5 ms·
If you'll die if a roll of three dice comes up sixes, you're not really in a lot of danger. If you do it every day, you have about 15 months to live.
by pessimizer 5y ago
If you'll die if a roll of three dice comes up sixes, you're not really in a lot of danger. If you do it every day, you have about 15 months to live.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moralestapia 5y ago>you have about 15 months to live Or a few minutes ... or 20 years. That's the thing w/ statistically independent trials.
- ska 5y agoThat's like the difference between You could win 100mm in the lottery (true statement!) Lottery tickets are a good investment (almost always, false statement). Planning on "well it could happen, technically" isn't a good approach.
- blunte 5y agoBut when looking at a possible positive outcome, such as the lottery case, it can "make sense" to buy one ticket. Your chance of winning goes from No Chance to A Chance, which is an infinite improvement.
- ska 5y agoThat's not how this works as a rational investment choice. It's true that you can never win a lottery you don't enter, but the expected value of that ticket is vastly lower than what you paid for it. That means, as an investment, your $10 will be expected to do better in literally anything with a positive return. If you are buying > $10 worth of dreaming (for you), fine - but that's consumption.
- jrochkind1 5y agoIf you've already done it for 12 months without it happening though, the next 3 months are no more dangerous for you than for someone starting from scratch.
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoVery true. The only winning move is not to play!
- tshaddox 5y agoThat's true, but usually when we are deciding which actions to take, we're not comparing "I take actionA" versus "I take actionB," rather than comparing "I take actionA" versus "some random other person takes actionA."
- jrochkind1 5y agoOK, the next 3 months are no more dangerous for you than if you hadn't spent the last 12 months doing it. What you did in the past has no bearing on the chances going forward. I'm not sure if it's more clear to say it like that or not. Clearly, humans have a lot of trouble speaking and thinking clearly about statistics. The next three months are no riskier than your first three months were. They don't become more risky because they will add up to 15 months total -- once you've already finished the first 12 without incident.
- kenjackson 5y agoFor the dice roll example that is true. But other examples it isn’t. For example the MTBF of a device that has run for x hours approaching the MTBF is probably more likely to fall in the next x hours. Or if there is some cyclic behavior. Like waiting outside for a hot day.
- jim-jim-jim 5y agoFunny book recommendation: "The Dice Man" by Luke Rhinehart.
- QuercusMax 5y agoAnyone who's rolled double natural 1s with advantage would never take this bet - and your example is twice as likely to occur!
- cipheredStones 5y agoIf you think a 1/216 chance of sudden death isn't a lot of danger, I don't want to go rock climbing with you!
- withinboredom 5y agoDon’t look at the actuarial tables. The odds are worse than that over a year’s time after ~35
- sin7 5y agoWhat am I missing? 6 x 6 X 6 = 216 or about 7 months.
- randomswede 5y agoDice (typically) do not have a memory, so whatever happened yesterday will not influence what happens today. If you roll it daily, your chance of surviving at least N days is (215/216)^N, for the specific case of "rolling three 6 on three 6-sided dice" that puts you at ~50% at 149 days and at ~10% at 496 days. At sufficient scale, even incredibly unlikely things become quite probable.
- sin7 5y agoruns <- 10000 x <- vector(mode = "numeric", length = runs) for (i in 1:runs){ while (sum(sample(1:6, size = 3, replace = TRUE)) != 18){ x[i] <- x[i] + 1 } } summary(x) quantile(x, c(0.5, 0.8, 0.9)) > summary(x) Min. 1st Qu. Median Mean 3rd Qu. Max. 0.0 62.0 149.0 216.2 300.0 1902.0 > quantile(x, c(0.5, 0.8, 0.9)) 50% 80% 90% 149 350 495 A simple simulation. Run 10K times. Count the number of times it takes for three dice to add up 18. The numbers very much agree with you. The median is 149. The 90th is 495 in the simulation, which is close enough to 496. There is very much a long tail in the data. So, the median and the average will not be the same. Is it a coincidence that mean is a 216?
- randomswede 5y agoOff the top of my head, I don't know. It MAY be related to the fact that 6*3 is 216, but I don't have deep enough statistics knowledge to say for sure. You coudl try it again with 3 8-sided dice and rolling 24, that should give you ~50% at 344 iterations, and ~90% at 1177 iterations. If my supposition that the mean is related to the possible rolls, then the mean should end up being 512. Iteration counts gathered with Python and a (manual) binary search (actually faster than writing code).
- 5y ago
- Someone 5y agoThe expected value will be 6³ = 216 days or about 7 months. Where do you get the factor of two from? Also, “not really in a lot of danger”? Those odds are worse than that of a 100 year old in the USA (they have a life expectancy of over two years) Certainly, as an additional risk, it’s high.
- wizzwizz4 5y agoYou forget: once you roll three 6s in a row, you're dead, and you don't roll any more. Your expected calculation assumes that people keep rolling after they get 666. Though I'm not sure where they got their figure from, because there isn't an “expected time to live”; there's a 90% probability to live time, a 5% probability to live time…
- Someone 5y agoThere’s a difference between expected value of number of days you’ll survive and the number of days a given fraction of the subjects will survive, but I don’t see either supporting the claim “If you do it every day, you have about 15 months to live”. (215/216)^450 ≈ 0.124 , so about one in eight will survive for 15 months or more. The “5% probability to live” time is around day 645 (about 1¾ years): (215/216)^645 ≈ 0.0501 the “half will survive at least for” point is around 5 months: (215/216)^149 ≈ 0.501
- barrenko 5y agoYup. Don't do stuff (repeatedly) that have an absorbing barrier - https://medium.com/ml-everything/nassim-taleb-absorbent-barriers-and-house-money-8b21cff2e338 https://medium.com/ml-everything/nassim-taleb-absorbent-barr...