8 ms·
> the mere act of doing it more often dramatically changes the risk. Kind of. However, you already know that the first N outings didn't have a disaster. So tho
by HWR_14 5y ago
> the mere act of doing it more often dramatically changes the risk.
Kind of. However, you already know that the first N outings didn't have a disaster. So those should be discarded from your analysis.
Doing it N times more has a lot of risk, doing it the N+1th time has barely any.
- HPsquared 5y agoThe "slippery slope" principle applies here though: N+1 enables N+2, which enables N+3 and so on.
- aaronblohowiak 5y agobut the risk is independent. so once you do the N+1 time safely, you are back to N and your next time is _also_ just an N+1.
- pessimizer 5y agoContinuing to do something regularly doesn't ever mean you're just going to do it once more.
- nefitty 5y agoPsychologically, behaving in a certain way makes it more likely that you'll behave in the same way in the future. That's an integral idea underpinning justice systems.
- twobitshifter 5y agoTrue but it would be incorrect to assume that you can safely keep basejumping every day in a year, just because you haven’t died in the last 50 days. Eventually the stats say you will be 87% likely to have an accident when you consider your choice at the beginning of the year. It might be day 20 or day 300, but you won’t know what case you end up in. The chance of your next jump being your last is always the same, but that doesn’t decrease the risk of repeated trials.
- jrochkind1 5y agoNot exactly. If you've done it 50 days without an accident, your current chances of the accident happening in the remainder of the year are NOW less than 87%. If you've made it Jan 1 to July 1 months without an accident, the chances of you making it to Dec 31 are now better than they were on Jan 1 -- because now they are just the chances of you making it six months, not a year. The chances of flipping 6 heads in a row are 1/64. But if I've already flipped 3 in a row... the chances of flipping three _more_ heads in a row is 1/8, the same as always for flipping 3 heads in a row. The ones that already happened don't effect your future chances.
- twobitshifter 5y agoI meant to say starting a new year after the 50 past days, I see that wasn’t clear though.
- Stronico 5y agoRisk is independent of prior events, habits are not - I think that was what the anthropologist story is about
- ummonk 5y agoThe risk is independent but the marginal enjoyment isn't. You don't get double the satisfaction from climbing twice as much.
- majormajor 5y agoYes, but when you make a plan to find an acceptable cumulative future risk, planning to do it once a week for the rest of your life is planning to expose yourself to significantly more risk than doing it twice a year for the rest of your life. You might still die in one of the next 20 instances. But you've added a lot more not-dead time in between them! Saying "I can do one more with minimal added risk" every single time after not dying is true and yet pointless, because it's not a given that "minimal added risk" = "not dying." It's survivorship bias to not think frequency doesn't affect the cumulative odds of your future planning solely because you've already done a lot of trials.
- mkolodny 5y agoSlippery slope is a fallacy, not a principle. Just because you took N steps, that doesn't necessarily mean you will take N+1 steps. It's a convincing fallacy because sometimes you do take N+1 steps. But just like in the article, heuristics aren't always right.
- vojvod 5y agoSlippery slope arguments aren't inherently fallacious. If you can justify one more climb on the grounds that probability of injury or death is very low then you will be able to justify every subsequent climb on the same basis.
- mkolodny 5y agoSlippery slope arguments are inherently fallacies. They don't prove that something will happen. Just because you can justify the next climb on the same basis, that doesn't mean you will. You could decide that you've already tested the odds one too many times.
- vojvod 5y ago"You could decide that you've already tested the odds one too many times" was the original point. Someone responded that the N previous times don't matter and N + 1 has barely any risk. Another poster countered that that argument as stated applies not just for N + 1 but for (N + 1) + 1 etc and therefore the slippery slope principle applies. Of course if you add in "you could decide that you've already tested the odds one too many times" then it's a fallacy to invoke slippery slope because an off-ramp is explicitly specified. In this case slippery slope was mentioned only because N was dismissed as irrelevant.
- bhuber 5y agoDon't get on that greased sliding board that ends at the top of a cliff. Once you start sliding, it will be hard to stop because of the grease, and then once you slide off then end you will fall and die. Do you really think this slippery slope argument is a fallacy? FWIW, wikipedia acknowledges slippery slope can be a legit argument when the slope, and it's chain of consequences, are actually real. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope . Indeed, this is the very basis of mathematical induction.
- pessimizer 5y agoIf you'll die if a roll of three dice comes up sixes, you're not really in a lot of danger. If you do it every day, you have about 15 months to live.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moralestapia 5y ago>you have about 15 months to live Or a few minutes ... or 20 years. That's the thing w/ statistically independent trials.
- ska 5y agoThat's like the difference between You could win 100mm in the lottery (true statement!) Lottery tickets are a good investment (almost always, false statement). Planning on "well it could happen, technically" isn't a good approach.
- blunte 5y agoBut when looking at a possible positive outcome, such as the lottery case, it can "make sense" to buy one ticket. Your chance of winning goes from No Chance to A Chance, which is an infinite improvement.
- ska 5y agoThat's not how this works as a rational investment choice. It's true that you can never win a lottery you don't enter, but the expected value of that ticket is vastly lower than what you paid for it. That means, as an investment, your $10 will be expected to do better in literally anything with a positive return. If you are buying > $10 worth of dreaming (for you), fine - but that's consumption.
- jrochkind1 5y agoIf you've already done it for 12 months without it happening though, the next 3 months are no more dangerous for you than for someone starting from scratch.
- montebicyclelo 5y agoThe parent comment talks about scaling back the amount of rock climbing they do in order to reduce risk.. And now you are saying that they should go one more time, because a single climb is low risk?
- HWR_14 5y agoYes. I am saying their analysis of risk is incorrect, and therefore if that's the only reason they aren't climbing then they should climb more often.
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoI disagree, their analysis is perfectly correct. The more frequently you take a risk, the greater the chance that risk materialises. Parent wants to lower their overall risk, but doesn't want to stop climbing entirely. So they climb less often.
- mort96 5y agoI think you're reading it wrong. After a long life of rock climbing, there's no significant risk of doing it one last time or 10 last times (ignoring the effect of old age itself and whatever). But when you're in earlier stages of your life, you're asking a different question: You're asking, is this something I want to do hundreds or thousands of times in my life, knowing that each of those times has a small chance of ending my life? This becomes a completely different question. If I'm 35, maybe I will climb 30 times per year on average for 30 years until I'm 65. That's 900 climbs in total. If my goal is to not die or experience serious injury from rock climbing even once in my life, I have to consider the chance that any one of those 900 climbs will result in serious injury or death. I don't know the numbers for the risks involved, but it seems reasonable to be cautious. Maybe I don't want to give up on rock climbing altogether, but maybe I can scale it back. If I limit myself to 1 climb per year, that's 30 climbs in total. Much lower risk than with 900 climbs. This is not a logical fallacy.
- HWR_14 5y agoThat would be a reason to have not climbed more than a specific rate ever. It wouldn't be a reason to scale down the rate of climbing as you age.
- srcreigh 5y agoUnder this assumption, by the principal of mathematical induction, you can easily do it K more times for any K without taking on barely any risk at each step of the way.
- 323 5y agoThis is called the Turkey fallacy: the turkey was feed by humans for 1000 days, and after each feed event he updated his belief that humans care for him until it's now almost a statistical certainty.
- lapetitejort 5y agoIs this the reverse of the Gambler's Fallacy? Instead of "The numbers haven't hit in a while, therefore they're going to hit soon." it's "The numbers haven't hit yet, therefore they're never gonna hit."
- jaggederest 5y agoAlso known as complacency. Working in a woodshop, one of the things you are most vulnerable to is failing to respect the danger you're in. This is why many experienced woodworkers have been injured by e.g. a table saw - you stop being as careful after such long exposure.
- 323 5y agoA related thing is normalization of deviance. You start removing safety because you see nothing bad happened before, until you are at a point where almost no safety rules are respected anymore. You can see this a lot in construction videos.
- toss1 5y agoYup, complacency can kill you. In this case [0], a skydiver forgot to put on his parachute... https://reverentialramblings.com/2018/08/15/the-skydiver-who-forgot-his-parachute/ https://reverentialramblings.com/2018/08/15/the-skydiver-who...
- ask_b123 5y agoWow, that's terrifying and a good cautionary tale. Also, when I read > I’m hoping you can you forgive me as a minister of religion for likening this story to a spiritual cautionary tale. Yes, we do need to live each day as if it might be our last. I thought, "Hmm, sounds adventist", and sure enough :-)
- jvanderbot 5y agoIn a skill-based game, N+1 has less incremental risk than adding 1 more trial with N-1 games did.
- mrow84 5y agoThis assumes a lot about the underlying process, particularly independence. Whilst assuming independence might hold reasonably well for low numbers of samples, the assumption might be increasingly (and dangerously) misleading. The intuition expressed by GP captures that.
- NineStarPoint 5y agoThe point is that they're changing their habits. Of course we ignore the n times they've gone before, now instead of their habits meaning they'd go m more times in the future, they're going to be going p times in the future for some p that is much less than m. So it's not about how often they've done it over their lifetime so far, but about how many times they will be doing it over the rest of their life.