5 ms·
PDEs are really useful if you are in the rare domains where they are useful. But most PDEs don't have even have closed form solutions for non-trivial boundary c
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
PDEs are really useful if you are in the rare domains where they are useful. But most PDEs don't have even have closed form solutions for non-trivial boundary conditions. So unless you are a physicist or something adjacent, no, no you really don't need to know these.
Hard to say what's the intended audience for the page though. Could be a message aimed at physics undergrads or something. If so, then indeed, you should know these.
- salty_biscuits 5y agoNavier stokes are incredibly important pdes for science and engineering, yet proof of even the existence of solutions is not currently available. Numerical methods are far more important than analytical solutions.
- medo-bear 5y agoMost useful equations don't have a closed form solution. This is why things like machine learning exist. More specifically PDEs are a hot topic in DNNs at the moment. See physics informed neural networks: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physics-informed_neural_networks https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physics-informed_neural_netw...
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThe point is that equations without closed form solutions are pretty useless if you aren't into pretty hairy maths, Green's functions and the like. An equation everyone should know is Hooke's law. That's useful at a high school level.
- medo-bear 5y agoi disagree. equations are useful only if you have use for them. this is by definition of the term. on the other hand, high schoolers rarely feel like Hooke's law is useful!
- pvarangot 5y agoIsn't Hooke's law a solution to the harmonic motion PDE in that page?
- tagoregrtst 5y agoNo? Hooks law is an approximation to a material (and spring) property that sets the PDE up. Sin(x) is the solution. But I could be wrong :S
- capn_duck 5y agoASin(wx) is a solution for certain initial conditions. In general there's no single "solution" to a PDE.
- tagoregrtst 5y agoI meant its a solution to a specific problem set up using Hooke’s law
- kergonath 5y agoYes, it is. Hooke’s law tells basically that the force is proportional to the deformation, or in standard textbook physics, f = - k x, the classical harmonic oscillator. It’s not surprising if you see a solid material that way: - it is in stable equilibrium when no force is applied, i.e., it is at an energy minimum - therefore either extending it or compressing it increases its energy - therefore the second derivative of its energy is positive. On a high level, this sounds very much like a simple parabola, because it is one. For more technical details, we can always locally approximate a function using a Taylor’s series. In this case, the constant term and the linear term are zero if we place the frame of reference correctly (not necessary but it simplifies the equations). So the leading term is quadratic. If we are close enough to the energy minimum (i.e. if the deformations are small), we can ignore the other terms. Therefore, a solid is, to a very good degree of approximation for most of them, a harmonic oscillator. Alternatively, to a physicist, almost everything looks like a parabola. If the energy is a parabola, then the force is a linear function, or, as it was written in the linked document, -dE/dx = m d^2 E/dt^2 = - k x . (The first step being Newton’s second law). The analogy can be pushed a bit: a solid deformed quickly enough will have periodic deformations, periodically contracting and expanding, i.e. vibrating. This is strictly equivalent to a harmonic oscillator oscillating in its energy well. I suspect (please tell me if I am wrong) the sine(x) solution you mention refers to elastic waves, which appear if we take the next step and consider the solid as a bunch of coupled harmonic oscillators. Long story short, if we do that, we end up with the wave equation, from which you get sines (or more accurately, complex exponential settings).
- aqme28 5y agoI think we need a better mutual definition of useful. IMO an equation is "useful" if someone out there is doing practical things with it. You are taking a sort of definition where anyone can do math with it.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoWell the page title is "PDEs You Should Know", not "PDEs Someone Should Know"
- aqme28 5y agoThe math isn't that hairy. I took numerical methods and computational physics classes in undergrad.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blablabla123 5y agoI think the most generic approach is to prove existence and uniqueness and then go with numerical methods.
- nautilius 5y agoYou really should read up on numerical math, we really don't need closed form solutions, and this makes PDE far from useless.
- blueplanet200 5y agoDepends on what you're doing, but you can numerically simulate solutions to PDEs. To me that makes them useful even if we struggle to conjure up closed form solutions.
- aqme28 5y agoWhy does a PDE need an analytical solution? Are you arguing that e.g. Navier-Stokes isn't useful? edit: Just noticed that Navier-Stokes isn't even on here. This is frankly a weird list.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWell, to be useful, wouldn't you need to be able to use it? Most people outside of physicists and physics-adjacent fields are very far away from the mathematical tools to deal with these equations.
- medo-bear 5y agocs is a dominant topic on hn. cs is definitely physics and math adjacent
- aqme28 5y agoNumerical methods exist. There's a whole field to simulate PDEs that you can't solve exactly.
- sampo 5y ago> There's a whole field to simulate PDEs that you can't solve exactly. There are whole fields to simulate one particular PDE: Computational fluid mechanics for the Navier-Stokes equation. Computational electromagnetics for Maxwell's equations. Computational chemistry for the Schrödinger equation. Mathematical finance ...probably does also other things than just simulates the Black-Scholes equation.
- rprenger 5y agoI think what the other commenters are getting at is that PDEs can be used without having a closed form solution (and mostly are used that way as closed form solutions usually only come up in special artificial cases). You start your system in a real known state and then propagate it forward in time using (for example) the finite difference method on the equations to figure out the state at a later time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numerical_methods_for_partial_differential_equations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numerical_methods_for_partial_...
- kurthr 5y agoAs an engineer, I've used lots of FEA to solve problems, but if you can't put part of your solution space where it can be approximated by a closed form solution (and there are many more than those shown, which are amenable to solution to appropriate methods), you're going to have a hard time building a trusted model. There's a reason we still have wind tunnels. The most interesting parts of good FEA (where you've shown your model and reality match on measurable components), is that you can see hidden and unmeasurable variables, which may be design limiting.
- JadeNB 5y ago> PDEs are really useful if you are in the rare domains where they are useful. Aside from ‘rare’, this seems at best vacuously true. > But most PDEs don't have even have closed form solutions for non-trivial boundary conditions. So unless you are a physicist or something adjacent, no, no you really don't need to know these. As others have said, while your first sentence is surely true, the latter doesn't follow from it (and I would argue isn't true—but it depends on how you define adjacency). There are lots of things one can usefully do with an equation besides finding a closed-form solution. (For an ODE example, the classical predator–prey model does not have a nice closed-form solution, but is still plenty useful.)
- kleene_op 5y agoBeing familiar with PDEs is useful even without knowing how to solve them. Just the formulas alone teach you how physical quantities interact with one another and give you great insights on how the universe operates on a fundamental level. Most people may not be using them at their everyday job, or at all for that matter, but knowing the core ones is just as enlightening if not more than having read major works in Philosophy.
- dan-robertson 5y agoI was once asked a (programming) interview question and suggested solving it with differential equations (it was a system of odes but could be made into pdes too). But that wasn’t the solution they were looking for.
- blueplanet200 5y ago> Could be a message aimed at physics undergrads or something. The Black Scholes equation is present though, which is used in pricing securities in financial markets. Perhaps this page is aimed at physicists who intend on jumping ship to become a quant!