4 ms·
I subscribed to Forbes for a few years in the 1980s. Not because it had any decent journalism as far as I could tell but because it just seemed so deranged it
by gumby 5y ago
I subscribed to Forbes for a few years in the 1980s. Not because it had any decent journalism as far as I could tell but because it just seemed so deranged it was fun to read. The regular columnists were mostly (but not all) a collection of lazy Ayn Rand acolytes (I mean Rand acolytes are nuts, but the ones in Forbes back then didn't even try), a few old fashion racists (Hanke, Brimelow), and the odd thinker with an opinion piece on a topic I'd already read to death somewhere else. The "articles" were mostly reflexive genuflection to people who'd somehow acquired wealth. It's as if the entire operation consisted of people who were simply phoning it in.
It astonished me that when they switched to being a blog site it actually appeared that standards had fallen.
BTW I dumped Forbes and kept the UK magazine The Spectator. It was and is full of lazy rightwing rubbish too (though of a different strain) but has much more variety (had personal ads for a while) and the level of writing itself was generally quite high, in particular while Boris Johnson was editor (I know, that seems hard to believe).
Unfortunately these days I struggle to find a right wing, much less left wing, journal-of-rants that's worth bothering to read.
- ggm 5y agoThis to me exemplifies "read outside the bubble, think critically" -I also read the other point of view. I find it jarring, bizarre, assumptions from topsy-turvy land but this always makes me think "yea, thats what they'd say about you too mate" It is hard to find good, rational, oppositional writing. Its so easy to find pretty ranty, bad oppositional writing. Really? I increasingly think editorial, and somebody supervising the pub/comment is best. I know, I know, its not very "trendy" but man, wading through the dreck of people like me, commenting like me: it's killing it. If you want an example, "comment is free" in the Guardian. Its an insider-bubble. Reddit is just as bad. Heaps of pile-ons. I want to read serious, committed, christian-right points of view who believe charity, modesty and a gun solve all the problems of america, and I don't want to wade through trumpy shit to find it. (contextually it should be clear I am not christian, right, or believe in charity over taxes) Murdoch blew it. The Australian has become delusionally bad. I still think centerist-right papers like the Independent can do ok, I read german news, and RT, and WashPo when I can, and graze links of Drudge. He is as crazy as a loon but he kind-of finds things I can read. Slate is crap. I don't need guides to washing my purple love machine. Politico and TheHill are ok, sometimes but annoying videos. Is TheAtlantic soft-pop right? Feels it.
- zaphod12 5y agoInteresting the Atlantic is considered to skew left
- gumby 5y agoLike The Spectator, The Atlantic has been around for over a century (Speccie must be close to 200) so such things have drifted around for a while. Genteely apolitical papers like The New Yorker are less likely to; papers written for a cause (such as The Economist) are more likely to retain some political consistency for more than a century. I agree though: the Atlantic's position is hardly left wing except in comparison with, say, Fox News or The Wall Street Journal.
- ggm 5y agoA lot of 1940s/50s/60s/70s views of what left-right means, have been broken for decades. Reagan would not be alt-right. He was pretty far right to me economically and politically. There are socialist economists who still respect the chicago school, god alone knows how. MMT is killing it for a lot of rightist people even though its pure keynesian. (if you call anything modern, its suddenly ok?) We fling "kleptocracy" pretty hard at modern Russia. I find it passing strange that we don't look in a mirror sometimes. We berate china for insisting that schools teach history aligned to their own political system values. Isn't that almost exactly what the religious-right wants to do in the USA? It's a myth often repeated that the financial times has a marxist editorial. Certainly it's printed on pink paper, so there's that. And a lot of marxist economosts read it. I tend to think money-journalism tells the least lies, it generally doesn't work when you do. All other journalism, I am less sure but maybe its Gell-Mann Amnesia?
- gumby 5y ago> And a lot of marxist economosts read [the FT]. Marxists, Keynesians, the Austrians, “neoliberals” and Friedman all base their vocabulary and fundamentals on the labor theory of value and an economic model based on the Victorian industrial economy, which we no longer have and which was already visibly on its way out 25 years ago. I haven’t seen any good writing (not that I’m steeped in the literature) that rethinks these fundamentals. MMT is pretty bogus but to its credit nodes at least revisit some of the fundamentals.
- mistrial9 5y agoI read the American Spectator for a year or so. William F. Buckley Jr. was a regular there, if I recall. I was young so a lot of the thirst for battle was lost on me. However the quality of writing was undeniably high, and for the first time, as a lover of literature but basically in a very liberal bubble, I got the sense that there was a kind of intelligence that I really was missing. I didnt care about Left or Right affiliation at that time. Forbes at the same time seemed like more Hollywood in print, idolizing all things money. Sort of ridiculous to my mind, with expensive looking ads, and pretty decent typesetting for a magazine. Hard to describe the print world today among all the phone users and instant news everything.
- gumby 5y agoBTW that American Spectator was a completely unrelated magazine, not that that implies that there is anything wrong with it!
- ggm 5y agoI can't handle the British Spectator editorial. It's pretty unashamedly what it is, which I suppose is the point, but it's too depressing. Given the past editors, you would want to think its tolerably accurate to the desires in the heart of the UK Tory party. Perhaps I am alone in finding wry amusement that Michael Heseltine cannot but be considered left-wing now. Sure, he was always a "wet" but he was still a member of the Thatcher cabinet, and all it stood for. Well.. right up until the Westland Helicopter business. The spectator doesn't like him. I think that speaks volumes.
- Tomte 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20110805101637/http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/221039/great-lives/william-f-buckley-jr# https://web.archive.org/web/20110805101637/http://www.nation... is a very well-written review by him. It's the only piece by him that I have read, I think, and when I read his name it immediately jumped to my mind.
- zeruch 5y agoI still stick to the FT, occasional Economist, and then a bunch of specialized academic stuff. Forbes and Fortune were interesting in the 80s (in many ways they epitomized the 80s) but declined rapidly from there. By the dot com bubble they were a bit of a punchline with no setup.
- User23 5y agoBased on your tastes you might find Takimag and the Unz Review entertaining.
- jim-jim-jim 5y agoTaki Mag is my conservative rag of choice. I enjoy it because it's the most honest reflection of popular right-wing sentiment (it's racist). Has funny writers I can't help but like, like Ann Coulter and Jim Goad. As far as the left goes, I've really been enjoying Red Sails recently, though it's basically two peoples' blog. Lots of well written pieces from an explicitly Marxist-Leninist perspective, which agree or disagree, is way more interesting than the "AOC/Bernie said X" snoozefests Jacobin churns out these days.
- User23 5y agoEveryone who’s anyone on the left reads Sailer’s Takimag column regularly. It’s pretty funny. Although in my opinion he’s most entertaining when he nerds out on golf course design and moneyball. Red Sails is a great recommendation. Thanks! Do you happen to know a good English language magazine or blog for Xi Jinping Thought? As far as I can tell Marxism/Leninism is just an historical curiosity, but Socialism with Chinese Characteristics is a truly effective if not palatable living Communist system.
- jim-jim-jim 5y agoMaybe I was not precise enough with my language when I said ML. The people at Red Sails are very optimistic about Chinese socialism. They express this in their own pieces, but also share translations from Chinese figures.
- ggm 5y agoI loved "China Reconstructs" -the highest form of art was always there. I have a very tatty print of "the village fish-pond" -even the carp are smiling.
- gumby 5y agoBTW Taki was a regular in the Spectator of the 90s.
- sireat 5y agoAs an ex-Soviet teenager I loved reading Forbes in the early 90s. Thomas Sowell was my jam. The business success stories were so addicting. It was the time when their advertising slogans were: "Meet Michael Dell. He started reading Forbes at 19". So obviously I wanted success by association. As time moved on (and I moved away from Randism) I read Forbes less and less. I noticed that online standards were much looser than print. What really shocked me when the local (Easter European) print edition of Forbes had a glowing article about a disgraced kleptocrats wife. It was so obviously paid for and below any standards of journalism. So I started thinking whether my early positive opinions of Forbes were somewhat clouded by my youth. EDIT: It seems only New Yorker has stayed true to its quality. That is the articles do not try to outrage you and give respectable space to multiple viewpoints. As in after reading an article about fracking in a small town you would not be gathering pitchforks nor wishing for a private market solution. Just mild and considerate.