3 ms·
I guess the real question is, will a dollar spent on wheelchair ramps in buildings across the USA give a greater quality of life improvement to the average amer
by londons_explore 5y ago
I guess the real question is, will a dollar spent on wheelchair ramps in buildings across the USA give a greater quality of life improvement to the average american than a dollar spent on medical research that tries to repair spinal nerves?
Obviously "average american" is not intended to reflect the 'typical american', but instead be an average across all people, including those with mobility requirements.
- Tsiklon 5y agoThe distinction is that the quality of life improvement can be done now, and can make peoples' lives better immediately. It's not just wheelchair users that can make use of accessible infrastructure, the elderly, and young children can more readily make use of it too. I don't discount the promise or effect of such research, but the utilitarian in me says that this can make a tangible improvement now, and to more people and not at an indeterminate point in the future.
- londons_explore 5y agoThere are plenty of such tradeoffs... For example, the government could start a helicopter service to help people cross a river today, or they could build a bridge across the river, which will help far more people, but won't be ready for 5 years. I assume governments have models to make decisions about utility now vs utility later, and the way that trades off with cost now vs cost later. I don't see why this decision shouldn't just use those models and spend the money on whatever the models say makes sense.
- afarrell 5y ago> I assume governments have models to make decisions about utility now vs utility later, and the way that trades off with cost now vs cost later. I'm curious where this assumption comes from. It seems more likely that it would be made on intuition of what story will seem most defensible to voters or avoid the angry scrutiny of a legislator. If decisions were made with the high level of rationality you point to, it seems unlikely that the US would have problems like this: - https://pittsburgh.cbslocal.com/2022/02/07/pittsburgh-warning-signs-fern-hollow-bridge-collapse/ https://pittsburgh.cbslocal.com/2022/02/07/pittsburgh-warnin... - https://www.marketwatch.com/story/it-is-a-challenge-the-irs-wants-more-staff-to-cut-its-backlog-but-25k-salaries-arent-going-to-draw-job-seekers-watchdog-says-11644362209 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/it-is-a-challenge-the-irs-... - https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-announces-transition-away-from-use-of-third-party-verification-involving-facial-recognition https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-announces-transition-away-f... ---------------- Looking at your username lets consider a question such as "Should we pay additional money to design London's new Elizabeth Line with step-free access at all stations?" for such a model to answer such questions, we would need a way to accurately count costs. If could do that, then the line would already be open.
- dundarious 5y agoGiven perfect hindsight that we have now, at any point in the 20th century you would have to respond "yes, you should also fund accessibility right away" . The answer today is almost certainly the same. Never mind that there are reasons to need accessibility beyond spinal injuries.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> will a dollar spent on wheelchair ramps in buildings across the USA give a greater quality of life improvement to the average american than a dollar spent on medical research that tries to repair spinal nerves? Yes, I don’t know why this is even a question. Ramps support people who will never need spinal nerve repair. They support strollers, wheeled luggage, canes, crutches, fall risk folks, furniture movers, bike/scooters, etc.
- londons_explore 5y agoBut medical research leads to treatments which may have far better quality of life improvements than ramps. And when discovered, those treatments can be used forever, whereas ramps require constant spending for every new or renovated building. Both are 'obviously' better than the other, depending on what you look at. Therefore the decision really should be made with more data.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoIt’s not obviously better because you’re solving for one case when a ramp solves for multiple. At no point does solving nerve damage fix the fact a baby in a stroller has a better time on a ramp, unless you’re proposing a new technology that obviates wheels. But that just makes it the new ramp in its utility.
- mwcampbell 5y ago> But medical research leads to treatments which may have far better quality of life improvements than ramps. And when discovered, those treatments can be used forever, whereas ramps require constant spending for every new or renovated building. I think you make a good point here. Likewise, making software accessible, e.g. to blind people, requires effort for every GUI toolkit and non-trivial application. In the short term, that work has to be done, because it would be wrong to just leave blind people without a way to independently access software that might be critical to jobs, education, etc. But if we started funding research into curing or preventing all of the various causes of blindness now, then we could eventually solve the problem permanently. I'd have to find a different problem domain to work in, but I might be retired by then anyway.
- paledot 5y agoAnd spina bifida, and cerebral palsy, and strokes, and diabetes, and broken bones, and arthritis, and being pregnant, and just getting old, and literally hundreds of other disorders that cause temporary or permanent impairment. By the time you're finished fixing the reasons people encounter mobility issues, we'll be darn near immortal - and you still won't have magicked away the reasons that able-bodied people benefit from universal design.
- drekk 5y agoI don't know why this has to be framed as an either/or. The US doesn't invest in infrastructure but leads in medical patents, so the low hanging fruit is being ignored. It is cheaper to build ramps than fund good longitudinal scientific research. Also you can have perfect spinal nerves and benefit from accessible infrastructure. Parents with infants in strollers, for example. Ideally you would build the infrastructure /while/ allowing things like stem cell research but we live in a puritanical theocracy that opposes both for ideological reasons