At first my reaction to your comment was "wait, what was so amazing in so many ways? If it's not a good fit it's not a good fit". But thinking another minute..

At first my reaction to your comment was "wait, what was so amazing in so many ways? If it's not a good fit it's not a good fit". But thinking another minute... "The people were phenomenal" -- okay that is actually HUGE. It's much rarer than you might think, in my experience, to find a place to work where where most everyone is good at their jobs, motivated, friendly, and just generally great to work with. Giving that up is actually a pretty big risk.