4 ms·
My dream scenario: Several open source vendors get tired of Amazon taking their innovation, repackaging, and reselling it. They band together to create the str
by echelon 5y ago
My dream scenario:
Several open source vendors get tired of Amazon taking their innovation, repackaging, and reselling it. They band together to create the strictest open source license ever. Stricter than AGPL3: "If you run this as PAAS, your entire PAAS down to the billing layer must be open. Every ounce of your code. Even the internal employee management bits. Maybe you're allowed a budget of 30kloc secret blob sauce, but that's it."
It should also say: "All billing reports must be instantaneous, easy to understand, and attributable to the products and the teams that use them." And: "Egress should never cost more than ingress, and high quality export tools must be provided for every service offered."
Use this as the foundation to build a fully open source cloud platform with the tools anyone could use to stand up their own data centers.
It would be a dream to see cloud reduced to commodity. Then open source vendors could make good money on support contracts, focusing on the software they love building rather than being eaten out of house and home by the giants.
- jacob019 5y agoIt is infuriating how the these companies have managed to appropriate open source for profit. I would be pissed if my unpaid hard work community contributions were being appropriated to make Bezos richer while harming the OSS ecosystem that I love. That said, I don't think that more restrictive licensing is the answer. I don't know the answer TBH.
- Jtsummers 5y agoWhy would you be pissed if you gave away your work? Don't give it away under a license that permits commercial use if you don't want it to be used (freely) to make money by others.
- jacob019 5y agoBecause the are selling your work for profit without giving anything back to the community.
- markus_zhang 5y agoTBH if it's not in tge contract I would not really blame them. Change your license then.
- saimiam 5y agoI sense that you haven’t fully internalized the idea of some of the popular open source licenses. Such licenses are a bit like letting go of a balloon. Most times, the balloon will float away and pop on some tree with no benefit to anyone. In a few rare occasions, your obnoxious neighborhood kid will grab that balloon and play with it all afternoon. You might not like that the kid is enjoying your balloon but no right minded person would expect that the kid’s parents recompense you for the balloon you let go willingly. TBF, not long ago, someone posted on HN that AWS simply used their open source ware without even a thank you. It created quite a bit of noise on HN, so your opinion isn’t too far outside the norm.
- willcipriano 5y agoIt's more like setting up a little reading library. Have you seen those? People build little dollhouses and fill them with books with the idea that anyone can grab one and donate back when they can. It's mostly to encourage children to read. Now imagine Amazon comes by and lists the books in the reading library on it's website for sale. You offered them for free after all. Further they are knocking on your door obnoxiously asking you when you are going to get a particular book in stock, since they have a customer who wants it.
- trelane 5y agoI won't comment on the other licenses, but the point of the GPL is _user empowerment._ The origin is that Stallmann had a broken printer but was not able to fix it due to it having a proprietary driver.[1] It's not at all about ensuring support (or preventing profit). It's all about ensuring the end user (even if that end user is 37 steps away from the original author!) has _all_ the rights to do anything with the software that they would like. Quite a lot of the time the user may not be able or want to use the rights granted them, but that doesn't make those rights useless. Indeed, they serve an important function, see the various offshoots of that early Linksys WRT code! It saddens me greatly that so many have lost sight of this. [1] https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/201cthe-printer-story201d-redux-a-testimonial-about-the-injustice-of-proprietary-firmware https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/201cthe-printer-story201...
- theamk 5y agoWhy not? Licensing is designed exactly for that purpose. When you choose an MIT/BSD license, you are giving an express permission for other to profit from your code and give you nothing back. It's not like it is new or something.. I remember reading the same discussions back in 2000's, when people discovered that Windows used parts of BSD's network stack.
- jacob019 5y agoHistorically, when businesses adopted open source software they would contribute upstream. Cloud vendors changed that model. It's interesting that attitudes about this behavior have changed.
- theamk 5y agoThey did? Which fraction of bash users (for example) contributed anything upstream? I am betting significatly less than 1%. I am not sure why people suddenly get outraged about cloud. Most webhosting providers in the last 20 years had business criticaly dependent on Linux kernel and Apache. Almost none of them contibuted anything to those projects. And people were not complaining.
- rmbyrro 5y agoI suspect there's an ideological influence to this weird outrageousness. But I'm probably wrong.
- jabl 5y agoBack then OSS was more volunteer labor based, or red hat style business models based on support contracts etc. So there was maybe less expectation of monetizing OSS directly. These days the conflict seems to be about big cloud vendors productizing OSS code made by SaaS vendors, thus directly competing with them. It seems more like an economic argument (we want to get paid for the OSS we create) dressed up as an ideological one (OSS is about community, or whatever).
- 5y ago
- theamk 5y agoIn the first paragraph, you are describing SSPL license, adopted by MongoDB and ElasticSearch. So far, it has not been used to build fully open source cloud platform. Instead, it has been used (with limited success) to ensure that people who want to run ElasticSearch in the cloud have only one choice, going to Elastic NV.
- oneplane 5y agoNone of that is commercially viable (so far), and commercial activity really doesn't benefit from this at all. What matters is the 'stuff' you get for your money. AWS knows this (as does Azure and GCP), as do the B2B customers. It's just a simple sum. Either the customer does more of the hard but generic work, or the provider does more of the hard (generic) work. You make two calculations (including potential benefits of vertical integration) and you pick what works best. "Inventing" generic compute with an API, web console and service-wide IAM is possible, but adds no value at all to say, e-commerce. So you might as well just pay some vendor to already do that, and if possible to do it at a scale and quality you will never be able to reach as a single business anyway. So you go to a cloud since that already has it and you can't replicate it anyway. If it turns out to be expensive but still cheaper and better, that's a win, OSS/SSPL be damned.
- sylens 5y agoYou are describing the SSPL, which people on this website (not me) have loudly cried about as being a proprietary license