7 ms·
Unmasking Insubordination
- MikeTheGreat 5y agoI tried to visit the link but it timed out before anything showed up (is the link correct?) I flagged it b/c the link isn't working. If there's something else I should do instead let me know (at which point I'll happily un-flag it :) ) ETA: Ok, I've un-flagged it. Next time I'll check out archive.org or else just skip it. My thinking was that the article was so new here on HN (7 points, zero comment when I found it) that the problem must have been that the link was bad, not that the web server buckled under the load). C'est la vie :)
- jtbayly 5y agoYou should check it out on archive.org instead. Don’t flag sites just because Hacker News hugged them to death. (Edit: and if the archive.org link works, paste it here for others.)
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220207215914/https://mwi.usma.edu/unmasking-insubordination/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220207215914/https://mwi.usma.... as the site seems to be broken right now, for me at least.
- _Microft 5y agoThe link fails to load. Internet Archive to the rescue - here is a current capture: https://web.archive.org/web/20220207215914/https://mwi.usma.edu/unmasking-insubordination/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220207215914/https://mwi.usma....
- bryanrasmussen 5y agofeel sort of bad considering how quickly they went down, thanks for the archive link.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crackercrews 5y ago> The behaviors of soldiers who are resistant to a military order fall into one of four categories recently described by Eric Hundman: grudging obedience, refinement, exiting service, and defiance. What is refinement?
- alamortsubite 5y agoSome clarification from Eric Hundman's site: I argue that the interaction between brokerage and command centrism leads commanders to pursue four types of responses to orders they deem inappropriate: they can refine their orders, defy their orders, obey their orders, or exit their military roles. All brokers remain in their military roles in hopes of maintaining their brokerage-derived social power – command-centric brokers work with their superiors to refine and improve their orders; brokers who are not command centric defy their orders outright. Non-brokers who are not command centric feel little obligation to support their superiors and have little social power to lose by changing their social positions, so they respond to inappropriate orders by exiting their roles in the military. Non-brokers who are command centric, however, lack the power that might make them risk disobedience and, because they identify strongly with the command authority that issued their orders, they do not see exit as legitimate. They therefore simply obey. From http://www.erichundman.com/research http://www.erichundman.com/research
- Jtsummers 5y agoAnd from this article: > The philosophy and principles of mission command give subordinate leaders room to implement their superiors’ intent using disciplined initiative. This is the resistant behavior that Hundman characterizes as refinement. Leaders at lower echelons are best able to understand the practical ramifications of any policy implementation. General Mark Milley, the current chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, went so far as to say that subordinates needed to exercise “disciplined disobedience” and ignore specific orders to achieve their higher commanders’ intent. On the battlefield, this enables subordinate leaders to react to changing situations and take advantage of new opportunities as they arise, without needing to seek approval from their superiors. Historically the Army has made great use of mission command, enabling victories from the defense of Little Round Top to the thunder runs into Baghdad. [emphasis added]
- petermcneeley 5y agoVideo game tie in here. The term Fragging which is used in Unreal Tournament is actually a term that was coined in the Vietnam war. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fragging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fragging
- ineedasername 5y agoSome soldiers simply were settling grudges. Some felt that fragging, especially in the wake of particularly idiotic commands, could be an effective way to dissuade other superior officers from similar acts of stupidity or futile loss of life. Less violent methods of disobedience would include imaginative interpretations of an order.
- chrisco255 5y ago> Subordination is a key component to an effective military force. In order for commanders to maximize their units’ effectiveness on the battlefield, their subordinates must execute their orders fully and without delay. It's a leader's job to establish credibility and to protect morale in order to ensure that troops are responsive to commands. This article's focus on the soldier's insubordination rather than their own baseness is tone-deaf and lacks any sort of self reflection. It's clear that masking young, healthy adults who are tasked with the responsibility of rushing into oncoming bullets and missiles if need be, to mask themselves for going on now well into our third year of covid, which was never a particular threat for young people, is bad for morale. It's absurd and non-sensical. Meanwhile the dark tone set by the title and the subsequent remedies proposed make me more concerned than I've perhaps ever been about the direction our armed forces are under.
- Spooky23 5y agoA buddy was out on some punishment detail for a uniform violation — wearing a military issue fleece as a jacket, which is apparently controversial in some quarters. If dealing with clothing regulations that you dislike is a problem for you, the military is probably the wrong career choice. If you’re not going to perform a task that the average 2nd grader is able to comply with, why should we assume that you’ll run up that hill? In my non-military gig, we fired a bunch of people for this. It’s a stupid stand for freedom or whatever that was very expensive for those individuals.
- TheGigaChad 5y ago
- mpyne 5y ago> A buddy was out on some punishment detail for a uniform violation — wearing a military issue fleece as a jacket, which is apparently controversial in some quarters. Oh God I hope this isn't a problem, I've been using my fleece myself from time to time (though without the rank tab in this situation, to 'civilianize' it).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jlcoff 5y ago> It should not be a controversial statement to say that soldiers are expected to follow orders. Quite the opposite, a soldier duty, at least in the US is to protect not the Government, but the Constitution. If the government betrays the Constitution, it is the duty of the soldiers to disobey. At this point, civil war is upon us and history will be the final judge, not a military tribunal.
- mpyne 5y agoThat's why it's the job of soldiers to follow "lawful orders", not orders generically. On the other hand there is basically zero jurisprudence of a soldier ever getting in trouble for following an order they thought was given under competent military authority, even though it was illegal. So it can be hard for a soldier to rely on the mercy of the courts in this situation. Though that is still not justification for carrying out an illegal order.
- jlcoff 5y agoThe "law" itself may be unconstitutional.
- jlcoff 5y ago> On the other hand there is basically zero jurisprudence of a soldier ever getting in trouble for following an order they thought was given under competent military authority, even though it was illegal. Are you kidding me ? It was called the Nuremberg trials. Following orders has not been a valid defence ever since.
- mpyne 5y agoWere any U.S. soldiers tried at the Nuremberg trials? A comparable incident would be the My Lai massacre, after which 20+ soldiers and officers were tried of various charges, only 1 was convicted, and even that 1 soldier was promptly paroled by the President. Despite that, it is still theoretically possible to be tried and convicted of crimes despite having a military order to do so (and this was true even before Nuremberg). My point is that in practice having an order to do something counts for a great deal.
- throwaway22032 5y agoThere are so many interesting questions here and the author seems to have a laser-like focus on the material fact that he feels insubordination has occured and that this is a problem, which doesn't really require more than a sentence or so of explanation. For example, in training, why is it that the soldiers agree to polish their boots, iron their uniforms etcetera - e.g. generally perform a ton of ancillary tasks to the actual job? I don't think it's solely because someone said so. There's a level of respect for the ritual that comes from somewhere. Like, they might think that today they can't be arsed with polishing the boots, but that it's a point of pride to do it. Or there's a competitive aspect with the others. Maybe it actually is just because the commander will bark at them otherwise - but that just cycles around to the motivation to the commander. Once you figure that out, does that illustrate that there's something unique about mask wearing? Like, you have this empirical data that soldiers will literally run into a battlefield and dodge landmines and all the rest of it, you've created a framework in which that's an order they'll obey. I dunno, it feels like the article is really light on the "whys". The thing your mental model told you should happen is not happening - so try to understand it? Try to figure out why people don't want to do this thing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lazide 5y agoRecruits do what they are told because they have been conditioned to do it - it’s the purpose of boot camp, it’s the purpose of drill Sargents, it’s the purpose of the ritual and culture of the military. If they lose that conditioning or fail to comply, there are many negative consequences for them. From minor things like being passed over for promotion, to jail. When you become familiar with, and have experience with people and what combat operations actually entails, it becomes obvious why this is the case, and why it is necessary. Soldiers who do not follow orders, even sometimes nonsensical ones, die or get others killed. Sometimes everyone. It is impossible and unwise to explain the needs and situation behind every order in a combat situation. Even if there was no leaks, assuming every grunt will have the capacity and meta awareness of the situation to process it correctly and not get confused just doesn’t work. It also opens up reinterpreting orders in ways that have unexpected consequences and end up breaking larger unit movements that depend on specific side effects and actions. It also has negative side effects of course - inefficiencies, difficulty adjusting to changing circumstances, opportunities for corruption and abuse. Blind obedience is a double edged sword, for the same reason our brain generally has mechanisms to shy away from us chopping our own hand off. You don’t want that. But you need to ensure that orders are followed when it matters, or you don’t have a military, you have a social club with tanks.
- cat_plus_plus 5y ago[flagged]
- josephcsible 5y ago> How to wear and use masks is taught to every servicemember within weeks of joining the military. Therefore, any argument questioning the legality of an order to wear masks is ridiculous. How to strip-search people is taught to every TSA agent. Would any argument questioning the legality of an order to strip-search every single traveler be ridiculous too?
- yuliyp 5y agoThe author of the article is talking about specifically actions occurring fully within the confines of how members of the military carry out their duties. A superior officer can order one of the soldiers in their unit to guard something. They can order them to carry a rifle while doing so, and can order them to do it wearing a mask. Asking that soldier to force someone not in the military to wear a mask or undergo a strip search may be illegal (I honestly am not sure and it's a moot point to this discussion). TSA agents are not members of the military, though. They are employees of the TSA, and the relationship is not bound by the Uniform Code of Military Justice, but to an employment contract and normal civilian laws around labor.
- josephcsible 5y agoI think you got too focused on the details of my analogy and ignored the point of it: just because everyone gets taught how to do something, doesn't necessarily mean that thing is okay to always do.
- yuliyp 5y agoI think the point of the "taught" point in the article was to reinforce that mask wearing was not a novel question in the context of "is this an order that a military officer can give to a subordinate?", nothing more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eyelidlessness 5y ago
- joelbondurant1 5y ago
- fargle 5y agothe solution to author's condundrum is twofold: "soldiers who are resistant to a military order fall into one of four categories recently described by Eric Hundman: grudging obedience, refinement, exiting service, and defiance." But I'd say not masking is more "grudging obedience" not "defiance". It's minor, and easily correctable if challenged. They start court-martialing for a single mask violation, then it starts to look like defiance. But if the structure from top to bottom "accepts" that non-masking is context-sensitively and accepted (sometimes), not adhering to the "letter of the law" is just skating by or cheesing-it. Not open defiance. Yeah, that sounds a LOT like the real military. To me this means the issue there is the chain of command. Look, it's either a serious issue or it isn't. If you send mixed signals, then what do you expect? The second thing is that, in the real world, orders can't be "stupid". If your orders are to run into a machine gun nest and certainly die but as a hero for the greater, etc. even that can work. See that ain't stupid - that just sucks for you. But if it's stupid you are saying - do this for no reason because bureaucratic stupid, stupid. And you are going to get at best grudging acceptance. I'm not saying it's actually stupid. I'm saying the behavior of all ranks indicates they "think" and act as if it was thought "stupid". I mean, when you are young and healthy and a war-fighter - do you really think that "useless" masking to avoid a "minor flu-like" virus might not just seem "stupid". To be clear, I'm not saying it is stupid or is just the flu or whatever. But it's clear to me that a bunch of military and first-responders that have a very different risk posture might very well be just thinking along those lines and they act as such. They aren't acting stupidly or randomly. There's a reason that there is such blowback.