3 ms·
1.) It's not about piracy, it's about attack surface. 2.) What are the antitrust issues? They're doing this to help preserve the security and integrity, very s
by runjake 15y ago
1.) It's not about piracy, it's about attack surface.
2.) What are the antitrust issues? They're doing this to help preserve the security and integrity, very similar to what Apple does with iOS devices, and almost every single Android vendor does with its devices.
Edit: The downvoters have spoken. But why is Microsoft being singled out when every other platform does, or is looking to do the same exact thing? Android, iOS, and soon likely Mac OS X.
- narag 15y ago1. The predictable outcome has not to be the same as the stated goals. 2. The antitrust issue is that every OEM that wants to distribute Windows could be forced to ship computers that prevents other systems to work. This could be seen as Microsoft abusing his dominant position to block competitors.
- runjake 15y agoSo does the same line of reasoning in #2 apply to Apple iOS and Android devices? Why aren't people in an uproar about that? (I take that back, they are in an uproar in the Android world). If you've hung out at a WWDC in the past couple years, it's apparent Apple is looking into the same such security scheme(s) for Mac OS X. OEMs ship these computers as Windows computers. OEMs generally don't support alternative OSes on their hardware, because there hasn't been enough demand to make it worthwhile. Linux on the desktop isn't even on Microsoft's radar. That war was lost by Linux (although ironically, they may win or at least fair very well in the "post-pc" era). I'm still confused as to why Linux diehards don't just create their own (ARM-based?) desktop platform where nothing is locked down or closed source.
- rbanffy 15y ago> the same line of reasoning in #2 apply to Apple iOS and Android devices? They are not PCs and are not sold under the expectation they are able to run something other than what was built in. What Microsoft is trying to do is to force OEMs into creating Windows-only PCs.
- runjake 15y agoThere's no expectation that PCs will run anything other than Windows for the vast, vast majority of consumers, either.
- AlexandrB 15y ago> So does the same line of reasoning in #2 apply to Apple iOS and Android devices? Why aren't people in an uproar about that? (I take that back, they are in an uproar in the Android world). This line of reasoning doesn't apply to iOS/Android because there is more than one major player. On the other hand it's basically impossible to go into a retail chain and walk out with a PC that runs something other than Microsoft Windows (unless you're buying a Mac, but they are still only a small portion of the consumer PC market).
- bad_user 15y agoI think it's a worrying trend, ever since Apple's iOS. It's a pity that so many developers that are accustomed to use open-source tools will choose shinny over liberty to tinker, because after all -- it's the third-party developers that make or break a platform. Basically Trusted Computing is sneaking in, because Apple-stuff is the developer-equivalent for the dancing kitty that begs clicking. IMHO, people saying that trusted computing is a good thing are in fact idiots that haven't thought this through; since crackers will always crack, virus writers will always find back doors, and the only ones getting hurt will be legitimate customers (exactly as DRM). And in case you think iOS is secure, you probably haven't seen JailbreakMe in action. At least with Windows XP you are aware that it isn't secure.
- rbanffy 15y ago> Microsoft being singled out when every other platform does Because PCs have been general-purpose machines up to now and Microsoft is trying to turn them into Windows machines. You still can install Linux on a Mac and I don't think the future will bring a OSX-only Mac.
- runjake 15y agoAnd you'll still be able to install Linux on a UEFI PC. So what's the difference here? The Secure Boot feature is a UEFI feature, not a Microsoft-specific feature.