3 ms·
The intellectual level, complexity of research-level math is so great these days . Your kid has a greater chance of being a multi-millionaire NBA player than b
by paulpauper 5y ago
The intellectual level, complexity of research-level math is so great these days . Your kid has a greater chance of being a multi-millionaire NBA player than being smart enough to understand this stuff or do cutting-edge math research, compared to something like history or literature. As a field, modern mathematics is so far ahead of what laypeople can do but also even much of the field itself. It's like, imagine getting a PhD in math, which is a hard thing to do, and then multiply by a factor 100 in difficulty. Even 18th century math would be a challenge for many math grad students. Just crazy
- thechao 5y agoI think you're equating "mathematician" with "Fields-medallist-adjacent"? As such, I think you'd need to equate such a mathematician to the list of "greatest of all time" in basketball, who are still alive. I suspect those numbers would still tilt in favor of there being more mathematicians than NBA players. On the other hand, I think this is a great way for us science-y types to get a good handle on how hard being an NBA player is: NBA players are the moral equivalent of near-Fields-medallists; that's how good they are compared to the rest of us. I'm no mathematical slouch — I've done grad work in Math, taught myself differential geometry, etc.; but it'd be fruitless to compare me to Terry Tao. There's really no reference for how good he is at math compared to me. I think, analogously, you wouldn't be able to compare a college-level basketball player to, say, Michael Jordan.
- m00n 5y agoSorry, but the breathless way, that maths is often discussed on HN, makes me feel uneasy. It feels strange to see adults that opine on every subject, from nuclear fusion energy, to virology and financial markets, like they know it all, to suddenly "I was never good at math", like a clichee party conversation. I mean, I get it: It first feels strange and magical, since even the explanations of some of the vocabulary take more time than we are willing to devote to a single thought. But instead of digging in and looking up what "Borel measurable" might mean, the HN crowd rather watches the x-th numberphile video/emotionalized Quanta blurb. /rant More to your points: > Your kid has a greater chance of being a multi-millionaire NBA player than being smart enough to understand this stuff There are >5000 math phds each year, so no, getting into the NBA is harder. > Even 18th century math would be a challenge for many math grad students. Just crazy Not sure, what this is supposed to mean. Certainly as a math grad you should be able to _understand_ 18th century math. Now, to _come up_ with the stuff is something else entirely. But I'm not sure how many engineers would claim they had discovered the telegraph, were they be born instead of Gauss.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI was good enough in maths to get a PhD from Commutative Algebra, but the really good ones were on another level, where you could barely follow their thoughts (especially real-time; anything can be attacked with enough patience, but it was precisely the speed of their train of thought that humiliated you the worst). People like Erdös were gods in the mathematical universe.
- xyzzyz 5y agoThis is exactly right. I could also get a PhD degree in math myself (I dropped out after obtaining Master during which I obtained novel results in algebraic geometry), but after meeting and interacting with actually smart people, it became clear to me that I’m just not nearly on the same level. Research level mathematics requires completely another level of sheer brainpower that most people don’t even imagine exists.
- laingc 5y agoAdding my voice to this too. I have a PhD in Differential Geometry and would consider myself to have been a decent student and researcher. The "good" people in my field were more than a head and shoulders above me, and the "great" people were somewhere off in the stratosphere. The nature of Mathematics is that the potential depth of understanding and progress is essentially infinite, which frees truly spectacular minds from the constraints they would experience in other fields.
- octopoc 5y agoIs that because the "good" people in your field were just way more obsessive about the topic? I feel like there are some topics that I'm obsessed with that I'm so much more informed on than most people in my field that I can run circles around them. They would call me super smart if the things I'm obsessive about mattered. Sometimes they have mattered. But I know better than to talk about them at length because people get bored.
- throwaway81523 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]