4 ms·
I think the real question is what "usernames" will look like. There were hints dropped that this could be stronger than a typical username (like what HN has). I
by godelski 5y ago
I think the real question is what "usernames" will look like. There were hints dropped that this could be stronger than a typical username (like what HN has). I took a poll on reddit[0][1] to see what people wanted. I was rather surprised at how many wanted strong anonymity. I expected that the top choice would be the weak anonymity, where people just have an alternative to phone numbers. But I think if that's what Signal was rolling out then it would have been here already. So I hope they make anonymous communication available to everyone. I don't expect strong anonymity in the initial rollout, but I hope that is what they are working towards.
As I see it, there are three aspects to protected communication: privacy (no one sees what you're saying), anonymity (no one sees who's communication), and censorship prevention (no one can shut down communication). If we get strong anonymity in Signal then that is 2/3 and would be a great leap forward for free speech _everywhere_. I expect censorship prevention to be the hardest of these to tackle, even with decentralization.
[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/skoaf6/poll_why_do_you_want_usernames/ https://www.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/skoaf6/poll_why_do_...
[1] Yes, I realize there are issues with the poll. Polling is hard.
- gst 5y ago> I think the real question is what "usernames" will look like. There were hints dropped that this could be stronger than a typical username (like what HN has). Quite a bit of code related to usernames has already been checked into Signal. Here's the username regexp and the method that checks if a username is valid: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/blob/a5e5a735800cbdb3afa01a67390b6efa2fc91be6/app/src/main/java/org/thoughtcrime/securesms/util/UsernameUtil.java https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/blob/a5e5a735800...
- crossroadsguy 5y agoIt is unfortunate that they seem to be going for user created username. I’d rather have something like ~hkopy-vnhyt randomly generated and given to users with option to try for another randomly generated username if they didn’t like the first.
- Godel_unicode 5y agoNobody is stopping you from doing that for yourself.
- julianwachholz 5y agoWell the username "~hkopy-vnhyt" would be invalid because they only allow case insensitive a-z, digits and _ underscores. I can see some reasoning, but there's technically nothing stopping them from allowing more universal ASCII characters at the very least.
- godelski 5y agoYeah I'm a little upset about this. It is just set up for birthday problems. I'd be happy if it was you handing out a random string or 1-time code and then you pick a username per chat. But a global username identifier isn't anonymous (not any more than a phone number anyways) and I do not believe is a good solution.
- iqanq 5y agoSo choose an identifier that does not... identify you. Or choose not to have a username. I assume that that will be an option, since Telegram has it as well.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoNo, the problem your parent is referring to is that you have the same username in every chat. Discord really suffers from this.
- godelski 5y agoActually there are two main problems I'm referring to. You identified one of them. If I want to stay anonymous, I'm really asking how to compartmentalize chats and groups of people. We have different identities with different groups and use different names with them. The other problem is actually the act of sharing a username. If my username is "godelski" then yeah, I can share it on HN and Reddit where I use that username. But now I've deanonymized myself to friends and family who can see that username through Signal. Alternatively, if I have a username "not_godelski" then how do I get in contact with someone on HN while maintaining anonymity? If I use share it under this account then those two names are linked forever and that deanonymizes me. I can't create a new account just to share that name because those groups know me by that name. If I can have an infinite number of usernames, that solves the problem, but this isn't practical (even 5 usernames would be problematic and requires a lot of cognitive load, which is antithetical to Signal's philosophy). There's also a third problem I don't care as much about but I'd assume Signal does. And that's naming collisions. NYT has a Signal number that allows whistleblowers to contact them. What's stopping me from creating the username NYT_Whistleblower and becoming a honeypot? Edit: Lots of people are saying you can't share contact without revealing your identity. Does a 1-click link not solve this issue? If I post a signal.me/#one-time-code/jdjkerfe2r3rfwseffre5ge5g then I don't see how that would reveal my identity. (I'm also not a fan of "you can't". I can understand this being unsolved, but it feels like there are solutions to this problem)
- hndamien 5y agohttps://getsession.org/ https://getsession.org/ Already does all of these.
- godelski 5y agoI am under the impression that sessions only does #1 and does #2 with weak anonymity. Can you explain how it solves all 3?
- gnud 5y agoI clicked around a bit trying to find out who creates and runs Session. And of course it's built by someone pushing a new crypto currency. That made me really really sad.
- thristian 5y agoTo be fair, Signal is also built by somebody pushing a new crypto currency (although with Signal the app came first).
- emptysongglass 5y agoThat's because it's essential to providing incentives to the operators of the nodes where messages pass through. I know it's fashionable to hate on crypto because crypto but please try and see it from a utilitarian basis. Session has a lot of cool things going for it. They managed to solve the problems of P2P (high battery life number one) with these incentivised traffic passing nodes. They improved on TOR and you can already use the fruits of its invention for general traffic. The big problem as I see it is the team is all Australian. They'll need to find a way to pass stewardship to the community in time.
- hestefisk 5y agoThe site is down…
- clairity 5y agoi'd expect it to be much like imessages/facetime on apple products. it can use an email username or a telephone number. the telephone number predominates (because it also does sms/mms), but either can be used on any apple product.
- kelnos 5y agoI wouldn't expect that. A goal of allowing usernames will likely be to let people remain completely anonymous. Linking your Signal account to an email address doesn't work for that. Even if you create a throwaway email account somewhere, it'll often be traceable back to you somehow.
- godelski 5y ago> A goal of allowing usernames will likely be to let people remain completely anonymous > Even if you create a throwaway email account somewhere, it'll often be traceable back to you somehow. I'm surprised to hear you say this considering your completely opposite stance in response to a comment of mine. I don't see how a throwaway email is any less anonymous than a username. In fact, I see it as more anonymous since I can generate these on the fly whereas I can't do this with usernames.
- clairity 5y agoah yes, i didn't mean to imply an email address specifically, just that the other username would be mostly equivalent, if slightly inferior, to the phone number. i'm really glad that they're moving away from phone number as identity, and hopefully to fully anonymous, which they've rightly been criticized about up until this announcement.
- genewitch 5y agoWait, is the idea I can go to signal on some library computer and send a message to whoever I want anonymously? Because that's a pipe dream. First of all, you can't monetize it, and, unfortunately that is a non-starter. I can't see people throwing money at this, with the implications. Secondly, assume I want to contact the same anonymous person again. They have to somehow easily prove they have access to that username. Even 4chan had a mechanism for this. Assuming you don't shield your IP, or you move between locations between, at least the service knows that, and that isn't anonymous. A pre shared key off a one time pad only proves that someone has the same pad. I think anonymity isn't achievable. Secure is more important. I talk to someone a lot, I want that secure. I don't really care if anyone knows we're talking, just whether they know the content. Hosting your own metal somewhere helps with that. You'd obviously notice a warrant or whatever.
- frankfury 5y agoI'm really curious about how will the usernames pan out in the end