3 ms·
"In Scotland, there is at least one sheep, at least one side of which appears to be black from here some of the time." It would be practically impossible in th
by tialaramex 5y ago
"In Scotland, there is at least one sheep, at least one side of which appears to be black from here some of the time."
It would be practically impossible in the 1940s to have faked the photographs but it's not difficult at all to misrepresent what they are photographs of, the circumstances in which they were taken, and how they came to be available.
Facts are true, and we should rightly ridicule people who insist otherwise, but the interpretation of those facts is subtle and subject to much mischief.
Most of the WW2 photographs I've spent time looking at were subject to an altogether more scientific consideration of this problem. They're aerial reconnaissance photos, so, hopefully they're pictures of something the enemy doesn't want you to know about, captured at great risk by expert pilots in unarmed aeroplanes (a camera plus film goes where the guns would otherwise fit in the plane). But in this case the answer to the question "What is actually captured in this photograph?" is known only to the enemy who've no intention of telling you, so you have to guess and you'd better guess right.
For example, suppose you've never seen a modern rocket. You've seen the powder-filled devices of course - still popular today as fireworks and sometimes for simple amateur rocketry (for beginners or children) but never a liquid fuelled rocket. Now, somebody shows you a photo with scale of a prototype German V-2 rocket and they propose this is a rocket, one of Hitler's vengeance weapons, with a range of perhaps 200 miles. It'd be so fast you can't hope to intercept or avoid it, once launched it is unstoppable. We must do everything possible to destroy them first, right? But on the other hand, whoever heard of a rocket with such ludicrous range - maybe it's a hoax, intended to do nothing more than divert Allied bombing away from valuable fuel and real military targets...
- jimnotgym 5y ago> (a camera plus film goes where the guns would otherwise fit in the plane) I don't think that is necessarily true. I think the guns and ammunition were very heavy so removing them allowed you to fly faster and further. I don't think say a PR spitfire had cameras in the wings where the guns normally were, I think it was in the fuselage behind the pilots seat so always looking down at the ground.
- tialaramex 5y agoGood point. I know that during WW2 there was a lot of innovation in this area, and indeed this article suggests a lot changes over those few year but yes, you're right I was incorrect to suggest that you'd rip out the guns from an existing fighter in order to fit cameras in the reclaimed space, the recon planes don't have guns for weight reasons and also to emphasise their mission purpose, if your plane doesn't have any guns you won't go looking for fights. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aerial_reconnaissance_in_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aerial_reconnaissance_in_World...