3 ms·
> we <must> ask algorithm questions to ensure engineers can think properly I thought that described today's interviewing zeitgeist, pretty well. In my experien
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
> we <must> ask algorithm questions to ensure engineers can think properly
I thought that described today's interviewing zeitgeist, pretty well. In my experience, absolutely no one even glanced at the dozens of open-source repos (for finished, documented, tested products), or the hundreds of pages of writing I have amassed, over the years, which ahem, are actual artifacts of lots of my "proper" thinking.
I've only practiced a few Codility exercises, a few years ago, when I was still interested in working with someone else. Otherwise, I never practice leetcode. As I am quite aware that many, many people practice these types of things, for hours every day (I strongly suspect while being paid by their current employers), I just consider that a wash.
If this is a requirement, then I'll never get hired, and I might as well give up (I can actually do reasonably well, at these kinds of things -mostly-, as they are usually basic commonsense exercises, but I won't ever have the rote efficiency of a practiced leetcoder).
Since I don't actually need the work, I accepted that this is just the way things are, and withdrew from consideration.
Too bad. I suspect that some companies that I would have enjoyed working at, and that I could have been a valuable IC at, are maybe having to deal with less-than-ideal workers.
- ushakov 5y agoi feel you Chris, you have actual case studies, projects to show, so much you could talk about people who practice leetcode are either unemployed or too desperate to get a job employers who do this have bad hiring practices and bad attitude my personal advice: get work from people you know, beggars can't be choosers
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> or too desperate to get a job I wouldn't necessarily say this. Since it is "how things are done," these days, I strongly suspect that folks want every competitive advantage they can get, and it's perfectly understandable. It's just that it's an extremely 1-dimensional way of evaluating people that are supposed to be creative and intelligent. It doesn't actually tell you anything about them; just that they are good at practicing rote (which, to be fair, may be exactly what a corporation is looking for). I am very fortunate. I spent my life, living frugally, and investing carefully, so I have the ability to step back. I know that very few people have this capability. A career is a really big deal, and worth it to prepare for. The problem is that over thirty years of shipping software is not something that is easy to express in a few scholastic tests. It's something that can sometimes be easily demonstrated, but consuming and evaluating it is time-consuming. I have spent a lot more time, preparing my portfolio, than lots of folks have spent at leetcode. If that's not valuable to a company, then, c'est la vie.
- Dave3of5 5y agoYip pretty much the same for me. I done one hacker rank on my last round of interviews and it absolutely killed my confidence. It was 5 questions automatically timed to 15 minutes. So in terms of completing it you really need to have seen these types of questions before as they left no "thinking" time only time to type up the solution and a short debug. I got 3.5 of the questions finished in that time so I'm going to be working on my speed for the next time. Like you I think it's kinda sad given that the people who promote this style of interview say is so that they can assess how you "think" or "approach" a programming problem. The reality is that it's a hazing ritual, they are looking for you to have seen the type of question before memorise how to solve it and instantly start applying that in the interview. I'd note that overly strict interviews often cause companies to not be able to hire efficiently and effectively which the very same companies will complain loudly about. Companies I've worked for rejected almost all candidates and still complained they couldn't hire anyone.