually. That's my personal concern and I feel like its being swept under the rug. There is a nonzero risk of autoimmune disorders which will be difficult to detect, especially if past preprints regarding expression of the spike protein in human tissues post vaccination prove to be true. Finally: >The long-term impact of either one cannot be conclusively determined in the short-term, barring the invention of time travel Right, which is why vaccine trials normally take 5-10 years and "safe and effective" has been a campaign of transparent propaganda. Numerous past vaccines have been pulled from the market for fewer side effects. Combine that with the stigma against reporting side effects/speaking against the vaccines, the fact that the actual safety trial data is a secret known only to pfizer/moderna and the FDA, the rumors that adverse event collection during clinical trials was (deliberately?) inadequate, the history of big pharma deliberately harming consumers in pursuit of profits, the full protection of pfizer et al from liability, and the assertion that covid is less of a problem than it has been made out to be (especially with recent data on omicron), no, the choice is not clear at all if you have not been taken in by the propaganda. Edit: let's also remember that the claims of both safety and effectiveness have been repeatedly revised, and multiple points of "misinformation" have been proven correct. So on top of all this it should be clear that our institutions are not deserving of the amount of trust that people like you are placing in them. The executive branch wanted a vaccine yesterday, the FDA suspended typical testing protocols for what amounts to a rubber stamp, and now we are the safety trials. Not even getting into our sudden collective amnesia regarding regulatory capture.
- kareemm 5y agoGenuinely curious about these. Can you cite sources? > There is a nonzero risk of autoimmune disorders which will be difficult to detect, especially if past preprints regarding expression of the spike protein in human tissues post vaccination prove to be true. Which preprints? Why do you say autoimmune disorders have a nonzero risk and will be difficult to detect? > actual safety trial data is a secret known only to pfizer/moderna and the FDA Do you have a source? > multiple points of "misinformation" have been proven correct. Which points of misinformation are now correct?
- JSavageOne 5y agoThe infection fatality rate (not to be confused with case fatality rate) is about 0.2%, and only statistically significant for old people >60 and those with comorbidities. Anecdotally no one I know including myself who doesn't fall in these buckets experienced worse than a week of flu symptoms. The vaccines are only shown to last about 6 months, and even then aren't even effective with the latest variants. I don't think it's unreasonable for a healthy person under 60 years of age with no comorbidities to opt out of the vaccine (or the flu vaccine, which actually is deadlier than people think, yet nobody cares about your flu vaccination).