3 ms·
The reasoning in this post is completely backwards: just because a job could be completely replaced with a rock without affecting the majority of cases doesn't
by woodruffw 5y ago
The reasoning in this post is completely backwards: just because a job could be completely replaced with a rock without affecting the majority of cases doesn't mean that the actual practitioners of that job are either completely useless or are themselves on autopilot.
Siskind assumes the latter and reasons towards the former, which isn't aligned at all with what actually happens in the world: we do predict hurricanes and exploding volcanoes, and there's no particular evidence that the average doctor is ignoring their patients. We're all subject to biases and fatigue, but neither of those supports the claim that we're all phoning it in all the time.
Edit: I will also note that "when nothing happens at all, a person can be replaced with a note on a rock" is not an interesting statement to make. Dressing it up with eloquent prose (and he is indeed eloquent!) does not change this, and does not a poignant observation make.
- three14 5y agoHis whole point is that the occasional person who IS "phoning it in all the time" will appear to be very good at their job, possibly better than the people who are really trying their best to get it right.
- ravi-delia 5y agoWhere are you seeing the author suggest most people in the described jobs could actually be replaced by rocks?
- woodruffw 5y ago> Where are you seeing the author suggest most people in the described jobs could actually be replaced by rocks? I really think it's harder to get more literal than this: > He could be losslessly replaced by a rock with the words “THERE ARE NO ROBBERS” on it.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think the point is that the person who inappropriately uses a heuristic instead of doing their job, is in fact, not doing their job.
- andrewla 5y agoA guard who adopts the heuristic "there are no robbers" can be replaced with a rock, but has adopted a heuristic that almost always works. Guards that do not adopt that heuristic cannot be replaced by that rock.