7 ms·
Why limit it to crypto? People don't question why the value of houses seems to magically rise globally despite no tangible value being added to the assets in mo
by globular-toast 5y ago
Why limit it to crypto? People don't question why the value of houses seems to magically rise globally despite no tangible value being added to the assets in most cases. People don't question why Wall Street traders get rich by trading second derivatives of mortgage backed securities with each other all day. What makes a mortgage any more "real" than an NFT?
- blfr 5y agoPeople question it all the time. And a house has obvious utility. It's also kind of a share in the city's future. It can be mispriced but it's not entirely based on hype.
- globular-toast 5y agoI'm not talking about the houses, though. I'm talking about mortgages. Have you ever wondered why you can't just save up for a house and buy it with cash? Why do you need to first acquire this thing called a mortgage? What part is the bank actually playing in this transaction? You'll pay tax to them for 30 years but what exactly are you getting in return? These are the questions that need to be asked.
- rchaud 5y agoHouses are acquired in cash all the time. There is no legal requirement to tie oneself to a mortgage, if you already have the means to pay the price in full.
- fusionbro 5y agoThe reason people aren't buying a home in cash, which is not necessarily common but completely doable and not illegal or anything, is because almost no one can afford to do so. Saving for 30 years and then buying a house in cash all while paying rent somewhere in the meantime I think is pretty undesirable.
- pjc50 5y ago> Have you ever wondered why you can't just save up for a house and buy it with cash? You can. > What part is the bank actually playing in this transaction? They're lending you the money. I assume you have some different, less obvious answers to this? If you're against the lending of money for interest, how about a halal mortgage? https://www.qardus.com/news/halal-mortgages-everything-you-need-to-know https://www.qardus.com/news/halal-mortgages-everything-you-n...
- globular-toast 5y ago> You can. Practically speaking, not really. A tiny fraction of people might earn enough to save enough to buy a house, but most will be priced out at every stage by people taking mortgages. Some people inherit existing property and trade it for other property. But if you are starting from scratch it's virtually impossible. Do you know anyone who has done it? > They're lending you the money. Are they? If I lend you my car, I don't have access to my car during that time. But money is just made up. There's nothing moving around. Banks aren't losing anything when they lend you something. They just create a deposit and a liability and get on with it. As long as they are all doing it at roughly the same rate nothing stops the economy filling up on debt, as it has done and continues to do. Remember, banks lending money is nothing like you or I lending money. The banks control the ledger. They don't play by the same rules as us.
- blfr 5y agoYeah, states usually do grant banks a limited right to create money. But once again, this is not based on hype. These states often have sovereignty, land, allegiance of their citizens, recognized legitimacy, police force, serviceable tax regimes, tanks, etc.
- globular-toast 5y agoSo you're making an argument to the status quo? I'm not sure are about states granting banks the right to create money. Do you have a source for this? As far as I can tell they do it simply because we all use them and trust them to keep the ledger. The state (meaning, the US or UK) doesn't seem to have much control over it.
- dboreham 5y agoThe magical value of houses has been a concern for decades (see numerous housing crash episodes) but there is a difference: the payment stream from a mortgage is enforced by laws and backed by the ability to take ownership of the mortgaged property. Perhaps a better comparison would be NFT vs mortgage _insurance_.
- fusionbro 5y agoNot sure it's so magical. If you own a home in a city whose GDP is increasing every year it makes some sense that property in that city would also increase in value.
- sakarisson 5y agoYou can live in a house, you can't live in an NFT.
- tomatocracy 5y agoYes. NFTs are perhaps more akin to people who sell "plots of land" on the moon or Mars.
- scottiebarnes 5y agoNFTs are more like Lebron James rookie cards. A piece of cardboard print with graphics on it, no rights to the image, art, athlete or organization.
- cuteboy19 5y agoThe scarcity of houses is real and physical. The scarcity of NFTs is artificial, completely made up.
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago> The scarcity of houses is real and physical Not really in a lot of cities, most scarcity is based on government regulations (=not allowing more of them to be built, or not allowed to build larger ones). There are a few locations where there is no actual usable space to build more, but mostly, that is not an issue.
- notahacker 5y agoThe scarcity of land is physical. And to supply more housing you need to pay for the ownership of physical assets, and then for people to physically demolish them and physically build bigger structures, which is a lot of expensive to take if the demand for property doesn't already exceed its supply Or you could create more "limited edition" monkey pictures at essentially zero marginal cost.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoThere are a lot of places where there is enough land to build more and more, but the governments don't allow it. And there are also places such as san-francisco, where replacing single-family houses with apartment buildings would solve a lot of the housing crisis, but the government (and NIMBYs) don't allow it.
- notahacker 5y agoEven in a world with zero building regulation you're still running into constraints though. Sure, people could build more apartments which would slow growth in accommodation prices and maybe directly hurt the value of the neighbours' properties they overshadow, but land is still limited amd expensive (more expensive if you're allowed to build tenement blocks on it) and construction still physically intensive and expensive, so there's still no incentive to drive prices down by supplying more apartments than the market demands. cf NFTs where digital art itself can be copied and viewed infinitely, and the NFTs themselves are just tokens issued at near zero cost by providers which could happily issue infinitely more tokens referencing the same art (even though at the moment, for the sake of trust and collectibility and not dampening the hype yet, it's more lucrative to issue finite numbers of additional tokens referring to more low-effort variations on the original art instead.)
- posix_me_less 5y agoMortgage means somebody is going to pay somebody else regularly for 30 years, or bank gets a valuable property. That is more reliable wealth guarrantee than NFTs are.
- ARandumGuy 5y agoThis seems like a classic whataboutism. Mortgages being bad or good has absolutely no bearing on the quality of cryptocurrencies or NFTs. If crypto was actually good, you shouldn't need to deflect criticism with "but the existing financial sector also sucks!"
- globular-toast 5y agoIt's not a deflection. I'm saying the whole thing is a disaster. Crypto and NFTs are just the surface and are quite rightly causing people to question the meaning of it all. But if you dig a little deeper you'll find it's just an extension of what's been going on for a long time behind closed doors. I thoroughly recommend the book Other People's Money by John Kay. In it he reminds us what the actual value of the financial system is and talks about what it has become. Bitcoin was an attempt to get the actual value of cash (just one facets of finance) without paying tax (interest) to the banks.