3 ms·
Why would you sue Google and not Lenovo? Google didn't promise you anything to begin with, the device manufacturer did.
by paxys 5y ago
Why would you sue Google and not Lenovo? Google didn't promise you anything to begin with, the device manufacturer did.
- fsckboy 5y agowhen you sue for damages, you sue the party who damaged you. if I throw a rock through your lenovo, you don't sue lenovo.
- paxys 5y agoGoogle didn't "damage" anyone by choosing to upgrade their OS. Lenovo was the one who made a promise at the time of the device sale, and now they are no longer abiding by it. Of course software features are taken away all the time, so that probably won't fly either.
- mdoms 5y ago
- InitialLastName 5y agoYou're getting downvoted because you turned aggressive, but you're also not looking at this in quite the way that the legal system might. When Lenovo sold a product that (presumably) depended on a service they had under contract (even if just a EULA) with Google, they made a promise of continued functionality to the user. Google changed the service, causing damages to the user, yes, but as Lenovo is the mediator of the exchange, the user sues Lenovo (for selling a device that stopped functioning) and then Lenovo sues Google (for the damages of them getting sued.
- drzaiusapelord 5y agoYep also you signed a hefty EULA with Lenovo allowing just this. Lenovo uses the google home software modified for its product. This is the same problem android phones have. Google moves on and OEMs don't bother to keep up. Or OEM's contract end and they don't want to pay to renew. These hit the market in 2018 so they were most likely licensed in 2017, so that 5 year just expired and now they can't use whatever google service anymore. That doesn't make it morally right, but legally, this isn't a case that's going to work out. If cases like this did work, the tech industry would collapse because every ambulance chaser would sue over any tiny software change.