3 ms·
The problem is that the title is misleading. It's like an article with the title "New world record in the 100 meters dash using a new technique" and in the midd
by gus_massa 5y ago
The problem is that the title is misleading. It's like an article with the title "New world record in the 100 meters dash using a new technique" and in the middle of the article it explains that it's about bungee jumping a 100m fall.
- mlyle 5y agoThe squaring a circle with compass and straightedge has been known to be impossible for 140 years. We're obviously talking about the version of the problem everyone's been working on for roughly the last 100.
- whatshisface 5y agoThen you must agree that the problem that was solved is not in the literal sense of the word "ancient."
- mlyle 5y agoThis is just a further result: - You can't do it with a compass and a straightedge, like the ancients were trying (1880's?) - You can't do it with scissors, either (mid-20th century?) - But with modern mathematics, and really complicated shapes-- you can. (now).
- ruggeri 5y agoIt might be obvious to people who are familiar with the problem. In fact, the title confused (and baited) me because I was familiar with the problem, but not the new formulation.
- dfabulich 5y agoI think it's fair to say that this is an "ancient problem." The ancients only had a compass and straightedge, but they were asking a general question, "can you square the circle?" They weren't asking "can you square the circle using only these two tools currently known to us?"
- gus_massa 5y agoThe old problem is solvable with a compass, a straightedge and a rope. [You wrap the rope around the circle and straight it to get a segment of length 2πR, and take the middle point to get a segment of length πR. Then use the compass to continue it with a segment of length R. And then calculate the square root like in https://www.geogebra.org/m/edtecfcv https://www.geogebra.org/m/edtecfcv to get a segment of length sqrt(π)R that is the side of your square. I'm sure this was known in ancient times.] Using only compass and straightedge is more like a esthetics decision. The old problem is difficult (impossible) because you have strong restrictions about which points you can draw. You have no rope and no magic rule to get any arbitrary length. The new problem is difficult because you must cut one figure and rearrange the parts to get the other figure. They have very different restrictions, in spite both are about a circle and a square with the same area.