4 ms·
I agree with your take on the doctor heuristic. But there is also the worry that the patient won't call back for longer than they should, and the underlying di
by kelnos 5y ago
I agree with your take on the doctor heuristic. But there is also the worry that the patient won't call back for longer than they should, and the underlying disease could have a chance to get a lot worse in that time. If a doctor really isn't doing any basic diagnostic work, and is just telling people "take some aspirin, and call back if it doesn't go away after X days", that is still IMO negligent. If I have cancer, I don't want to wait 2 weeks or a month longer than necessary to start treatment. That could be the difference between life and death.
On the security guard, you're right, but I think it's still interesting to think about. If the security guard really does just assume any noise heard is not robbers, then they are effectively not doing anything. Their deterrence value is non-zero, agreed, but maybe it's cheaper and more productive to install motion-activated security cameras at ingress points, and big honkin' signs at the perimeter that say "Security monitoring in effect 24/7". Yes, you have to pay for the monitoring, but that's probably cheaper than paying for a butt-in-seat. And safer, too! Most security guards at most places probably aren't trained for much beyond the basics. I think it's more likely than not that someone will get hurt if robbers do show up and a security guard gets involved. I would much rather some stuff get stolen than people get hurt. (Certainly there are some things that are critical enough that require a well-trained security force. I just think these things are less common than most people would think.)
> Un-nuanced and quite sloppy presentation of heuristics.
I think the lack of nuance is in part the point. We should be examining places in our lives where we go by our gut feeling, or by the common case, when we probably should actually be doing research, diagnosis, or testing. Even if the results aren't as dire as some of the non-nuanced takes, they're still bad enough to warrant some thought.