3 ms·
> We know from the Snowden revalations that their technical capability in 2008 (he only exposed info on things that were already old, his intent was to show ill
by lmm 5y ago
> We know from the Snowden revalations that their technical capability in 2008 (he only exposed info on things that were already old, his intent was to show illegal surveillance not capability remember) was such that they had some kind of access to every conceivable device on the planet and the majority of communication that went through the US.
We know they had access to every centralised provider's servers (including Google and any other company you care to name). We also know that they couldn't break post-DES cryptosystems when properly used - indeed NSA employees expressed considerable frustration about the fact that they couldn't break PGP-encrypted emails or chats and had to resort to metadata analysis, social engineering, hacking individual users and so on.
> 1) Telegram is weak, NSA has access
> 2) Telegram is strong, NSA does not have acces
It's not a binary. Most attacks on cryptosystems reduce the amount of work it takes to break in rather than making it completely free. And even if the NSA theoretically has access, that doesn't mean they can predict an attack or will share that data with every contry/agency/company. We know the NSA was reading all unencrypted emails up until at least 2012 or so, yet there was plenty of crime committed and discussed over email during that period.
(I'm no fan of Signal or the way it's marketed, quite the opposite, but I trust Telegram far less)
- trasz 5y ago>NSA was reading all unencrypted emails up until at least 2012 or so, yet there was plenty of crime NSA is not a law enforcement agency; they don’t care about crime.