5 ms·
Why do so many people want to ban FSD Beta from public roads every time it almost causes an accident, when we usually don't take away people's driver's licenses
by josephcsible 5y ago
Why do so many people want to ban FSD Beta from public roads every time it almost causes an accident, when we usually don't take away people's driver's licenses even when they do cause accidents?
- moralestapia 5y ago>when we usually don't take away people's driver's licenses even when they do cause accidents? Huh? Yes, we do?
- ummonk 5y agoNot really. We will take away drivers licenses for driving under the influence or extreme speeding, but a lot of accidents are due to long tail bad drivers (elderly people who just don’t have good reactions, careless people, people who just haven’t learnt to drive well, cell phone users, etc.) who rarely have their licenses taken away. Of course, I think the solution to this is improving public transport and more aggressively taking away people’s driving licenses, rather than giving autopilot a pass.
- randoglando 5y ago> who rarely have their licenses taken away. My understanding is if you accumulate a certain number of points, it gets taken away. The reason DUI etc. receives such harsh penalties is because the number of accidents DUI has caused makes it obvious that drinking is a factor. It should be the same with "autopilot".
- moralestapia 5y agoI agree with what you say and just want to add that the benchmark for FSD shouldn't be the bad drivers, it should be the best ones.
- stefan_ 5y agoBecause a human putting 5 in the field for 1+3 is an isolated mistake, but the machine doing it is the result of a deterministic process that is likely to occur much the same way over and over again. In other words, no, we don't ignore MCAS causing the plane to go into a stall under some isolated circumstance just because humans also put planes into stall.
- Arainach 5y ago> 5 in the field for 1+3 Please translate.
- abduhl 5y agoBecause 1 guy doesn't drive 12000 cars at the same time while Tesla FSD Beta software does.
- ixfo 5y agoBecause we do take people's licenses away if they repeatedly cause accidents? Treat the Tesla FSD as a human driver and it would've had its license revoked many years ago. It's only through close supervision by humans that accidents have been as infrequent as they have been. The clip in question, if a human hadn't been paying attention, FSD would've knocked a cyclist over - at best. Do that enough times as a human - not many - and you'll be disqualified from driving pretty promptly in most civilised countries.
- boardwaalk 5y agoInteresting to treat FSD a single driver, when it’s driven further than any human driver has many times over. Objectively, that is a bit of a double standard.
- zardo 5y agoIn my state vehicular manslaughter is still vehicular manslaughter, no matter how many miles you drive.
- ummonk 5y agoIt’s arguably an inappropriate standard, but not a double standard. If as a human driver you drive a bunch but get into accidents frequently, they won’t make any allowances for the fact that you drive a lot when deciding whether to suspend your license.
- plutonorm 5y agobut they obviously should.
- whiddershins 5y agoThat’s not true multiplied across the hours and miles it has driven. No single human driver could do this amount of driving, so comparing all FSD mistakes to a single human is an error.
- 5y ago
- CamperBob2 5y agoA lot of people lost a lot of money shorting Tesla, or currently hold short positions, and will grind their ax in any context where it's even vaguely relevant. A lot of people simply don't realize that human drivers kill each other by tens of thousands per annum in the US alone, so there's a lot of room for self-driving technology to do a lot of good. A lot of people are unhappy at being used as unwitting beta testers simply by virtue of having to share the road with beta FSD systems. They have a point, but see the previous one. Finally, a lot of people question some of the engineering practices at Tesla, such as their refusal to incorporate multiple sensor inputs as failsafes. I'd fall into that category, personally.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blinding-streak 5y ago> so there's a lot of room for self-driving technology to do a lot of good. There's a lot of room for self-driving technology that actually works to do a lot of good. Tesla's FSD is hot garbage.
- FireBeyond 5y agoSeriously, this argument is tired. Cue up those who think that it's fundamentally impossible to see a downside to anything Tesla does without having a vested financial stake in their failure. That's categorically false. Or are you going to claim that many of the people here in this thread, for but one example, are "Short TSLA"? I'm not. I hold no financial stake in TSLA. > A lot of people simply don't realize that human drivers kill each other by tens of thousands per annum in the US alone According to the EMR system at my job, I've been an EMS responder on 378 fatality MVAs, and several thousand more non-fatality. And I still hold my position that Tesla is reckless. Throwing fixes over the fence for safety issues (phantom braking for one recent example) with 48-72 hours since the last update proves beyond any doubt that there's no ethos of thorough testing.
- josephcsible 5y ago> Cue up those who think that it's fundamentally impossible to see a downside to anything Tesla does without having a vested financial stake in their failure. While you're right in the general case, the presence of "$TSLAQ" in the original tweet means that the author of it almost certainly does have a vested financial stake in their failure.
- draw_down 5y ago
- magnetowasright 5y ago
- pengaru 5y agoStrawman much? If you link a twitter video from a driver swerving erratically at cyclists, there will be no shortage of a mob demanding the driver lose his license and be put behind bars. In this case the driver is an AI, so you respond by banishing all the cars this AI controls, goodbye Tesla FSD.
- josephcsible 5y agoDoesn't that kind of stuff get linked all the time in /r/IdiotsInCars? But how many of those people do you ever hear of losing their licenses?
- wonnage 5y agoThe standards for automated driving have to be way higher than they are for human drivers. What's the point otherwise? "it's ok if our buggy AI car crashes into things because humans do too" is not a great pitch
- gdulli 5y agoA single human driver can't kill other people at scale. Human drivers are predictable in aggregate, from decades of observation of driving patterns. Every single software update has the potential to turn the whole fleet into murder machines at once even if last week it was comparable to human performance.
- heavyset_go 5y agoReckless driving, DUI etc convictions often come with license suspensions, and ultimately license revocation if the bad behavior continues.