3 ms·
There's a weird intersection of nationalism and personality where folks behave as if they're almost one and the same. Any criticism toward a nation's actions i
by duxup 5y ago
There's a weird intersection of nationalism and personality where folks behave as if they're almost one and the same. Any criticism toward a nation's actions is a personal attack by default it seems.
I've got strong feelings about China's leadership, it has almost nothing to do with the locals.
- platinumrad 5y ago"It has almost nothing to do with the locals" so why was there a poster depicting an ordinary athlete throwing a virus at the viewer? Tell me what this accomplishes aside from associating the pandemic (which is widely hated for obvious reasons) with a random chinese person? Funny how the downvotes keep on coming in but nobody is shameless enough to defend it.
- Freak_NL 5y agoUsing the image of a person in a cartoon to represent a state actor (especially when adorned with symbols strongly associated with that state such as a Pickelhaube for Prussia, or in this case simply a national flag) is one of the oldest forms of political commentary. You can see it in the political cartoons of most major newspapers.
- platinumrad 5y ago1. There is a huge difference between an athlete, who is an ordinary citizen, and a soldier, who deploys violence on behalf of the state. 2. This isn't going to be popular, but a lot of anti-Prussian propaganda was racist. (And if you're about to say "ackshully, Prussian isn't a race" please consider that the colloquial usage of "racism" encompasses a number of other prejudices and those prejudices aren't suddenly excusable because they aren't technically based on your definition of "race.")
- bllguo 5y agoI read this as "western political cartoons have a proud tradition of racist imagery," which is not a very convincing rebuttal
- chrischen 5y agoIf the locals associate with China’s leadership and you are against China’s leadership, then you are effectively against the locals…
- duxup 5y ago> associate with China’s leadership What does that mean?
- Wiseacre 5y agoActually deciding to become a member of the Chinese communist party versus just being a Chinese citizen?
- wolverine876 5y agoIf membership is necessary for you or your family to get ahead, for your kids to get a good education, etc., it might not signal support of the CCP.
- duxup 5y agoIf I'm expressing some disagreement about policy and the Chinese government I'm probably not counting who is or isn't a party member. And at least generally just being a party member of a party anywhere doesn't mean any individual always agrees with every policy, and I certainly don't assume they get to make policy.
- skeeter2020 5y agoExactly, but America's probably not a great market to sell this sort of distinction.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoReally? I don't think I've met a single american who seems happy with their government, no matter which way they lean or which colour tie the president has. But I've still met a lot of proud Americans. Which nation do you think this sort of distinction might be better sold in?
- asow92 5y agoWe still get called racist when we try to bring up this distinction.