3 ms·
So, Tesla is adding another point of failure to their car subsystems instead of removing it, and still pushing self-driving technology as aggressive if ever. S
by bayindirh 5y ago
So, Tesla is adding another point of failure to their car subsystems instead of removing it, and still pushing self-driving technology as aggressive if ever.
So, what happens if that electric steering subsystem breaks without a redundant backup? "Customer took the risk, we don't care?"
You even didn't notify the customer about it in the first place.
- optimiz3 5y agoTesla isn't selling self driving on these cares without a retrofit per the article.
- bayindirh 5y agoI'm not sure. From the article: "Tesla vehicles can still use the current “level 2” versions of its driver assistance systems, Autopilot and Full Self-Driving (or FSD), without the dual-control steering system. But employees told CNBC if Tesla launches a more sophisticated FSD update, owners with the affected cars who use that premium system will need to get a steering rack retrofit from a Tesla service center." (Emphasis mine)
- roflchoppa 5y agoIf the electronic power assist steering controller fails during use, the rack falls back to manual mode where the steering is heavy. I wonder if they were collecting data on how many units fell back to the backup unit, and decided it was enough to either not use it, or pay the warranty costs for fixing them. There's really nothing in the EPAS system that can wear out, maybe the motor itself... FSD is trash, all these Teslas on the road braking to a stop for no reason, driving slow in the fast lane >:( Cut them off the computer wont care.
- bayindirh 5y agoI know, but I'm considering a situation where the electric steering gives up at a very inconvenient moment (accident aversion, overtake, etc.) and the driver cannot provide the required force to correct the car, even with a 100% concentration. > There's really nothing in the EPAS system that can wear out, maybe the motor itself... After the whole logging and wearing down flash memory saga, I'm not sure about that. In theory you're right, but in practice "It's a Tesla".
- roflchoppa 5y agoA Honda Legend has level 3 autonomous driving in Japan I wonder what their setup looks like. Every car that I've been into looking to scrape the controllers and motors out of uses a singular EPAS ECU, but none of them provide any level of automation. What level of system redundancy do they offer on brakes?
- donkeyd 5y ago> You even didn't notify the customer about it in the first place. No customer was ever aware that there was a redundant sensor. To me the 'they didn't tell customers' part of this is really odd, since it's not like it's part of the sales pitch. It's not like when they just stopped adding USB-C ports.
- bayindirh 5y agoMy 20 year old Ford has a backup ECU unit inside its ECU and secondary programs if the ECU itself or half of the ignition or fuel transport fried, or the engine is heated beyond control (coolant loss, etc.). I had to use at least one of these modes twice during the ownership of my car, too. My ignition coil's one output went dead, twice. Once overnight, once during driving at highway speeds. In both cases I went to where I need to go safely, because the car knew what to do, and the facilities to do so. These features are written in the user manual as fine prints, but they're not sales points. Nobody advertised these to me. Tesla is selling an autonomous, connected car with enough electronics to fly a small plane, and they rightfully add redundancies inside it. That's great, that's the way it should be. Then they're removing a redundancy feature which might save lives even if it's rarely used. It's akin to MCAS system. "It doesn't change the behavior, so the pilots don't need to know". We know how well it went.
- donkeyd 5y agoYeah, I wasn't saying it isn't a problem they removed it. I don't know whether it is, because I don't know the importance of the part. I was saying how I don't understand that it's a problem they removed a part and didn't tell customers. Parts get added and removed from products all the time without informing customers.
- DerekRobot 5y agoAt this point, I wouldn't be surprised if the Pixhawk org. was more cautious about fail-safe systems than Tesla
- rasz 5y agoWhat you describe is a software fallback (Limp mode), and doesnt require another separate computer. US cars are not my forte, can you name actual year/model so I can see with my own eyes that extra backup ECU unit just sitting there doing nothing?