3 ms·
The Federal Reserve Is About to Give US Workers the Shaft
- akeck 5y agoI have this non-scientific intuition that interest rates should generally be slightly above the dividend payment rate of the S&P 500 (or maybe Russell 2K). That way there's less of a clear choice between equities, bonds, and other assets.
- csense 5y agoYou have the right idea, but the wrong direction. In theory, interest rate on government debt should be slightly below dividend payments of equity (stocks of private companies). That's because the dividends are more risky, so investors demand a higher yield. If interest rates on government debt go up, then people should, in theory, sell some of their stocks and buy government bonds. Think of it this way, if there is (in your words) "a clear choice between equities [and] bonds", then people will sell whichever one is less desirable and buy whichever one is more desirable. This will make the less desirable asset cheaper and the more desirable asset more expensive, and this process will continue until you reach a market equilibrium where investors as a whole are indifferent between stocks and bonds.
- akeck 5y agoThanks so much for the explanation! TIL
- mikece 5y agoAs if screwing our buying power through inflation wasn't bad enough: now we get higher interests rates? Are they trying to crash things?
- uejfiweun 5y agoI feel like a crash would be a good thing for workers though? I mean pretty much nobody will ever be able to buy a house unless there's a major asset price crash.
- xxpor 5y agoSure, if your only expense in life is buying a house.
- quantified 5y agoIf it’s not the biggest, you have attained a measure of wealth, good on you.
- xxpor 5y agoPractically speaking for most people, the effect that buying a home has is replacing their rent payment with a monthly mortgage payment. While it's still probably the single largest payment made in a month, it's (hopefully) not a majority of your income, or even spending. Plenty of folks pay more for say, child care now.
- quantified 5y agoPer month, perhaps. Over 30 years? Everyone’s got their own equations, if I paid for the house all cash, of course. If I have one kid, and only 10% down on a $2mm house, gotta really pamper the kid to catch up
- xxpor 5y agoUnironically yes. But the point is the crash will bring down inflation. Some bank last week estimated that to get to 2% inflation would require 10% unemployment though. I'm skeptical of Phillips curve arguments, but even if that's remotely true it would be a complete disaster.
- tylerhou 5y agoHigher interest rates reduce the money supply and generally slow inflation. So if you don't like inflation, you should support higher interest rates.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis rate adjustment was arguably overdue. People always complain about rising rates, but the alternative is prices spiraling upwards even further and an even harsher corrective move down the road. To be sure, good fiscal discipline from the government could also help avoid spikes in bond rates.
- say_it_as_it_is 5y agoPrices haven't risen because of wages. They rose because business owners know to not let any good crisis go to waste. Businesses blame Covid. They blame supply chains. They blame wage increases. Lo and behold, YoY financial performance indicates recording-breaking rise in profits. Give the shareholders a bonus!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jeema101 5y agoHe seems to be admitting that inflation is high, and yet saying we should do nothing. This is precisely what was said by policymakers in the early 1970s who were saying pretty much the same thing back then: we can't act on inflation because it will hurt the labor market. This of course resulted in inflation becoming more and more firmly entrenched until their WAS a wage-price spiral that was very hard to break. It then look the new Federal Reserve chairman more than a decade of trying to get it under control, and ultimately, it was only done through sky-high interest rates that caused 2 bad recessions. Most of that pain could have been avoided had they just acted more decisively in the early 70s. And now here we are again decades later with the worst inflation in 40 years and some people saying we should just 'let it ride and see what happens'! Well we already know what happens if history is any indication.
- mattbrewsbytes 5y agoDo other countries economies experience these cycles in this repetitive fashion? It feels like the US correction/recession/crash cycle keeps going even though they (media, Fed?) call it different things or blame different things each time. If this was happening to say a build/deploy system for software and it kept having crashes/halts on some interval I would want to find root causes. I am no economist but it seems like a root cause analysis is in order of the whole system. I know you can’t just stop the economy and look at log files to figure it out, but there aren’t even conversations about it, like you said “let it ride and see what happens”.
- nine_k 5y agoThe US can basically print money, because USD is the world reserve currency (most of the world, that is). This puts the US in unique position when it can inject massive amounts of liquidity into the economy, and nothing bad is apparently happening for years! The world happily buys dollars. Then the consequences still catch up and bite, but it's already a different administration. So the temptation is high.
- ericmay 5y ago