3 ms·
It is authentic English usage. That is, the words are actually used that way, whether you like it or not. Attempts to define "correct" usage that are not desc
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
It is authentic English usage. That is, the words are actually used that way, whether you like it or not.
Attempts to define "correct" usage that are not descriptivist are... arrogant. Elitist. Attempting to hold back the tide. And doomed to failure. We'll use the words how we please. If you don't like it, we'll ignore you.
This isn't science, where there are "correct" answers. There's no objectively correct definition of any word. Languages are defined by how they're used.
(Note well: I am not saying that anyone can make up any definition they want for a word. They can't. I'm saying that the speakers of a language, as a whole, define words by how they use them. You can't hold back that tide, no matter how much you wish to.)
- User23 5y agoUsage is an important signifier of social status. There are plenty of dialects that signal high or low status depending on who one is talking to that one is free to speak, but being competent in one’s culture’s prestige dialect is a valuable skill. In their rush to bless every passing linguistic fad, M-W comes off rather preachy, even prescriptive, in their supposed descriptivism. Worse they’re not even good at it. If one wants the bleeding edge of living language then urban dictionary is a far superior resource. M-W is a bad dictionary.
- gowld 5y agoWhy isn't it arrogant to make language ambiguous in a way that it hard to ever recover from? Prescriptivism tries to preserve the information content of language. We can all communicate if we speak the same language. We can't if language forks until a million incompatible variations.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoPrescriptivism has various goals according to its various exponents. One very traditional goal is to preserve modes of speech that have become obsolete, or to avoid modes that are perceived as innovative. But that has nothing to do with information content. Complaining that an element of the sentence is being marked twice instead of once is also an odd way to "try to preserve the information content of the language". The more times something gets marked, the more obvious the informational content carried by the marking becomes.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Attempts to define "correct" usage that are not descriptivist are... arrogant. Elitist. Attempting to hold back the tide. And doomed to failure. Well, there is a little more gray area around dead languages. The Latin that gets used to publish 18th-century scientific papers is oddly close to the languages actually spoken by the authors in the 18th century. This means that, for us, 18th-century Latin is much easier to read than De Bello Gallico is, even though Julius Caesar is known today for the simplicity and clarity of his prose.[1] So there's room to say that while 18th-century scientific Latin is Latin, it's not great Latin and probably indulges in some constructions that a native speaker would have perceived as straight-out errors. But to make this observation we have to be willing to conceive of some Latin as being correct and some as being wrong, even though all the samples from both groups are plainly identifiable as Latin. And while it's very clear in the example which variety of Latin should be "correct", and it's less clear when sampling two living varieties of a living language... the argument isn't really any different. [1] Exactly the same thing happens in classical Chinese, where as time marches on, documents are still written in classical Chinese, and there's an obvious difference between classical Chinese and vernacular Chinese... but the later the authorship of the document is, the more likely its classical Chinese is to include some vernacularisms.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI agree that "literally" is used to mean "not literally". My beef is that such usage diminishes the language, rendering that word ambiguous. And I claim that a significant minority of readers find these usgaes sufficiently jarring that they stop reading, or at least have their attention diverted from the writer's meaning. Therefore I think these usages should be avoided, simply in order to achieve the writer's intent. And I think lexicographers should signpost usages that are likely to repel some readers. Dictionaries are used (a) to help decode a text, and (b) to help construct a text. In the former case, you need a descriptivist lexicon, in case the text involves dubious usages. In the latter case you need a lexicon that at least warns you that certain usages are annoying to some people.