3 ms·
> If so, why hasn't all the journalist unions he see forming already restricted the number of journalists and increased their wages? They tried. Unions have a
by bluGill 5y ago
> If so, why hasn't all the journalist unions he see forming already restricted the number of journalists and increased their wages?
They tried. Unions have a hard time stopping the supply of free labor. We have a first amendment which limits their legal means to passing laws that other unions have. We also don't have the safety dangers of plumbing or electric that give laws restricting supply some legitimacy.
Unions work best when (among other factors) everyone has a feeling that they are not better than the others and can substitute for each others. Writing fails this in general because writers want to have their own voice. You want everyone to know it was you writing, and a guest writer will have a different voice and different ideas. Note that in corporate writing the above doesn't apply and so unions are more likely to have a place (but corporate writing is mostly by marketing and probably better paid and so the union doesn't really have as much to do and so there is less reason to pay those dues)
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>They tried. Unions have a hard time stopping the supply of free labor. We have a first amendment which limits their legal means to passing laws that other unions have. We also don't have the safety dangers of plumbing or electric that give laws restricting supply some legitimacy. I think the bigger hurdle is that the people they'd need to convince, politicians, are by nature of their profession, very well versed in public messaging and "journalist adjacent" skills and deal with journalists on the regular and therefore very likely to say "lolno" to any request for a moat of regulatory capture. Plumbers and electricians would never have been able to get the regulatory capture they have if the people they needed sign off from had been equally well versed in their skills and exposed to dealing with them.
- bwestergard 5y agoDid you know the sector with the sharpest rise in union membership last year was media? "Among the industries with a growing share of union membership is journalism, where 33 workplaces voted last year to organize with labor unions, according to Poynter, the media industry news outlet. In 2021, employees at Politico, Forbes, The Atlantic and Insider all joined NewsGuild, while journalists at MSNBC voted to organize with the Writers Guild of America East." https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/590631-union-membership-hits-new-low https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/590631-union-member...
- Ekaros 5y agoWhen your skills are replaceable you have very little leverage. Journalist are certainly a field where these days you can be easily replaced even by possibly unpaid intern. Only if you have build a name and grinded it out you have some leverage. Thus union is little help if you could just fire your entire staff and pay a few editors to hire new people.
- throwaway2037 5y agoI understand the sentiment of your post. Zero trolling: For a very high quality pool of journalists and writers at The New Yorker, do you think that also applies? I hold the opinion that certain media outlets have out-sized caché (attraction) in their country's culture and are able to "punch about their weight" and draw incredible talent for the wages. It is almost like an inverted veblen good! Examples that come to mind: The New York Times, The New Yorker, The New York Review of Books, The Economist, The Financial Times, Le Monde, Nikkei Shimbun, Der Speigel, and Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. Re-reading that list before clicking 'reply', I wonder if all of them have strong employee unions. It seems possible. EDIT: What about public radio and television in highly advanced democracies? It is a pretty similar situation. High quality staff, peanuts for wages, but they don't have commercial pressures. US, Europe, Japan, Korea, Taiwan all have outstanding, neutral public broadcasters. (Queue the 1000x naysayers that will say "Oh, it's never been worse -- see recent scandal XYZ".) Is the answer: Gov't funded (taxes) public broadcasters that cover news that struggles to make money in the private sector? Maybe.
- rjsw 5y agoITYM "cachet" not "caché".
- e4e78a06 5y ago> Journalist are certainly a field where these days you can be easily replaced even by possibly unpaid intern Only if you're a median journalist. If you're a top 1% caliber journalist you're not replaceable. It's much like software engineering, social media influencers, and Hollywood in that regard. 10x skill gap between median and top and heavily bimodal comp model as a result.