5 ms·
"There's a picture of me in the Bitcoin blockchain, can you get it removed?" would be a fun litmus test for these folks.
by ceejayoz 5y ago
"There's a picture of me in the Bitcoin blockchain, can you get it removed?" would be a fun litmus test for these folks.
- Guest42 5y agoI wonder if that could turn into a government justification for shutting down the blockchain, something they don’t want in there.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThere's already one piece of CSAM in there. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/mar/20/child-abuse-imagery-bitcoin-blockchain-illegal-content https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/mar/20/child-abu... Anyone with a full Bitcoin node is in theory in significant violation of US law; child porn is a strict liability scenario, where intent doesn't matter.
- mrlemke 5y agoI have had concerns about this possibility. Would it be possible for a miner to reject transactions containing this crap?
- inkblotuniverse 5y agoEncrypt arbitrary data, put it on-chain, and then publish the key on-chain at a later date. No real way around that unless all miners opt to drop that metadata, which amounts to a fork
- wolverine876 5y agoBlockchain has a lot of mythology around it right now, but really no special status. For these purposes, it's a distributed database. If you opt to put a distributed database with criminal materials on your computer, you could very well break the law. People have been criminalized for bittorrent, music sharing services, etc. Uninformed people I know hesitate to use Tor clients due to its reputation; well-informed people hesitate to run Tor exit nodes. Why would blockchain get special status? For example, imagine a blockchain explicitly intended for use by drug dealers to exchange money or CSAM users to exchange materials (maybe they read on HN that it's anonymous, impossible to censor, etc.): Could the government shut that down? Would they? Would you dare allow any such thing on your computer (ignoring that you probably have no interest in either service).
- robbedpeter 5y agoThere are interesting experiments using torrent streaming, tor, and riffs on ipfs exploring the possibilities of distributed data storage. The existing tech is resilient and resists censorship at the highest level of skill and resources. Blockchains allow structure and incentive beyond the data in itself. If someone published all the leaked pii of us citizens from the last decade to the bitcoin blockchain (which would probably exceed high 6 figures in fees,) the financial incentive would effectively permanently protect it. It's about as far from ephemeral as data can get. Governments could hamper the use of bitcoin, shut down exchanges for fiat, but it's effectively impossible to get rid of the data once it's published to the blockchain. Non blockchain distributed data systems can theoretically be censored, but in the same sense that tor users can be tracked - the resources needed aren't trivial. Building in a consensus based way of eliminating garbage from non-functional blockchain data might prove legally necessary, as bitcoin nodes are effectively hosting all sorts of nasty and illegal data even now. Transaction size limits and fees prevent meaningful abuse or use of bitcoin as a data sharing platform, but there are solid cryptocurrencies designed for arbitrary public distributed data. I'd love to see a scihub blockchain, or a better steemit type system. It'll be interesting to see how cryptocurrencies evolve, and how long it takes governments and cultures to adapt.
- wolverine876 5y ago> the financial incentive would effectively permanently protect it What financial incentive? How would that work?
- robbedpeter 5y agoThe roughly 1 trillion usd market cap. The whole reason people get into bitcoin is to make or move money. Sure, it could go down, but even if governments crack down there will be a residual user base and the blockchain will persist.
- wolverine876 5y agoPeople keep saying things like that, but I haven't seen much reason or evidence. It seems like a techno-nerd sci-fi story.
- UweSchmidt 5y agoThey could approach the intermediate services that are usually used to access the blockchain. Moxie had his NFT removed by one of the market places and gone it was from the wallet, gone for all practical purposes. https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html
- throwaway22032 5y agoThis is a super interesting article. I'd avoided looking into NFT's because the concept strikes me as being just, well, cringe, but I'd assumed at least that the chains stored the hash of a jpeg or something. You're telling me that they're not even immutable? They really just store urls with _no checksum of what's on the other end of the url_!?
- bsamuels 5y agoit's up to whoever created it. there's good permanent storage solutions out there like arweave, but if you're just trying to grift people, imgur should be fine.
- throwaway22032 5y agoI suppose the point is that you should use an url that's content addressable right?
- jcun4128 5y agoThat's an interesting claim "permanently" > protocol matches people who have hard drive space to spare
- donmcronald 5y agoThat’s the way I understood it and I was stunned. I absolutely love that he used a poop emoji for the NFT that you’d see in your wallet. Haha.
- guelo 5y agoSo decentralized lol!
- martin_a 5y ago> would be a fun litmus test for these folks. I always thought the same about those companies who pose themselves as some "domain registration office" and tell me that they have a customers request to register $firstname$lastname.$tld but that they found out about me and would like to offer me the domain, because I'm $firstname $lastname obviously. What would keep me from registering a TLD by myself and then order them to do so? On the other hand: I already bought too many domains while being drunk, so I won't get deeper in to that.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> What would keep me from registering a TLD by myself and then order them to do so? Nothing's stopping that; you're just not the mark they're looking for. They're looking for people with little experience with domains who'll be told because of the other person's interest it's gonna cost $500 and you should act quick or forever lose it.
- pstuart 5y agoThere really should be a breathalizer requirement for domain purchases.
- Mezzie 5y agoI'm so glad this isn't just me.
- SilasX 5y agoYes! I don't if there's a name for it, but that's a technique for vetting potential frauds -- ask them to do something impossible and see their reaction. It's arguably what the British MP was doing when he asked Charles Babbage if the Difference Engine would still give the right answers when you put the wrong numbers in.
- memish 5y agoPirateBay would be a good test too. Can they get things removed from there?
- fyver 5y agoWell, IBM was able to remove Z/OS the TPB.
- rideontime 5y agoIt's actually pretty easy, you just have to DMCA the service the image is actually hosted on.