5 ms·
Why would supposedly secure communicator use actual phone number as identifier is beyond me. And everybody does that, either phone number or email. The only s
by scotty79 5y ago
Why would supposedly secure communicator use actual phone number as identifier is beyond me.
And everybody does that, either phone number or email.
The only software I could find for anonymous communication was old Polish communicator http://gg.pl http://gg.pl which uses arbitrary numbers as identifiers
I understand that startups are scared that they won't be able to build up userbase from scratch but come on! Discord and Slack did it.
- palata 5y agoTwo words: threat model.
- scotty79 5y agoI don't get it. I find my interlocutor knowing my phone number a severe threat to my privacy.
- bt1a 5y agoSure - that's why Signal is for secure communication between individuals who have some level of trust. There's nothing stopping your interlocutor from leaking all of the messages you send to them, what's the big issue with them having your number?
- scotty79 5y ago> Sure - that's why Signal is for secure communication between individuals who have some level of trust. If I have this level of trust with someone they are about at level of adding them as a friend on Facebook. Who knows, I even might invite them on Facebook sooner than I decide to give them my phone number. > what's the big issue with them having your number? Seriously? With my number you can harass me endlessly with phonecalls, text messagers, registering for various services that will harass me basically forcing me to abandon this phone number and notify all of my valuable contacts of the number change. Hell, they might even plaster town with my number with advert saying "Win 50$ in Chewbaca noise contest by subitting your best attempt at that number." as one creative asshole did to some poor girl. > There's nothing stopping your interlocutor from leaking all of the messages you send to them That way less of a problem if I haven't doxed myself in those conversations. All he will publish is some conversations he had with someone.
- austhrow743 5y ago>If I have this level of trust with someone they are about at level of adding them as a friend on Facebook. Yes that's exactly what Signal is for. Talking to people you would otherwise talk to on facebook messenger but you rather not have facebook engineers be able to read your personal conversations.
- lmm 5y agoThe fact that my number is registered to my legal identity? In my country, and I think in most countries, it's not legal to sell a SIM without checking and recording the buyer's legal ID.
- godelski 5y agoYou're confusing privacy with anonymity. Privacy is people not being able to read what you are writing. Anonymity is being... anonymous, unknown. Signal is keeping your conversations private but they are not keeping your account anonymous.
- scotty79 5y agoMy anonimity is huge contributing factor to my sense of privacy. I don't care if you seen my dick if you have no way of knowing it was mine.
- godelski 5y agoI think the question of how to be anonymous is quite hard though. I wouldn't exactly call our usernames here anonymous.
- tomcooks 5y agoYou chose your username here and in most other places. You can even change it easily on many platforms. Your username doesn't require you to show your ID and have your calls tapped and traced towards your person. Do you want me to continue?
- godelski 5y ago> Do you want me to continue? Yes actually. The problem I'm seeing here with the responses is that people are only thinking of "one move." That first move is creating a anonymous username. Yay. Easy. Now here's the problem. How do I share that while staying anonymous? What conditions do I need? If I can only have one username for all of Signal, does that create a bigger problem? There's a few more "moves" for you and these are what I'm looking for answers to.
- palata 5y agoMaybe you do, yes. And maybe you're happy with an alternative with usernames where the server keeps the list of your contacts. Or maybe you are not, and you will want an alternative where you need to rebuild your contacts list every time you install the app. But some people are happy messaging people based on the phone number, because everything else is too cumbersome. Different people have different threat models, and one chooses the best UX for their threat model. For millions of people (maybe not you), apparently it is Signal.
- pomian 5y agoThat looks like a great app. Thanks. Can you send SMS to a regular number with this?
- scotty79 5y agoI'm not sure if it's great. It just lets you communicate without endangering valuable resource that your phone number is. > Can you send SMS to a regular number with this? Why would it do that? Every phone has perfectly good sms app. What would that even mean? Using sms as a transport layer? Or making messages passed through internet look like pseudo sms messages to someones phone number?
- mburns 5y agoFWIW, Signal can send SMS to a regular number on Android. https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007321171-Can-I-send-SMS-MMS-with-Signal-#android_sms https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007321171-Ca...
- pomian 5y agoThanks for the reminder. The idea was to use signal with a degoogled phone. It would be great if signal could send SMS without the cell network. There are places and devices, without cell connections.
- int_19h 5y agoIt's the network itself that is limiting this, since SMS was designed for intra-network communication - so the sender needs some kind of network ID. Something like Google Fi can provide a web-based client for your SMS (which works on any device and doesn't require cellular) because they know your virtual SIM and can emulate it as needed. But I don't see how Signal could pull that off.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- raspyberr 5y agoSignal started off as a secure SMS replacement. Also, they mainly used numbers so they could leverage the social graph of phone contact lists. That way they didn't need to store any social graphs on their systems.
- scotty79 5y agoThey must store something to route messages. Graph of random numbers is even better than the graph of actual numbers. They just wanted to piggyback on already existing network of people contacts. Standard startup "growth hack".
- godelski 5y ago> Graph of random numbers is even better than the graph of actual numbers. ,,To Signal'' it is a graph of random numbers.
- byhemechi 5y agoSignal originally send messages via SMS. The hosted version using phone numbers is a carryover from that transition.
- pseudalopex 5y agoThey said it was to piggy back on people's contacts too.
- odjebioff 5y agoTry Threema then, they don’t require email nor phone
- crossroadsguy 5y agoOne fundamental problem with messaging apps is that you need other people you want to connect to to be using that app. Decentralisation and all that - again, other people.
- brewdad 5y agoThis was why I started using Signal in the first place. I could replace my SMS app with Signal and immediately gain the advantages it offers for my friends that were also on it or willing to switch. Over time, more have switched to it and the network grows but I don't miss out with those who won't switch for whatever reason.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y ago> Why would supposedly secure communicator use actual phone number as identifier is beyond me. It's pretty simple - user friendliness and sign-up friction. Signal's main market is not us HN user tech bros who want (pseudo)anonymity. It's main market is closer to regular people, the same people who are fine with using WhatsApp or Facebook messenger or whatever, with their phone number. They also want it to be as easy as possible for new users to sign up. Simply enter your phone number and boom you have a signal account. With email the sign up process is not insanely difficult - but its still more steps than phone signup for the regular person.
- jabbany 5y agoDoesn't explain why _only_ phone numbers are (currently) supported. Having phone numbers as the default or even asking permission to import your contacts would have been fine-ish if it was also possible to register using another anonymous method like email... One counterpoint to using phone numbers: In China mobile phone numbers are almost universally enforced as your digital identifier because it makes surveillance extremely easy for a government while making it relatively hard for platforms themselves. Registering for a phone number mandates an ID check at the point of the service provider. This means that with a phone number based login, (1) you can be largely anonymous to platforms as you can have > 1 phone number, (2) you have 2fa built in automatically, but also (3) that the government can easily figure out who owns what accounts because your accounts are directly linked to your phone(s) and your phone(s) directly to you. It would be a great step forward if Signal moves towards alternate verifications that don't involve phone numbers...
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoAh GG - your number with them used to be just as important as your phone number in Poland. I remember looking into this a few years back and the only issue I found was that the company that owns it now itself wasn’t entirely trustworthy.
- shp0ngle 5y agoIt's kind of easy - spam. Spam protection is hard. Forcing to use phone numbers is a "easy" protection against spam. It's harder to get thousands of SIMs than thousands of usernames.
- zaik 5y agoXMPP, IRC, Jami, Matrix, Tox and probably several others too also don't require email or phone number.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoKeybase got it right before Zoom acquired them. They decoupled identities from your account data. Basically they allowed you to claim identities via a dozen or so different things they supported (email, phone, twitter, github, domain names, public pgp keys, etc.), and then prove that you owned it by posting some token, sending a message,. Which would then associate the identity with the account. The more identities you claimed, the stronger the proof that you were you. Taking a new device into use was as simple as authorizing it from one of your existing devices. All the data would sync over and be encrypted with a device specific key locally. And you could disable that key from any of the other devices. Too bad that company more or less failed. They never really figured out a business and the zoom acquisition looked more like an acquihire than a long term commitment to the product. But it's a good design that is worth copying.
- Hakashiro 5y agoThreema allows phone number, email, both, or neither and just a random PIN like BBM
- arepublicadoceu 5y ago> I understand that startups are scared that they won't be able to build up userbase from scratch but come on! Discord and Slack did it. I don’t use slack but the few times I tried to use discord it always said something suspicious was going on and asked me for my email (needless to say I immediately closed the window) I wasn’t using vpn, only my default ublock and Firefox built in track blocking.
- grishka 5y agoEmail is okay to me because you can actually own one. Phone numbers though are terrible because they're tied to countries, their security depends only on your carrier, you can't run your own carrier to take it into your own hands, and sending SMS costs money. Also the underlying interconnection networks like SS7 aren't secure at all and rely on trust.
- quesera 5y agoUnfortunately, you do not own your email address either. TLDs are managed by governments or government-adjacent organizations. Domains are managed by the TLD manager. Email addresses are managed by the domain manager. I've never had a phone number or a domain name taken from me, but I've heard of more cases of the latter than of the former.
- grishka 5y agoThere are now those custom TLDs that are not managed by a government-related organization. Your domain is managed by whoever you registered it at. You can transfer your domain between registrars too. Your email address is managed by you because you control the domain. You can use someone else's email service with your domain, or you can host your own. You can switch between one and the other without anyone noticing. I've heard stories of how a US carrier issued a replacement sim card to a fraudster. I've also heard stories of how a Russian carrier intercepted someone's SMS messages to break into their Telegram account.
- quesera 5y agoBut unless you operate the TLD, you do not "own" your email address. Donuts can choose to cancel your domain registration, or to hand it to someone with a more compelling trademark claim, etc. Legal niceties vary by jurisdiction, but at the end of the day you "own" nothing but a contract where you are the subordinate party. SIM swapping is a big problem, but that is more equivalent to DNS hijacking of your domain than to the concept of legal/contractual "ownership" or rights to operation. But semantics aside, the important question is how easy would it be for a malfeasant to interfere with your quiet enjoyment of your public identifier (phone number or email address). SIM swapping is way too easy. Domain hijacking isn't hard either, and sometimes one attack can leverage the other.
- hackernewds 5y agoAren't Slack and Discord also tied to your email? I think HN and Reddit are better examples (although some dark patterns do push you towards associating with your email)